Cotton Exchange

345 Hickory Hollow Rd, Waterford
(262) 534-9291

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Broiled Scallops and Porterhouse Steak

Bluegill with Potato Pancakes

Ribeye Steak and Cheese Potato

Oysters Rockefeller

Beer Battered Cod

Ribs and Shrimp

Onion Haystacks

Seafood Platter

Coconut Shrimp

Chicken Oscar

Photos

+47 photos

+46 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Doordash

Recent Reviews

I was super excited to try this place as we were in the area it gave off a Magnolia vibe (Johanna Gaines). We were disappointed with the food! The caesar salad was okay, but definitely not house made. The bread they served with it was warm. Their chicken Alfredo and bayou chicken tasted like prego on overcooked noodles and pre-cooked chicken. Their atmosphere (we got seated in the bar unfortunately) it was very much a sport bar with lots of televisions and slot machines just not...

June 2025

Have been to the actual restaurant a couple of times. I remember it being a good (but not great) experience. I was happy to see that they were a vendor at the Waterford River Rhythms concert at the Village Hall Park.

They offered a couple of sandwiches. We got one of each. The Italian Beef and the Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap. Both were good. The beef was tender, and so was the chicken.

Couple of suggestions. They add the giardiniera into...

June 2025

It's been a minute since I've eaten here last. The seafood was good, steak flavor was delicious. I felt the server could have been more friendly. The busser had more personality than the waitress. Hoping maybe she had an off night. It seemed quiet in there & expected a better serving experience for the price. I'd give the specialty drinks an A+.
Great drink menu!!

May 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Waterford, WI

Cotton Exchange

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Cotton Exchange