Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli

I am kicking myself for driving past this place so many times and never stopping. Stopped here today on a whim. WOW! Staff was friendly, and this place is spotless. Loved the lunchboxes and nostalgia! I got the honey roasted peanut butter and raspberry jam on white bread, toasted. Yum! Can't wait to come back and try other combos (so many choices!) My co-worker got a sandwich and soup and said the soup was great, too, and tasted homemade. Had the pleasure of meeting the owner, Mike. Super nice guy. Will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Honey Roasted, Red Raspberry

fresh ingredients, so delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Apple Slices, The Big Apple, Strawberry, Red Raspberry, Lovers, Strawberry Lovers

Really cool deli with a large variety of peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. They also sell jams, nut butters, lip balms, liqueurs, and soda! Cool nostalgic decor too! Can’t wait to go back to try a shake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Who doesn't like PB & J? Awesome comfort food. So much goodness. The only drawback - too many choices of goodness.

Vegetarian options: Go there and love it.

Dietary restrictions: Well if you are allergic to nuts, this isn't the place for you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What a unique place! Fresh made peanut butters, a great assortment of Jellies. The Sandwiches look and sound delicious 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

PB&J will always be a classic, and there spin on it with all different variations of jams and combinations. The nostalgia of eating a PB&J is real

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bagel PB

If you're a fan of peanut butter, jelly, or the classic combo of the two, this place is a must-visit! We first discovered their Honey Roasted Peanut Butter at a farmers market and instantly fell in love. It's the perfect blend of creamy and chunky and great with anything. We had said when we bought it that we would have to make it a point to go to the store and try some of the menu. When we ran out of peanut butter it was the perfect excuse.

The inside is decorated with old lunchboxes (that you can buy or trade) and has that nostalgia feel that pairs perfectly with a PB&J. The staff is incredibly friendly and patient, happily guiding you through the menu full of delicious pre-made combinations and plenty of options to customize your order.

I opted for the Bagel PB, featuring Honey Roasted Peanut Butter, honey, and cinnamon on a grilled bagel--absolutely divine! My husband tried The King, a grilled sandwich loaded with Honey Roasted Peanut Butter, sliced bananas, honey, and bacon. We also shared a cup of Tomato Basil Soup from The Soup Market and enjoyed their signature Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli Root Beer. Everything was flavorful, satisfying, and filling.

Before leaving, we couldn't resist grabbing another tub of their Honey Roasted Peanut Butter to take home.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went past here earlier and decided to walk there since I had some free time. Wish the city had bike racks or something to lock it to big maybe with time I guess. Moving on I got the the crunch and punch with sourdough and grilled it. It's a crunchy peanut butter with a jalapeño raspberry jam. I absolutely loved it and could probably have it a little bit hotter for more punch that the name implies. They have so many jams and jellies lol can't wait to try them all when I'm back. I'd definitely come back. Can't wait to bring my gf for a quick snack!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

When you want something delicious, fun, and different for your net training session or networking event Mike and the team can help you stand out with a meal that takes you back to being a kid!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love everything about this place. Their peanut butter is amazing. I will never buy from anywhere else again. Their shakes are also very good as well as their wine. It's a must try.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Everyone should experience this place at least once in their life.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was in the area for work and saw this cute little spot and what a great idea if you love nut butters! Nostalgic decor, home made peanut and almond butters. Also cashew butter. Lovely jam choices and many toppings. Check it out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I came across this brand at my local farmer's market. Completely expecting something that tasted half like cardboard and half like roasted peanuts I took a sample of their honey roasted peanuts butter and I couldn't stop eating this. I'm not a peanut butter connoisseur by any means, nor am I crazy about peanut butter. Do I love it in a good PBJ sandwich with the occasional substitution of jelly for Nutella or a sliced banana? Yes. Do I eat peanut butter every day? Not really. I'm telling you I can't stop eating this peanut butter. When I'm not eating this, I'm thinking of when I can fit it in my next meal so I'm being calorically responsible. I Hate crunchy peanut butter and was not expecting a crunch when I had this sample and I'm telling you, it was love at first bite. I'm a Jiffy girl, don't even like Skippy that much and this has replaced big brand peanut butter for me.

What do I like about it?
As soon as you bite into the peanut butter, the aroma of freshly roasted peanuts hits you. You continue eating and this ever so slight crunch accompanies the smooth peanut butter like sugar crystals dissolving. (I'm not a fan of crunchy and smooth together which is why I hate traditional crunchy peanut butter that gets stuck in your teeth, but these are like tiny sugary peanut butter pop rocks bursting in every bite.) The smoothness of the creamy peanut butter then introduces you to this background note of flowery honey that you start to sense as you continue eating. Even after you're done, you don't get a bitter aftertaste that you may with other peanut butter, it's just a clean taste with a slight aroma of freshly roasted peanuts.
Literally addictive, the best peanut butter I've had in my life.

Thank you for making this, I will be visiting your store!

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Honey Roasted

I came across this brand at my local farmer's market. Completely expecting something that tasted half like cardboard and half like roasted peanuts I took a sample of their honey roasted peanuts butter and I couldn't stop eating this. I'm not a peanut butter connoisseur by any means, nor am I crazy about peanut butter. Do I love it in a good PBJ sandwich with the occasional substitution of jelly for Nutella or a sliced banana? Yes. Do I eat peanut butter every day? Not really. I'm telling you I can't stop eating this peanut butter. When I'm not eating this, I'm thinking of when I can fit it in my next meal so I'm being calorically responsible. I Hate crunchy peanut butter and was not expecting a crunch when I had this sample and I'm telling you, it was love at first bite. I'm a Jiffy girl, don't even like Skippy that much and this has replaced big brand peanut butter for me.

What do I like about it?
As soon as you bite into the peanut butter, the aroma of freshly roasted peanuts hits you. You continue eating and this ever so slight crunch accompanies the smooth peanut butter like sugar crystals dissolving. (I'm not a fan of crunchy and smooth together which is why I hate traditional crunchy peanut butter that gets stuck in your teeth, but these are like tiny sugary peanut butter pop rocks bursting in every bite.) The smoothness of the creamy peanut butter then introduces you to this background note of flowery honey that you start to sense as you continue eating. Even after you're done, you don't get a bitter aftertaste that you may with other peanut butter, it's just a clean taste with a slight aroma of freshly roasted peanuts.
Literally addictive, the best peanut butter I've had in my life.

Thank you for making this, I will be visiting your store!

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Honey Roasted

I was a proud supporter of this company for the last few years. I purchased their products at various venues in Wisconsin as well as a brick and mortar store which sold their product for a while. I realized they were not going to be near where I shop so I placed my first online order. I waited two weeks after realizing my card had been charged and no order had been shipped. I called and was told the owner would call me. He did return my call and said that they had issues with their third party administrator. I expressed my disappointment with this, as most items do not charge until product is shipped. After informing him that I had purchased his product many times and was hoping for a reduced shipping charge since his online state you will receive product within 7-14 business days and it was not even shipped yet. He became rude and stated that he would not do anything to accomodate the issue. I told him I would not be purchasing his product again. He rudely stated he would refund my card and hung up on me. I am a 60 year old professional person and have never experienced this poor of a level of customer service from a business owner. I would discourage anyone from ordering online as he stated this was not the first time he had an issue like this. He stated that orders had been lost in junk mail before. It is absolutely incredible to me that someone can run a business like this, and then be rude to a customer. I will be definitely sourcing this product elsewhere and will discourage others from buying it. Worst customer service ever!! Now I know why the vendor that was selling his product stopped also!!!