Restaurants in Sun Prairie

“We love bringing out of town friends to Sal's. We had the Valentine's menu and it was the best food we've had in years! Tameka was amazing and the food came out so quick. Clean plates all day!”

“Everything is delicious. Real, tender, moist, smoked bbq with loads of flavor that is enhanced with their selection of sauces. Coming from a southerner, this is the real deal and all the guys are great. The only thing missing is some goulash but I recognize that it’s not likely to be a seller.”

“Great menu options and our waiter Jim was one of nicest and attentive people. I will certainly be back.”

“First time dining here. Great food and atmosphere. On a side note… To a beautiful lady. You were the beautiful woman dining—maybe with your mom—at “a restaurant by the river”. We locked eyes, shared a smile, and you held the door for me as we walked out. I wanted to introduce myself but got a little nervous. When you turned around after walking away, I knew I missed my chance. If you see this, I’d love a second one.”

“Amazing! Stopped in for the first time and had lunch this week. Great food, will be back for sure.”

“Great local hang for friendly and local vibes. Still feeling out the menu but what I had was delish. Could be the start of something special. We'll have to return again to find out.”

“What a great little hidden gem! Great drinks, gourmet food, amazing staff and we even got to meet the owner, Steve! Very friendly atmosphere. We will definitely be back!!”

“Excellent burgers and fresh cut fries. Topping choices are numerous, even including green chillies. The Mooyah sauce is like Big Mac sauce, and is very good if you like that. Evan Case did a great job with our split order, waiting to prepare the to-go part of the order until we were about finished with our dine-in food.”

“We were absolutely blown away by our meal tonight! Our waitress, Julie, was the sweetest and most attentive person you could ever ask for. She immediately made us smile and laugh. The flavors in everything we tried were exceptional! The housemade hummus was absolutely delicious, we wanted to lick the plate clean. The lentil soup was superb. We got the (huge) entrees of kebabs and shawarma. The tumeric rice was incredibly flavorful, the garnishes were even a pleasant surprise, the meats were all seasoned differently and were all phenomenal. Everything was amazing. We will be back soon!”

“I recommend Anna Pizza if your in the area. I myself have problems with my stomach and have to be on a KETO DIET and I order a very thin crust. I may not eat the crust but there topping and cheese are so delicious and good and they don't bother my tummy either. I think it's because they must use real or high quality products. I love there Pizza. I myself give them 5 stars.”

“BEST PIZZA I have ever had! They have great burgers soup, salads, appetizers and pastas too. Definitely coming back.”

“This is a really nice local restaurant. Got a nice big eating area for your whole family. You can tell the food is definitely homemade and it tastes amazing. I would just recommend being patient to ask there is a little bit of a service delay due to not having a lot of staff members. I have no complaints, I really enjoyed eating here with my mom. We frequently order takeout as well.”

“The drinks and macaroons are great but don’t skip out on the food! They have a chalkboard up to the right of the register. I assume it changes because it has some items that are not on the online menu. I had the red curry noodles with chicken. It was delicious and tasty.”

“the chicken dinners in the tiramisu”

“Love your ideals. Do not cave.”

“The nicest people there. I dropped my cookies right outside and there were two workers who saw and they said they would replace the cookies that fell. They didn’t have to do that, but I am so grateful they did though. So shoutout to the two people that were working that day on Saturday at 2:10 pm, you guys have my heart. 🥹💗”

“I got the cinnamon roll was very tasty! But if looking for croissants I’d recommend going after 10 am I was really looking forward to it but after waiting still wasn’t available and was told about 30 mins when I got there ! But it’s a very quiet place for those who want coffee, good grilled cheese as I overheard costumers talking about how good their sandwich was!”

“If you’re looking for a place filled with warmth, kindness, and absolutely amazing drinks, look no further! ☕️✨ The quality here is unmatched — every drink is made with care, and you can truly taste the love in every sip. And then there’s Chris… the sweetest owner you’ll ever meet. Her mission, her heart for people, and her gift for creating a welcoming space make this coffeehouse something truly special. This place is more than a business — it’s a blessing. God truly works through this place and through Chris. Her grace, understanding, and pure kindness shine through everything she does, and you can feel it the moment you walk in. So grateful for this amazing spot and the beautiful community it nurtures. 💛✨ Highly recommend stopping by — your heart and your taste buds will thank you!”

“I love the breakfast here. I was some what disappointed with our service today though. The young lady that helped us didn't serve our drinks until after she had brought our food out. By the time she made our drinks our food was cold. Usually we have excellent service. I hope this was just an off day.”

“Great shop, owner and staff very pleasant. Drinks were great! Limited food menu. Definitely recommend!”

“First time eating here and have to leave a review. We waited about 35 minutes since it was busy, but it was worth the wait! We ordered the pretzel with beer cheese and mustard, the beer cheese had a nice kick to it. Also ordered a single smash burger which was one of the best I’ve had and bun was really moist. Got the shroomer pizza to share and although it was thin it was still stretchy and very good, no complaints! We will be back”

“Absolutely one of the best places if you want a great coffee beverage and great customer service!! Highly highly recommend the Jamaican Road Warrior.❤️❤️ A fabulous way to start your day!”

“the best chicken wings around . period. mmmmmmm”

“Very friendly and welcoming to new customers like me!!”

“I would like to give a huge shout out to Varsity Bar and Grill! We kicked off Rachel's 40th Birthday Party at Varsity on Saturday. The food was oh so delicious, the service over the top exceptional, friendly and welcoming. Varsity is everything you could ask for in a small town bar and grill. Thank you to Tony, Ben, Lyle, Jeff and all at Varsity who helped make the party a success! We'll be back!!!”

“We very much enjoyed our meal 4-2025 I'd go there again.”

“They take the ceremony out of the wine and have a laugh with you. What a great nook to chat, sit with a glass and laugh. What a welcoming staff!!”

“This is the best Mexican restaurant we've found in the Madison area, especially the margheritas. We live in Fitchburg and will be making the trip over here frequently!”

“The food is always great but the service and warm welcome we get from our server Shana is what keeps us coming back all the time”

“Best iced latte ever! Oh, and the maple scone made my taste buds so very happy! Wonderful, friendly staff topped off an excellent experience I'll repeat soon.”

“Stopped in for a slice. Great customer service great price for good ol zaaa”

“We got our daughter’s 11th bday cake from Crumb en Croute! Firstly, it was ADORABLE! And exactly what we asked for! And then when we ate it, Yummy 😋!!! It was so good!! We will be using them again!!! Thanks for making our daughter’s day!!!”

“I have always liked pizza from Rocky's. Even more so that you can get a slice quickly, eat it and get back to what you were doing. The breadsticks also are very good so as far as a quick pizza place this does a good job.

The staff member that we encountered was not super friendly and did seem as if she would have rather have no one show up.

Overall the food was good and we needed something quick. This was both of those things.”

“The chicken and potatoes were delicious! The salad bar is amazing! Pizza is awesome and dessert cookie pizza is delicious!! Pizza ranch certainly is “all that” and then some”

“Great food, huge adult drinks nice family friendly enviorment.”

“Great service and friendly environment!”

“Used to go here a lot on Monday's after golfing in Columbus. No longer open on Monday (sad face). Good fried frozen munchies and pizza. No grill, so no burgers that I am aware of. Nice country bar. If you are in the area, stop in.”

“Great food, drinks, and service. Jorge has always treated me right here!”

“Visited Monks on Father's day great food a special mention of a young man Maddox, a hostess. He was respectful and friendly and it was a very enjoyable time”

“I have only visited the Sun Prairie location since October 2023. My go-to is the breakfast sandwich and my son, who is very particular about his French Toast, says it's his absolute favorite. I'm not a coffee drinker but their Chai is my favorite when I'm out and about. Don't forget to ask for the cheesy potatoes!”

“★☆☆☆☆ – Consistently Disappointing Experience Disappointment every single time — whether dining in or ordering delivery. The food quality is consistently poor, and any time you try to offer constructive feedback, the owner, Adam, becomes defensive and dismissive. Instead of addressing concerns, he’ll tell you that you “don’t know what you’re talking about” and promise to refund your order — a promise he never follows through on. This is by far the worst Glass Nickel Pizza location I’ve experienced. With so many better pizza options in Sun Prairie, I regret giving them multiple chances. Do yourself a favor: reheat a frozen pizza. It’ll taste better, and you won’t have to deal with Adam’s attitude.”

“fresh sliced meat, great service, very yummy subs. I forgot about earning points and they didn't say anything :(. I spent $33 which I think would've been about 24 points”

“I came here with my family and it was the best breakfast I have ever had. Really good service with nice people, amazing food that makes you want to come here everyday, and would definitely recommend this place to everyone. 10/10!”

“Great food, friendly staff, welcoming environment! Never disappointed!”

“Came for the first time for a purse bingo- the owner, Tom, was extremely friendly and welcoming. The bar staff were super attentive and very friendly. It was a fun night out that was reasonably priced, good food and good people”

“great selection of spirits and inviting atmosphere.”

“Born and raised. Love the owners and all bartenders. 40 plus years lmao. Will always go there for fun and good drinks from all! My favorite go to bar in Sun Prairie!!”

“Honestly This is my first time going to Mod Pizza A week ago we had a Volleyball Tournament and then we here and the Pizza and the Garlic Bread was Astonishing 👍🔥”

“The chicken and potatoes were delicious! The salad bar is amazing! Pizza is awesome and dessert cookie pizza is delicious!! Pizza ranch certainly is “all that” and then some”

“This is a very good Starbucks location. Everything has been served correctly and on time. The service here is quite good, too. Friendly people, smiles, and a positive atmosphere and attitudes. Keep up the solid work.”

“Great Culver’s
Located near a lot of major businesses on the northeast side of Sun prairie
Employees are friendly.
Interior of the restaurant is clean

The butterburger and frozen custard I ordered was also very good in quantity,taste,and temperature.

Also to mention I have never seen a Culver’s until now with TV pricing/images instead of Paper, cool addition but also was confusing at first.”

“I want to start this review saying that I sure hope the manager that's Not Steven doesn't treat the employees like he treated us. We were headed to our hotel when other hockey team members called and said they were headed to Nitty-gritty to eat. We had seen the ads at the hockey rink and turned around and were the first ones there. I walked in and Not Steven asked how many. I explained I thought about 20-25 from our team were coming. He told us that he could not accommodate all of us in one area, that he had several teams coming in that had set reservations. He told us we should have made reservations months ago and made us feel like a complete inconvenience. I had never been to Sun Prairie and wouldn't have any idea of that. We waited for our friends and eventually Steven moved us together, after Not Steven seemed to go out of his way to spread us across the whole building. I'm so glad that we did not just leave due to the way we were treated by Not Steven. Our server was Joe I believe. He was attentive and polite and did a wonderful job. Honestly all the other staff seemed happy to be there and seemed to enjoy working there. The food was fast, tasted wonderful, and was very well put together. We ordered a few different things. The nachos had great ground meat that wasn't greasy gross. The flatbread was well made. Everything else was great also. The price for the plate size was good also. It's a shame that my first and lasting impression is of how inconvenient we were to Not Steven. I do want to note that, while we were there, I never saw any part of any of the other teams there. There did seem to be a small gathering of adults at one time but no other teams. I truly hope the manager doesn't treat his amazing team the way he treated new customers. Also, Steven was wonderful and was very welcoming.”

“Great burger using FRESH beef. Reasonable prices, great brew selection. Family run & they are super friendly. The patrons were also perfectly friendly! I'm coming back.”

“The staff were so friendly and courteous. I had inadvertently placed a duplicate order. The staff realized that right away but made some backup pizzas just in case. They refunded my card and said they would easily be able to sell the other ones. Excellent customer service!! The pizzas were fabulous.”

“I love the food here. great.”

“The staff was friendly and willing to speak of other matters besides ice cream. However, the Blizzards that I bought did not fail to satisfy as they were just the thing I needed to top off the day.”

“I love there coffee and cold coffee and there donuts 🍩 super yummy 😋”

“I love this Culver’s, today the staff was especially nice and they helped me with every order. Although the floors are a bit dirty as well as the tables it was a good visit.”