Nico’s Pizza
$ • Burgers, Pizza, Sports Bars
Hours:
9638 W National Ave, West Allis
(414) 316-9557
About Nico’s Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Nico’s Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Nico’s Pizza
We had pizza the night before so we both ordered sandwiches. I ordered mushroom swiss and she ordered Italian beef. I got a pizza burger instead of the mushroom swiss. I don't like to complain so I ate the pizza burger. Wouldn't order that again. Her Italian beef was okay at best. Very disappointed with our meals. We had heard that the pizza is good but we won't be back to try it.
May have gone past this place about a million times in the 35 years I’ve been alive, and I ask myself why?
Attended a baby shower today in the back hall / rental room they have and the pizza here was no joke!
No joke as in, this will most definitely be my go to spot for family pizza nights. Everything from the friendly “home sweet home” staff, the sauce, crust, toppings, and the cheese.
True Perfection!
Reminds me of my favorite Chicago pizza...read full review
While I agree that this is a pub trying to be a restaurant, the pizza was decent, but unfortunately dry. i'd give it a 3/5. additionally the website looks like something from 2000. it is not organized, it was 2 years outdated from information posted. it says west allis is still coming in 2023.... this is late 2025 now. additionally there's a cart system to place orders but no option to place orders. someone desperately needs to update and fix this site
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 1AM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in West Allis Also Viewed
Nico’s Pizza is a popular spot for many, celebrated for its magnificent portobello and sausage pizza with a cracker-thin crust, fresh ingredients, and amazing flavor. Customers enjoy the big pieces of sausage and awesome sauce. The fresh Motz app with tomatoes and balsamic glaze remains a highlight. Recently, some have noticed spicier sauce on the pizza, and while some have found the pizza to be dry, the great service continues to draw them back. The restaurant features a beautiful interior, perfect for dining in. The staff is fantastic and attentive, providing a personalized experience for every guest. With fun events like karaoke, music bingo, and live music, Nico’s is a rare gem. Many recommend trying the meatballs, garlic bread, and various pizzas, including cheese, sausage, mushroom, onion, and black olives. Nico’s Pizza is also a wonderful choice for parties and events, ensuring a memorable dining experience for all. However, there have been mentions of issues with the website being outdated and difficult to navigate, which may need attention. Despite these concerns, customer service has been outstanding, with staff members being accommodating and friendly, further enhancing the positive experience.