I was told this was the best pizza and fries around, so as a self-proclaimed foodie, I had to try it out! I discovered it was cash only, and I didn't have enough for my order. The man working (Ethan) still gave me my full order, despite me not having enough cash on hand. The food was exceptional, and the service was just as incredible. I returned today to repay them for their kindness. Just a really great experience, and I look forward to visiting again. You really need to try their pizza and fries. Thank you for the kindness, great food, and the great experience! Beautiful patio area with a view as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sweet Potato
Stopped quickly before catching the ferry back and grabbed a slice of pizza for my hungry kid and the iceberg veggies salad for myself. Holy cow, the best salad I have ever had! I have been paleo for years and have had more salads than a person can count. This veggie mix was out of this world! Oh and my son raved about the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
WJ
Delicious pizza! Superb crust!! A definite must when you're on the Island!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maryam D.
Listen y’all, this is HANDS DOWN the BEST pizza we have ever had AND the service is outstanding. Thank you to both of you for just being amazing people n having amazing food. We hope to see you again sometime. Love, The lady with the blingy hair cover n her two boys. We stopped by 9/24 right b4 you closed.
Kid-friendliness: These are amazing people.
Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken, Cheese Slice
Robert Jagla
Great large slices of pizza. Best I've had in Door Co.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lexie S
The food was okay. We got a turkey sub. For the price, we expected more. For $10 a sub, it is very plain and small.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Lexie Saladini
The food was okay. We got a turkey sub. For the price, we expected more. For $10 a sub, it is very plain and small.
Dawn Chier
Don’t get me started on these fries. Fresh, made to order. Tell him Dawn sent you ;)
There are many unique and attractive restaurants on Washington Island. But hey, sometimes you just want a pizza. This is it.We drove from out hotel to make an order. I guess we could have called; but exploring the island is part of the fun being there.You can dine in or carry out. Be careful getting to the place, as it's easy to get tangled up with the line to the ferry.The kid who waited on us was smiling and pleasant.The pie took about 15 minutes and we got it piping hot. We went back to the Hotel Washington and sat at a front yard table and enjoyed our pizza listening to red eyed vireos. Made our car smell like pizza for two days.The pizza itself was okay. A lot of cheese and toppings. They certainly don't scrimp.Washington Island is a nice place to spend a few days. Sometimes you just want a pizza. You can get a decent one here.
Jason Stephens
I phoned in an order for a couple of pizzas for lunch on a Sunday and the fellow taking my order was friendly and efficient. I arrived when he told me they'd be ready, and they were piping hot and fresh from the oven. The price was agreeable, and the pizzas were delicious!
Angela Conn
We make a special trip to the island just for Island Pizza! It's the one place our family of five gives a unanimous thumbs up to everything we've eaten from there. Whenever we plan a trip to Door County, one of the first things asked is, "Can we go to Island Pizza?!"
Yomoto Fukunma
Great food, great service and an amazing view, everything on the menu is great and Ethan really out does himself for his customers. 1st place I stop when I get on the island and I usually grab a slice to go on my way off island and the place I recommend to everyone for great fast food
I was told this was the best pizza and fries around, so as a self-proclaimed foodie, I had to try it out! I discovered it was cash only, and I didn't have enough for my order. The man working (Ethan) still gave me my full order, despite me not having enough cash on hand. The food was exceptional, and the service was just as incredible. I returned today to repay them for their kindness. Just a really great experience, and I look forward to visiting again. You really need to try their pizza and fries. Thank you for the kindness, great food, and the great experience! Beautiful patio area with a view as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped quickly before catching the ferry back and grabbed a slice of pizza for my hungry kid and the iceberg veggies salad for myself. Holy cow, the best salad I have ever had! I have been paleo for years and have had more salads than a person can count. This veggie mix was out of this world! Oh and my son raved about the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza! Superb crust!! A definite must when you're on the Island!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Listen y’all, this is HANDS DOWN the BEST pizza we have ever had AND the service is outstanding. Thank you to both of you for just being amazing people n having amazing food. We hope to see you again sometime.
Love,
The lady with the blingy hair cover n her two boys. We stopped by 9/24 right b4 you closed.
Kid-friendliness: These are amazing people.
Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken, Cheese Slice
Great large slices of pizza. Best I've had in Door Co.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was okay. We got a turkey sub. For the price, we expected more. For $10 a sub, it is very plain and small.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
The food was okay. We got a turkey sub. For the price, we expected more. For $10 a sub, it is very plain and small.
Don’t get me started on these fries. Fresh, made to order. Tell him Dawn sent you ;)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, fries, and views. Cash only.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Fries
Love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Their customer service is amazing!
There are many unique and attractive restaurants on Washington Island. But hey, sometimes you just want a pizza. This is it.We drove from out hotel to make an order. I guess we could have called; but exploring the island is part of the fun being there.You can dine in or carry out. Be careful getting to the place, as it's easy to get tangled up with the line to the ferry.The kid who waited on us was smiling and pleasant.The pie took about 15 minutes and we got it piping hot. We went back to the Hotel Washington and sat at a front yard table and enjoyed our pizza listening to red eyed vireos. Made our car smell like pizza for two days.The pizza itself was okay. A lot of cheese and toppings. They certainly don't scrimp.Washington Island is a nice place to spend a few days. Sometimes you just want a pizza. You can get a decent one here.
I phoned in an order for a couple of pizzas for lunch on a Sunday and the fellow taking my order was friendly and efficient. I arrived when he told me they'd be ready, and they were piping hot and fresh from the oven. The price was agreeable, and the pizzas were delicious!
We make a special trip to the island just for Island Pizza! It's the one place our family of five gives a unanimous thumbs up to everything we've eaten from there. Whenever we plan a trip to Door County, one of the first things asked is, "Can we go to Island Pizza?!"
Great food, great service and an amazing view, everything on the menu is great and Ethan really out does himself for his customers. 1st place I stop when I get on the island and I usually grab a slice to go on my way off island and the place I recommend to everyone for great fast food
Loading...