Custom Cakes near Verona, WI

“Melissa made all of the desserts for my wedding on 5/21/22 and they were all AMAZING. I was actually a bit disappointed that there were no leftovers! I have Celiacs disease, and Melissa was even able to make everything gluten free - cake, cake pops, Oreo balls, and pie bars...wow! The dessert displays and the cake decorations were also beautiful. We got so many compliments on the desserts, and Melissa was so easy to work with. Thank you, Melissa!“

“We ordered cakes for my Grandaughter's first birthday and we were extremely happy! They were delicious and moist. This was our first time ordering and we were very pleased. Thank you!“

“I went the on 2sept 2025 while on vacation there at about 5:30 pm. The employee behind the counter was very respectful and Pleasant. He treated me with the upmost respect and made me feel like I was an important part of his day. This experience is not common in a lot of places. I would definitely be visiting that cold stone creamery again on my next visit to Middleton.“

“We love Cold Stone, specifically this location! The owner is Great, very happy to always serve anyone that walks thru his shop. Everything we’ve gotten from here was superb, and it continues to be our top choice for ice cream.Try any mix flavor as a shake, lots of topping options available.“