Mythical Pizza
1855 Valley Rd Suite #200, Berkeley Springs
(304) 402-6984
Customers' Favorites
E T the Extra-Toppings Supreme Craft Pizza
Your Pizza Your Way 13 Full Size Pizza
ChildāS Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
2 Cheese Pepperoni Black Olive Pizza
Black Olives Mushrooms Pizza
Cheesy Garlic Bread Sticks
Nightmare on Braxie Street
Mothman's Pepperoni Roll
The Mothman Strikes Back
Uncle Beak Without Bacon
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best pizza in town by far. My only complaint is that I've ordered "fresh basil" on my pizza the last 4 times, and I haven't gotten it. When I checked today before leaving and pointed out there wasn't fresh basil, I was told they switched to dehydrated. Not a huge deal, except they charge an extra $1.75 for fresh basil and are putting about $0.05 worth of dehydrated on. Knocks it down from the 5 stars I would have given it otherwise.
Visiting in laws in Berkeley springs for Thanksgiving. Place seemed highly rated so grabbed a quick pizza here. Good price. Tasted really good. Flavor better than most things we have back home. Will 100% stop here again next time Iām in town š also the atmosphere is chill. Very unique
Absolutely loved the pizza! The best I have had in years! Sauce was excellent, plenty of cheese, pepperoni, sausage. Crust was just right.
Highly recommend trying one of their pizza if you are in the Berkeley Springs area.
Highly recommend trying one of their pizza if you are in the Berkeley Springs area.
You May Also Like
Dairy Queen - 1822 Valley Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Angus & Ale - 146 Southridge Dr
![]()
Gastropubs, American, Barbeque, Seafood, Vegan
Coolfont Resort - 3621 Cold Run Valley Rd
![]()
American, Resorts, Bed & Breakfast, Pet Friendly