Jack Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn

The Lamb Shank and Pork Schnitzel were great. My German Pancake was just so so. Too heavy.... Not like years past. The real deal Maple Syrup saved it..... Our waitress was very sweet. We were NOT rushed at all for Easter Sunday. Ate in the Bar area. We do enjoy going to Jack Pandl's. Just a little disappointed in my German Pancake.

What an absolute nightmare, made reservations weeks in advance. Upon arriving we were treated like we had no business there, it was slow and they were closing early. Both the host and the waitress working were the most unprofessional people I've ever encountered. Rude, unpleasant and unprofessional sums up the experience. Did not eat, left and found other accommodation

Very disappointing. Place is old. Service was good, food was ok. However, I was encouraged to order lollipop lamb chops and while I like them, I was planning on ordering the filet. The waiter encouraged me to order the lamb chops so I did , medium rare. They came well done. Now I wa told that was the last of the lamb chops, so I had to order the filet after all. My friend was through eating by the time I got my dinner and I was not so hungry any more. The filet was cooked correctly and I took. most of it home where it never tastes the same. Total experience was so disappointing. None of the food was exceptional. The bathroom was old and while pretty clean, not attractive or comfortable. As I said, this place is pretty old and not well kept up. A private note. I cannot recommend this restaurant.

I love this place! I've driven past it my entire life and it took me until this year before giving it a try. The food is soooooo good!!! The staff is amazing! I want to be a regular!

Food and service at Pandl's were great. Outside of building is beginning to look kind of shabby. Needs some updates. Presentation is everything at an eatery.

Nice spot for a Friday night fish fry in Lent. A bit crowded but service makes up for the crowd.

Step back and step out! Great food and old fashioned atmosphere, order a bit of everything

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Broiled Whitefish, Weiner Schnitzel, Apple Strudel

Parking: It's fine, just go inside!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve lived on the east for over a decade and every time I drove by this place, I thought I would love to eat there. Today, Sunday, I went there with four people. The waitress was rude, the food was terrible. Warm rolls, the waitress passed around and asked us if we wanted one roll. When my friend asked if she could get two, the waitress said “ if I give you one, all other customers will not have one”. The menu is very limited which is fine, my sister ordered the ham and cheese omelet, she asked for no ham. The waitress said it comes with the ham, then my sister said ok just a little ham. The order came with lots of ham. The omelette was very very salty. Mine had no flavor. Two of us ordered diet cokes, it was flat, she brought them again, it was still flat. I asked for straw, she said they ran out of straws. Overall, I would never go back. Worst experience and worst food I had in years.

Was just served as if we wasn't wanted. We got served water down drinks. The first set of drinks wasn't what we ordered the first time. Food had no flavor

A tribute to Milwaukee's dining history with wonderful homemade favorites including old world German fare and today's popular favorites. A wonderful atmosphere, good food and great service!

Wonderful and relaxing. Victoria our waitress was so attentive and pleasant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beautiful restaurant in a lovely location. Excellent food and a great birthday celebration but I seem to have taken no pictures.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Good place for that old German feel.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Clam Chowder

Had great luncheon for 10 people. Excellent food and service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5