Honestly this place gets 0 stars from me. I had my baby shower cake, cupcakes and cookies done here. And it looks nothing like how we told them. How the picture was supposed to be. They spelled my baby’s name wrong on the cake and they acted like they couldn’t fix a simple letter into the correct letter. The icing design was supposed to look completely different and it was PINK. And he’s a boy. lol. Don’t recommend this place AT ALL. This is ridiculous and makes a pregnant woman MAD.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Rachel
We have ordered cupcakes / cakes from here several times in the past and just realized I have never left a review. Sugar Pie has been our go-to when we need a cake that looks great and tastes great too! They never disappoint. Ordered 60 cupcakes for our son’s party recently and couldn’t have been happier. SO cute and they taste sooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Birthday Cake
Ashley Schultz
We have often stopped in and gotten sweet treats, but recently made a custom cake order for my daughters smash cake! It was absolutely perfect. The customer service and communication was exceptional. The cake turned out exactly as requested. We will definitely continue to support this business. I have never been disappointed!!! Highly recommend.
Beccah Griffith
Ordered over 100 cupcakes for a wedding in 6 different flavors with custom decorations and Sugar Pie absolutely met and exceeded our expectations. Cupcakes were delicious and beautiful!
Dietary restrictions: The gluten-free strawberry champagne cupcakes we ordered were among the most popular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
Kayla Falls
I often get cupcakes from there or cheesecake, but recently we got a Velaris birthday cake for my daughter and it was a huge hit. 10/10
Christine Johnson
My family and I LOVE Sugar Pie Bakery! Absolutely everything we’ve gotten from here has been phenomenal- and the staff is even better! So thankful to have such an amazing local bakery. We will be clients for LIFE! 🩷
Marie
Everything is WAAAAY overpriced. The cannoli $5.50 was too dense and hard. It is difficult to take a bite and huge chunks break off whether you want it or not. The cannoli filling texture is grainy and doesn't taste like traditional cannoli filling with smooth ricotta cheese. The sugar cookie $3.75 was thick but dry. I did NOT want to spend $5.50 on one cannoli but I thought I was at least going to enjoy it. I didn't even want to finish it. This is the first cannoli I didn't love.
Amanda Haid
These are the worst macroons I have ever had they were over done and fell apart!! I will not be back!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Maurice Porter
The cupcakes are overcooked and terrible! A chocolate cupcake with the Oreo filling on top of the worst cupcakes. The fun Fetty were beyond dry the peanut butter cup cookie, OK cupcake was overcooked and the chocolate is not a good quality my honest opinion.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Leila
I ordered a cake for my daughters birthday. It was beautiful and delicious but I was disappointed that they didn't get happy birthday on the cake with my daughters name. I specifically asked for that at least twice in email. The whole email ordering process did not feel smooth and I don't think I was asking for much. Responses took days over the course of a few emails. I got the vibe that they didn’t care about me as a customer.
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Cheesecake Brownie, French Macarons
Natalie Welling
My husband ordered me a gluten free cake for my birthday and it was fabulous! Not only was it tasty, it was also beautiful! I appreciate a bakery that can accommodate my allergen/dietary needs! Thank you so much for making my 35th birthday GREAT!
Christine Pearson
Amazing staff with new fun bakery finds each day
Danielle Hayes
This is the second year I’ve gotten my child’s birthday cake from Sugar Pie, and they did not disappoint. They were so easy to work with, understanding and just kind. The cake was out of this world, and the way it made my child’s face light up was priceless. Very fairly priced, the taste is impeccable and it’s just a beautiful cake (again)
Amanda Cavender
I placed a personalized cookie order for graduation. I emailed them with a picture and specifics of what I wanted. They went above and beyond to keep in contact with me about any questions. The cookies were spot on and absolutely delicious!!! We got so many compliments! They may be considered pricy compared to other places, but considering time, quality, and detail put into their food I would definitely choose them again.
Honestly this place gets 0 stars from me. I had my baby shower cake, cupcakes and cookies done here. And it looks nothing like how we told them. How the picture was supposed to be. They spelled my baby’s name wrong on the cake and they acted like they couldn’t fix a simple letter into the correct letter. The icing design was supposed to look completely different and it was PINK. And he’s a boy. lol. Don’t recommend this place AT ALL. This is ridiculous and makes a pregnant woman MAD.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We have ordered cupcakes / cakes from here several times in the past and just realized I have never left a review. Sugar Pie has been our go-to when we need a cake that looks great and tastes great too! They never disappoint. Ordered 60 cupcakes for our son’s party recently and couldn’t have been happier. SO cute and they taste sooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Birthday Cake
We have often stopped in and gotten sweet treats, but recently made a custom cake order for my daughters smash cake! It was absolutely perfect. The customer service and communication was exceptional. The cake turned out exactly as requested. We will definitely continue to support this business. I have never been disappointed!!! Highly recommend.
Ordered over 100 cupcakes for a wedding in 6 different flavors with custom decorations and Sugar Pie absolutely met and exceeded our expectations. Cupcakes were delicious and beautiful!
Dietary restrictions: The gluten-free strawberry champagne cupcakes we ordered were among the most popular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes
I often get cupcakes from there or cheesecake, but recently we got a Velaris birthday cake for my daughter and it was a huge hit. 10/10
My family and I LOVE Sugar Pie Bakery! Absolutely everything we’ve gotten from here has been phenomenal- and the staff is even better! So thankful to have such an amazing local bakery. We will be clients for LIFE! 🩷
Everything is WAAAAY overpriced. The cannoli $5.50 was too dense and hard. It is difficult to take a bite and huge chunks break off whether you want it or not. The cannoli filling texture is grainy and doesn't taste like traditional cannoli filling with smooth ricotta cheese. The sugar cookie $3.75 was thick but dry. I did NOT want to spend $5.50 on one cannoli but I thought I was at least going to enjoy it. I didn't even want to finish it. This is the first cannoli I didn't love.
These are the worst macroons I have ever had they were over done and fell apart!! I will not be back!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
The cupcakes are overcooked and terrible! A chocolate cupcake with the Oreo filling on top of the worst cupcakes. The fun Fetty were beyond dry the peanut butter cup cookie, OK cupcake was overcooked and the chocolate is not a good quality my honest opinion.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
I ordered a cake for my daughters birthday. It was beautiful and delicious but I was disappointed that they didn't get happy birthday on the cake with my daughters name. I specifically asked for that at least twice in email. The whole email ordering process did not feel smooth and I don't think I was asking for much. Responses took days over the course of a few emails. I got the vibe that they didn’t care about me as a customer.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
great place! in love with their macarons!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Cheesecake Brownie, French Macarons
My husband ordered me a gluten free cake for my birthday and it was fabulous! Not only was it tasty, it was also beautiful! I appreciate a bakery that can accommodate my allergen/dietary needs! Thank you so much for making my 35th birthday GREAT!
Amazing staff with new fun bakery finds each day
This is the second year I’ve gotten my child’s birthday cake from Sugar Pie, and they did not disappoint. They were so easy to work with, understanding and just kind. The cake was out of this world, and the way it made my child’s face light up was priceless. Very fairly priced, the taste is impeccable and it’s just a beautiful cake (again)
I placed a personalized cookie order for graduation. I emailed them with a picture and specifics of what I wanted. They went above and beyond to keep in contact with me about any questions. The cookies were spot on and absolutely delicious!!! We got so many compliments! They may be considered pricy compared to other places, but considering time, quality, and detail put into their food I would definitely choose them again.
Loading...