Muttley's | Downtown

CLOSED
$$ •

Muttley's | Downtown Reviews

Write a review

July 2021

There are no words adequate to express our disappointment with Muttley's. It's been a while since we were there, but after seeing some of the other reviews I felt compelled to chime in. We were looking to sample the local fare a year or so back and this place looked inviting from the outside. Inside was a whole different story. The atmosphere was dingy with poor ventilation, the wait was overlong considering the number of empty tables, and the service was disinterested in even keeping up appearances of caring.

The food, though, was truly horrendous. This place puts itself out there as a steakhouse, so of course we ordered the steak. I had a NY Strip and my husband got the ribeye. One was undercooked and the other was overcooked (how is that even possible?), and both had the basic flavor of congealed, burnt sawdust. The portions were tiny and the salad was literally wilted. The best part? The $70.00 price tag. Just drive right on by and go to McDonald's, it will be a better experience.