Pickaway Pickins
$ • American
Hours:
3556 Seneca Trail N, Pickaway
(304) 772-4500
About Pickaway Pickins
Customers' Favorites
Pickaway Pickins Reviews
Share your opinion about Pickaway Pickins
Great food, great service!
This place blows it out of the water. We truly love it! It's a staple of visiting Monroe county, which is 2 hours away. The fried chicken is amazing. Yesterday was a very tender, center cut sirloin with a blue cheese topping and homemade cooked cabbage. Way better than a chain restaurant. For dessert, was a Andes mint pie that was exceptional.
I visited the restaurant for my first time on Sunday. The hamburger steak was cooked to perfection! No other restaurant has the char-grilled taste like this! My friend got the hamburger, the best he has had! The owner was super nice, in having a conversation! I will be back, and highly recommend Pickaway.
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8PM |
Pickaway Pickins is a popular restaurant known for its fresh and fantastic food. The service is exceptional, and the staff is highly regarded. The diner is famous for its pies, with a variety of flavors available, including the entire pie for takeout. The salad bar and homemade soups are also a hit, with the vegetable beef soup being a standout. The menu features a range of sandwiches, including burgers, and the Rib special is a must-try. Customers praise the fried chicken for its amazing quality and the char-grilled taste of the hamburger steak, which is cooked to perfection. The tender center cut sirloin with blue cheese topping, homemade cooked cabbage, and Andes mint pie for dessert are highly recommended. The restaurant is clean, with friendly staff, and offers delicious home-style food that makes it worth going out of the way. Pickaway Pickins remains a favorite spot for delicious meals and great experiences.