New American Restaurants near Sun Prairie, WI

Salvatore's Tomato Pies Pizza • $
121 E Main St, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Fat Uncle Tony’S Pie
Classic Cheeseburger
Fat Uncle Tony Pizza
Farmer John's Pizza
The Woodsman Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Caesar Salad
Gluten Free
Kids Pizza
Tomato Pie

“I ordered on line and didn’t get the confirmation email. I called the store and they had the order as pick up the person answering my was quick to be able to change my order. I was not able to get a confirmation for delivery time… but short after what would have been pick up, my delivery driver was here! I was not expecting so soon but he was so friendly and wanted to be sure I had my food! Every single order from Sal’s… all the staff are so wonderful! Amazing kindness!“

4.4 Superb105 Reviews
Buck & Honey's - Sun Prairie American • $$
804 Liberty Blvd, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Flourless Chocolate Cake
Firecracker Shrimp Pizza
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Bacon Wrapped Dates
Cedar Plank Salmon
Thin Crust Pizza
Brussels Sprouts
Steak Gorgonzola
BBQ Pulled Pork

“The first time I’ve ever been there. I didn’t try everything on the menu so I’m just saying what I ordered today wasn’t the best. My all time favorite was the bartender Ms Michelle who was extremely nice ,friendly, and fast. I’m coming back to try something else on the menu but I hope to see the amazing Michelle in action she makes the best strawberry dessert drink ever.“

4.4 Superb261 Reviews
Pizza Ranch FunZone Arcade American • $$
682 S Grand Ave, Sun Prairie

“Despite the previous harsh reviews, this place seemed great to me! This place has a good variety of pizzas that you can choose and if you don't see a pizza that catches your eye, you can place an order for free. There are lots of sides to choose from such as: mashed potatoes, gravy, stuffing, pasta, salad, and plenty of desserts. This place also has an arcade in the back so you can easily entertain kids while you eat. This place is clean, moderately priced and has great customer service. Great place to take a family.“

4 Good43 Reviews
Pizza Ranch Buffet • $
682 S Grand Ave, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Stuffing with Gravy an Vegetables
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Cherry Dessert Pizza
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Fried Chicken Bar
Buffet Your Way
Clubhouse Salad
Chicken Sticks
Chicken Fries

“Good variety of great food (including fresh salad bar, nice selection of pizzas, chicken and other side dishes available, desserts, etc.), but I recommend checking open hours before paying dinner buffet prices to ensure a full, relaxed dining experience.We hadn't been to a Pizza Ranch in awhile but decided to splurge to commemorate a special event on a Tuesday (3/19/24), never expecting a restaurant open for dinner would close at 7 pm (and we didn't look up hours in advance).First, there were no prices on the chalkboard when we arrived, listing only children's prices (which we thought was odd). Then, we paid for two buffets at 6:26 pm (and included a staff tip) without any employee noting the soon-to-be closing time, but an employee stopped by before we sat down in a booth to tell us that the restaurant closed at 7 pm. -- we told both her and the cashier that for the dinner buffet price we were charged, we might have decided not to eat there that night knowing that we only had a half-hour to eat (when I'm guessing the average guest stays at least an hour). Both staff apologized and one noted the hours posted (on a small sign) on one entrance door, but we were offered nothing else (no full or partial refund, etc.). We felt rushed and didn't enjoy the dining experience as we hoped -- I only had time for one trip to the salad bar and pizza selection, and I didn't get to try any other food options or dessert.(Photos were edited to remove identifying information. We provided this feedback on the receipt's restaurant survey but we didn't get any response, so I'm posting here, to benefit others.)“

3.5 Good79 Reviews
Loading...
map Map