Mythical Pizza

Me and my husband drove 6 hours for this pizza and it was worth every mile! This pizza is such a unique treat. The atmosphere is so cool decorated in monsters and crypt characters. 10/10 will always recommend!

Man, I can’t stop thinkin’ about this wild little place. Got a build-your-own pizza and dude I think there might be magic in the cheese because good heavens, just when I said to myself and a bit to my mother, “I should probably slow down..” (in anticipation of the classic westward expansion and overall fullness that results from eating hella bread) the very same slice that I set down vanished from the box and materialized in my hand; as I was clearly under some sort of scrumptious spell, I shoveled it in my face once more. Thrice more. Fighting back the urge to freeze some and save it for my husband when he gets in from LA; as if that could even be the same. I therefore vowed that I’d return to Myth Piz soon to share the entire vibe with him. It’s not every day I find myself raving about pizza in WV. It’s also not every day I happen across distant family (Bigfoot) whilst raving. Don’t ask me when but I’ma be back 🙏🏼

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I came in on Wednesday evening for dinner. I was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere and hospitality. My pizza was outstanding. I spoke with the person in charge, Buffy, about how friendly the staff was. if you're in the area, I highly recommend stopping by.

So fun!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Nice to have good pizza in town

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place to stop on your way through Berkeley Springs! My family has a tradition of always stopping for a pepperoni roll on our way through WV and this one does not disappoint! Mythical has a great take on a classic roll with a thin crispy dough loaded with tons of cheese and pepperoni!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Most delicious I have had in a very long time.
16c pepperoni, cheese mushrooms. Everything I like perfectly made. Called in the order, 20 minutes to pick up. Ready and hot. Very friendly people.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is a fun place to eat if you like mythical creatures. All of the walls are decorated with Bigfoot, Mothman, and other similar creatures. The pizza was good. They have many options to suit your taste buds.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Mythical Pizza is a place to meet with friends and family plus they are very friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing food and great service! Awesome atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mythical pizza is the place to stop. We came through town late and just happened to find it on the map. So glad we did. The food was great and the customer service was excellent. Don't forget to check out the merch! We will be back for sure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cryptids and quick tasty pizza. Friendly owners and staff.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Really nice pizza place the pizza was really good! The manager was really nice!

My experience with Mythical Pizza was flat-out horrible and ranks among the worst takeout meals I've ever purchased. I was looking forward to a great dinner, but instead, I received food that was both poorly prepared and frankly, concerningly undercooked.
The main attraction, the pizza, was an absolute failure. It arrived looking and tasting as though it had barely touched the oven. The dough was pale, the cheese wasn't fully melted, and it was so soft that we literally had to put it in our own oven just to make it edible. For a professional pizza shop, serving a product that requires the customer to finish cooking it is entirely unacceptable.
The side order of chicken wings was no better. We specifically requested them to be crispy, but they arrived soggy, dripping, and looked severely undercooked on the inside. This was a major disappointment and a significant food safety concern. We did not feel comfortable eating them and threw them out.
Overall, this was a massive waste of money and a completely frustrating experience. I highly recommend potential customers avoid Mythical Pizza until they can reliably serve properly cooked food.

Food is always hit and miss. I could care less it’s all kiosks but the extra toasted crust is soggy one day and perfect the next. I can’t risk the funds on that.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3