Jimmy's Island Grill & Iguana Bar

2303 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa
(414) 837-2121

Recent Reviews

Brian K.

Great lunch experience! Food was good and service was even better. Looking forward to coming back.

Kris Kreutzberg

Chelsea was awesome as awaitress!!! The cook made awesome food, I had a patty melt, and it was awesome! Would recommend this place to everyone!!Parking: You can park right by the restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos

Megan Salentine

We came in as a party of 18, on a slow day. Chelsea was a rockstar with getting drinks and attending to all the chaotic needs, Mark cooked some amazing food, we were not disappointed! Thank you both for working through the pressure, with a smile! We appreciate you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jay R

Hi we went here for dinner 2/23/24 because we came here a long time ago and it was great. Bartender said they had no specialty drinks but we quickly saw on the menu they did. Ordered an $11 margarita because I was impressed by the size of the glass, well, they filled it with ice then poured just a shot of alcohol in. If that. Then they re-filled it with ice before filling the rest up with sour mix. I would suggest getting beer here if you want to drink. This was right in front of us so we asked if he could pour more in but he wanted an extra $3-$4. No way man. Slammed this ice filled drink in 3 gulps what a waste. Fish was good. They forgot our shrimp appetizer and blamed the printer so we said forget it. 15 minutes later they brought our burnt shrimp. 2 bartenders and no waiters this place was dead on a Friday night and it shows why. Go to cheesecake factory across the street plenty of business over there ? this place doesn't play island music either FYI. Sorry for the bad review but you needed it. You might get a better experience with a different bartender here.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Fish Fry

lydia Hansen

Jimmy's is one of my favorite places! Their drinks are amazing and the service is even better. Their bartender Pete is amazing and look forward to seeing him every visit. Can't wait to go back as it's been some time since Phil and I last went! Miss you guys! We will be back soon! Hope he sees this! Hii Peter!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Kbosh

Go for the drinks, stay for Peter.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nachos, Create Your Own Pizza, Spinach Artichoke Dip, Chips & Salsa

JORGE MENDIZABAL

Came here with my family on the weekend, not sure who server us , but was extremely nice to us , especially to my 2 little ones . This place full of tropical decors everywhere. We had a great time here and the food was delicious. Will definitely be back here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The 414 Chef

For a guy that looks like Ryan Seacrest and C.M. Punk . . Peter is very talented and knowledgeable behind the bar. He makes you feel welcomed and comfortable like you are in a Fortress.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos

The 414 Discount Superstore

For a guy that looks like Ryan Seacrest and C.M. Punk . . Peter is very talented and knowledgeable behind the bar. He makes you feel welcomed and comfortable like you are in a Fortress.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos

Sara Crutcher Emberton

Flavorful food, tropical drinks and unique beers, good service. Fun place with a tropical feel.

James W.

The tuna dishes here are awesome. As good as you get on either coast. Cocktails are equally good, too. Jim & Gret

Elle Arjee

The fish tacos are to die for and Peter is an amazing bartender!!! Love this place!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Z.

Food is plain jane! You have to go tonthe bar to order food amd drink, no waiter. Ambience is decent.

Tim Karth

Met for a drink, never been there, pretty much a typical themed hotel bar.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Ruth G.

The Thai calamari was ok but the subsequent meal was literally flavorless. That would be a steak quesadilla and a patty melt. There is no table service so you have to order at the bar and they bring your food. Bad 80's pop music plays in the background. Everyone was very nice but we won't be back.

Load More

Jimmy's Island Grill & Iguana Bar

2303 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226
(414) 837-2121