They had a band playing country and Christian music. The view of the lake was really pretty too.
Jennifer
Great atmosphere, we chose to sit in bar area so slightly nosies but no problem for us. Server kept drinks full and let us know food was comming even though we didn't wait long. Food was good, we had pizza and pasta. Husband had Ruben pizza and said it could have had more meat on it but was good.
Veronica Sanchez
Food is great but I’m not sure if something changed because the sauce does taste different and it seems to be a greasier pizza than previous visits. (It’s been this way the last 3-4 times we’ve been there). The food is still delish and the service is good! Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
amandeep badwal
Excellent food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Matthew Kraly
Got the Amazon pizza. Only complaint was I marked extra sauce for it and it seemed to hardly have any sauce in it. Other than that, it was a great pizza. I would definitely eat here again if I ever come back to Sun
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mirandah Welch
Our service was great! We got the Mediterranean pizza and it was amazing! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M Wolfe
My husband and I visited Sugar River Pizza in Sun Prairie. Our server Brandon was amazing. When we arrived he was the only server on staff at the time yet we received great service. At one point I saw him running to serve his customers. He was attentive, kind and really efficient. Our pizza was hot and delicious.We will definitely be back and hope to have Brandon as our server.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Amazon Deluxe
Erin Liparota
Parking: They are so busy it’s just usually hard to find a good spot in that lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug
We had a party of 4 as and ordered 3 pizzas and a couple beers. The pizza's were excellent and their selection of beers on tap was extensive. The restaurant was large and did not feel crowded. The noise level was fairly quiet. This was our first time at this location and we would go back in a heartbeat.
Michele Luther
It’s not my first time dining in we’ve been there maybe five times now I’ve just wanted to love this place because I wanted something different in pizzas. It’s nicely done inside. I see other reviews of not happy with the staff. We didn’t have problems with staff. except one time there was one waitress that did seem not happy but otherwise they’ve been nice since and we’ve always gotten seating right away.I wanted to love this place but the pizza doesn’t have seasoning or something is just missing. It’s just blah and the pizzas cheese If you look at every review picture every pizza is browned, it should be nice and cheesy looking & not be dried out. We’ve ordered each an individual pizza so we can try different ones and every time it’s not flavorful they have a lot of choices but it’s weird very pizza doesn’t have flavor. To give things flavor you need seasoning and I think that’s what’s missing. I also ordered a sangria and it was so filled with ice. I know they need to do that to save some money, but it just watered down everything. I told him the next one I didn’t want so much ice, it was better but then when we got our bill because it doesn’t show the price Which they should. It was $11 for a sangria!! So I think after this last time, I don’t know if we’ll come back sadly..
Parking: It just seems odd that place is so big and they don’t have enough parking. I believe, for a place like that.
My wife and went to Sugar River Pizza for the first time two weeks ago in New Glarus. We loved the pizza and the service. The other couple we went with loved it as well.
Tonight we ordered pick up from the Sun Prairie location. A very romantic Valentines dinner with our daughter who is home from college. The pizza was well over done and extremely disappointing. We ordered two 12” pizzas and both turned out the same way. I guess word to the wise… take your chances!!!
Food: 1
Mike
Awesome pizza!! Great space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debbie Castillo
Nice, clean restaurant. Our server, Laura, was very attentive and pleasant. Food was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Dianne Metcalf
Food was delicious. Aaron was our waiter and did an excellent job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandi Kelley
We came here for dinner on a Saturday evening. We, surprisingly, were sat immediately. We had to wait a little extra for our food because we had some large parties ahead of us, but they were able to bring the little one her apple sauce while we waited, so all was good. We ordered the chicken alfredo on wheat, and it was delicious. It definitely needed the salty parmesan cheese, though. The spritzer was also great. The only two issues we had were 1. The room we were in was freezing (it was a low as 68° at one point) and 2. The water was pretty nasty. Just don't drink the water.
Dietary restrictions: They have great wheat option
Kid-friendliness: They gave us crayons and a coloring page, great food options at $5
They had a band playing country and Christian music. The view of the lake was really pretty too.
Great atmosphere, we chose to sit in bar area so slightly nosies but no problem for us. Server kept drinks full and let us know food was comming even though we didn't wait long. Food was good, we had pizza and pasta. Husband had Ruben pizza and said it could have had more meat on it but was good.
Food is great but I’m not sure if something changed because the sauce does taste different and it seems to be a greasier pizza than previous visits. (It’s been this way the last 3-4 times we’ve been there). The food is still delish and the service is good! Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread
Excellent food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Got the Amazon pizza. Only complaint was I marked extra sauce for it and it seemed to hardly have any sauce in it. Other than that, it was a great pizza. I would definitely eat here again if I ever come back to Sun
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our service was great! We got the Mediterranean pizza and it was amazing! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I visited Sugar River Pizza in Sun Prairie. Our server Brandon was amazing. When we arrived he was the only server on staff at the time yet we received great service. At one point I saw him running to serve his customers. He was attentive, kind and really efficient. Our pizza was hot and delicious.We will definitely be back and hope to have Brandon as our server.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Amazon Deluxe
Parking: They are so busy it’s just usually hard to find a good spot in that lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a party of 4 as and ordered 3 pizzas and a couple beers. The pizza's were excellent and their selection of beers on tap was extensive. The restaurant was large and did not feel crowded. The noise level was fairly quiet. This was our first time at this location and we would go back in a heartbeat.
It’s not my first time dining in we’ve been there maybe five times now I’ve just wanted to love this place because I wanted something different in pizzas. It’s nicely done inside. I see other reviews of not happy with the staff. We didn’t have problems with staff. except one time there was one waitress that did seem not happy but otherwise they’ve been nice since and we’ve always gotten seating right away.I wanted to love this place but the pizza doesn’t have seasoning or something is just missing. It’s just blah and the pizzas cheese If you look at every review picture every pizza is browned,
it should be nice and cheesy looking & not be dried out. We’ve ordered each an individual pizza so we can try different ones and every time it’s not flavorful they have a lot of choices but it’s weird very pizza doesn’t have flavor. To give things flavor you need seasoning and I think that’s what’s missing. I also ordered a sangria and it was so filled with ice. I know they need to do that to save some money, but it just watered down everything. I told him the next one I didn’t want so much ice, it was better but then when we got our bill because it doesn’t show the price Which they should. It was $11 for a sangria!! So I think after this last time, I don’t know if we’ll come back sadly..
Parking: It just seems odd that place is so big and they don’t have enough parking. I believe, for a place like that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
My wife and went to Sugar River Pizza for the first time two weeks ago in New Glarus. We loved the pizza and the service. The other couple we went with loved it as well.
Tonight we ordered pick up from the Sun Prairie location. A very romantic Valentines dinner with our daughter who is home from college. The pizza was well over done and extremely disappointing. We ordered two 12” pizzas and both turned out the same way. I guess word to the wise… take your chances!!!
Food: 1
Awesome pizza!! Great space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice, clean restaurant. Our server, Laura, was very attentive and pleasant. Food was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza
Food was delicious. Aaron was our waiter and did an excellent job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came here for dinner on a Saturday evening. We, surprisingly, were sat immediately. We had to wait a little extra for our food because we had some large parties ahead of us, but they were able to bring the little one her apple sauce while we waited, so all was good. We ordered the chicken alfredo on wheat, and it was delicious. It definitely needed the salty parmesan cheese, though. The spritzer was also great. The only two issues we had were 1. The room we were in was freezing (it was a low as 68° at one point) and 2. The water was pretty nasty. Just don't drink the water.
Dietary restrictions: They have great wheat option
Kid-friendliness: They gave us crayons and a coloring page, great food options at $5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...