Smitty's Overtime Inn
8293 WI-173, Tomah
(608) 372-5499
Customers' Favorites
Ribs Wendsday Night Special Top Notch
Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
Thin Crust PEPP Pizza
Soup and Salad Bar
Roast Beef Dinner
Seafood Platter
Grilled Cheese
Onion Rings
Tater Tots
Deep Fried
Menu
Photos
+70 photos
+69 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We came to town for the Badger Nationals. We have friends who live in Tomah. I wanted a fish fry. They suggested we go here. Fast service, nice salad bar, great food!! We loved it so much, we came back on Saturday night for the prime rib. It did not disappoint!! Reasonable prices on both nights. My bf said if we lived here we would be coming once a week. We now have an excuse to go visit our friends more often just so we can come eat here!!
My first time at Smitty's, and I have to say . It is the best atmosphere . And the ladies bathroom is decorated so cute decorated in Coca-Cola memorabilia. Our bartender was the best ! I recommend if you're in the area , or if you're not. try going to Smitty's you will not be disappointed.
We meet here once a month and have lunch. The food is good and the service is exceptional. Nancy takes care of it every time and knows exactly what we drink and what we usually order. She's fast, friendly and efficient she is a big part of why we keep returning.
You May Also Like
Backwater Bar & Grill - WI-21
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, Burgers
Mr. P's Bar & Grill - 1015 E McCoy Blvd
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, American, New American
Perkins Restaurant & Bakery - 1015 E McCoy Blvd
![]()
American, Bakery, Vegetarian