32 Best Pizza Restaurants near Williams Bay

“Privato hosted our 50-person wedding on 9/9/23 and we could not have asked for a better experience. Sara was so kind, helpful, and flexible during our planning process. On the day of our wedding, the staff were so sweet and did such a great job. I believe Alyssa was managing that evening and she did an excellent job and was so accommodating. We had guests tell us it felt like our wedding was being hosted at a friend’s house rather than a venue, and we agree. It felt so personal and special thanks to Sara and the staff. We also had guests tell us it was the best food they had ever had at a wedding! It was delicious and accurate to our guest orders. Also, the tiramisu was absolutely amazing! They were also able to accommodate a few tricky allergies our guests had, which we really appreciate. The space just felt so comfortable and Sara was so wonderful moving everything for us according to our discussed plan. Sara and the whole staff really made our day feel so special and relaxed, we cannot thank them enough!“

“The pizza and wings I never stop craving.“

“First time checking out Mama Ciminos and I am not sure why it took us so long! lol. We will definitely be a returning customer! Owner was amazing, let us try his homemade sauce, it was delish! Chicken Alfredo portion was huge and very good! Would absolutely recommend.“

“Amazing food, amazing service. Great view. 5 stars“

“I am from out of town and today attended a party in Delavan that was catered by Jojo’s Pizza and Pasta. Food was absolutely delicious! Ready when requested, served hot and fresh. Italian beef and buns, pasta, bread sticks, wings and Caesar salad. Would highly recommend. Wish I lived closer!“

“Ignore how full you may feel after a few delicious plates - you MUST have the dark chocolate mousse for dessert. Perfection.“

“My boyfriend and I came down on the bike for lunch. What a phenomenal experience! The OG pizza and mushroom appetizer were amazing 🤩. The owner/chef truly puts his whole heart into his culinary masterpieces, and we will definitely return. I cannot wait to be back to try something else! What a great little find in the heart of Hebron ❤️“

“Great people and very personable. Very good pizza sauce to boot!! Haven’t tried any other items but the pizza is great!“

“From the friendly service to the super delicious food to the huge portions to the extensive menu, Nayeli's has it all. Today I tried their western chicken flatbread... in a word OUTSTANDING!“

“Amazing pizza!!!! Fresh and quality! Great wine options! Amazing service“

“Each person in our family got their own pizza and picked what they wanted on it so we were all happy! What a great concept with just one price no matter the toppings! And they even had veggie sausage with no extra charge. So good! Will come back next time we're in the area“

“That’s an amazing place, one of the best restaurants. I live in Chicago and one of the reasons that I go to elkhorn is to eat their pizza and garlic bread. It’s so delicious and I starve it everyday.“

“This is my favorite pizza place in Delavan. If I am getting pizza it is from here. Pizza is my favorite food and this is my favorite place to get it. I love that you can get it delivered or pick it up. Prices are very comparable to other competitors. One thing I would change would be their hours. They don’t open until 3 pm and are not open on Mondays. When I am craving a pizza this is the first place I think of. Always a must when recommending pizza places near Delavan.“

“Excellent Service, Excellent food and drinks!! Highly recommend, bring all your friends here!!!“

“Went here while in this town for lunch and this was AMAZING! The breadsticks tasted like what they advertise it like, and the pizza is the best thing ever! A great pizza shop. One complaint is that you only get 3 Mozzarella breadsticks for 4 bucks? Not a deal! Anyways, good place, still 5 stars.UPDATE: Long live our glorious Little Caesars in Delevan, you will forever be in our hearts ???? (it’s permanently closed)“

“Food was good service was very friendly. We had a burger, tots, Ruben egg rolls and drinks. Tots weren't great like the oil wasn't hot enough when they started cooking but stuff happens right. Overall I would say this is a safe place to grab a quick meal if you are passing through or going to the an event at the fair grounds.“

“Wonderful food. Good quality food. Fresh ingredients. I got a bacon cheese burger everything was perfect. The cook on the burger was great. All the veggies were fresh very good quality on the burger. Definitely get what your money is worth. I would have to say that one thing you could approve on is your hospitality. I found lots of the staff rude and cold towards their customers. Not helpful. The staff were not friendly at all. Other than that it was good experience.“

“Thank you Dominos for donating meals to the lake geneva aurora clinic during Covid pandemic.... from a grateful nurse“

“Great location and they also have an upstairs rental unit that has a boat slip available.“

“Keep track of your points. If they don't show on receipt you will have to go online and add them yourselves. This has happened twice this week to me. Never used to happen. when I complained they tried to blame it on the main office and I believe it is at the store. The person isn't pushing the right button or pressing hard enough for it to register the points. I won't be going more than once a week from now on because of this. the food is good. I like their chicken the best.“

“Pizza is the best around. Service was speedy.“

“I have lived in Walworth County for 18 years and discovered that Elkhorn Enzo’s has the best pizza in the county. Best ingredients, best authentic family recipes and best service.“

“Service was great! Food was fantastic!“

“Ordered pizza, hotdog, fries, shakes and everything was great. Lots to choose from on the menu.“

“Our oven just broke down to make pizza 5 minutes before there closing time and they were very understanding when making the food and we all appreciated it for caring about still having good customer service even after when they should have been closed“

“Great place. Excellent service food is outstanding!!!!“

“My wife and I had a great time. The bartender was friendly and the pizza was excellent. We’ll be back for sure.“

“I am always very pleased with this Domino’s location. They always get the food right. It’s delivered hot, delicious and speedy. Their drivers are also amazing everytime. This time we had a driver named David and if I’m not mistaken, he was our driver about two weeks ago when we ordered delivery. He is always very pleasant so I try to make sure he’s tipped well everytime. All in all I am never ever disappointed in the workers performances at this location and I highly recommend.“

“A wonderful view of Lake Geneva“

“Stayed at the harbor Shores Hotel in Lake Geneva, with the Ginos attached. Sat by the pool for a while, got hungry and went to order takeout. Was told of the kitchen was slammed, and take out orders on pause. Sat the bar, had an iced tea, and the bartender Emily Made sure that we eventually got some service. When we made our order, we got the sweet-and-sour chicken wings and a medium pepperoni pizza thin crust. The food was delicious! Atmosphere was pleasant, eating at the bar was just what we needed. We’ve eaten here before, last summer and the food was very good. Gino did not disappoint this time around!“

“What a fabulous dinner and server! We experienced a beautiful view, delicious food and wine, and a very knowledgeable and personable server .. Sabrina. Highly recommend Crafted Italia. A wonderful menu with a variety of small plates and dinners. The atmosphere is elegant and the view of Lake Como .. Breathtaking ❤️“