Cold Stone Creamery

2935 S 108th St, West Allis
(414) 541-3888

Recent Reviews

Sort by
ben h (Buckaroo)

This location is OLYMPIC LEVEL at sending half the order!

Kilee Wand

I’ve never had such frustrating customer service. We asked for two scoops in one bowl, but instead of listening, they made us pay for two separate bowls—no explanation, no clarification, just silence and attitude.

To make it worse, they left our cone sitting on the counter and didn’t even call it out. The employee wouldn’t speak up, didn’t seem to listen, and acted like we were supposed to understand their Cold Stone lingo like “Love It” or “Like It.” We’re customers, not employees—we don’t work there!

Jennifer Miles

Half cup of ice cream for $8 and an extra $2 for a cone. Flavor was ok, but nothing impressive. Had the nutter butter and there was maybe 3 pieces of cookie bits and 2 tiny strands of fudge. The ice cream barely covered the bottom of the cone. First and last time trying this place.

Ann

Very expensive oreo ice cream cake- worst ice cream cake I ever had. Whole family agrees

Mike M

Terrible service experience. Three staff members were overwhelmed, focusing on one customer while neglecting others. A delivery driver was waiting for unprepared orders, and the line barely moved. Employees spent more time chatting than working. After waiting 10 minutes with no progress, I left frustrated

I will not go back. Plenty of other good ice cream to choose from

Nina

Wonderful workers! I heard they have 3 new employees as to why they are asking questions left and right to a certain employee. They are slow but they're still learning and it's great to be part of their learning experience! They are very professional at their job even when I witnessed another customer giving them an attitude. Can be busy at times but it is definitely worth it at the end!!! YUMMY ICE CREAM 😊🤤

Jellybean

I came here to say a while ago and got a like it mint ice cream with Oreos and I fell in love and came back with the same order but added a waffle bowl and it was delicious. This is my go to place for ice cream and relax with family and the music is very chill. Thank youColdstone will be coming back again! The staff are very welcoming with a nice Hello and have a nice day I love that about a restaurant that welcome customers. Keep up the great work and team.

JS

This place has the crappiest service I have seen in a long time. There was a very long line when we were visiting and one of the employees named Abby decided that it was far more important to refill ice cream tubs that weren’t even close to empty instead of helping customers. Abby has no business working in customer service as she clearly doesn’t know what the term means. Please hire better employees!!!

Arnold Lueders

Waited 19 minutes for one ice cream. 15 people in line multiple workers but only one actually serving customers. Would highly not recommend.

ceceilia castillo

This Cold Stone lacks any type of customer service skill. They were extremely unhelpful when a birthday coupon of mine wasn't working. Then when I finally did get it to work, they didn't provide me any utensils or napkins. Last time they receive my money. So many other great and local establishments to support.

A iknow User

Nothing but love( I wish they would bring back the location that was closer to where I live) . I've been coming to coldstone for years. My favorite is the apple pie ala coldstone.. 😋.

Tee Zeigler

Very friendly and was fast being it was only one person working at the time.

Remy Swayne

Good ice cream. Doesn't taste like chemicals

Pam Bowen

The staff ignored me for 10 min!!! Don’t recommend coming here.

SPECT RADE

Tasted pretty good but I couldn’t drink well since there was Chunks of ice. not blended properly

Loading...