Italian Restaurants near Teays Valley

“Very surprised that this place has such a sub par review. I'm a truck driver and it visited here on. 7/14/25 in the evening with my 2 granddaughters. Our food was great and the service was awesome. Like someone else started, there seemed to only be one person working but he was prompt and very nice. I would definitely come here again. We ordered a Philly sub, honey mustard wings and a calzone. Photos attached“

“Just had a good meal! Service was excellent! Will definitely return! A+“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ all day everyday!!!“

“Best pizza in the area in my humble opinion. Consistently good. Always ready fast and cooked to perfection exactly as I've ordered it. My pizza is always correct. Once I was missing a ranch dip but I noticed minutes away and they quickly rectified it. I haven't gotten pizza anywhere else in town since I tried theirs after a couple bad experiences at Gino's in Eleanor. They are reasonably priced and have great family deals.“

“The food year seems to be under seasoned for the most part. The service was excellent. Good hostess. If you’re looking for good seafood , you’ve come to the right place or if you want a good steak or chicken, but if you’re looking for a burger joint, this is not it. The lobster bisque needed more seasoning and so did the rice that came with the meal. My wife and I loved the appetizers. Overall experience 85 out of 100.“

“We just had one of the best meals of our lives! Their blackened tuna bites were as good as tuna we've had right off the boat in Hawaii! I'll be dreaming about them tonight in my sleep! Their hush puppies we incredible as was the broiled cod! Great service as well! The owner was friendly and accessible making sure everyone's Valentine night was perfect! Thanks Again!“

“I was on my way to Michigan and stopped by this place on the way. While ordering they were having trouble with their system but decided to take care of 2 hungry kids and a hungry dad. I ordered the chicken salad and ordered pasta with sauce on the side, 2 meatballs, and also got some garlic bread. The food was perfect. On my way out, I asked how I could pay and the lady behind the counter said “It’s on me.” I don’t take that lightly and could be more appreciative of the gesture. I’ll be stopping by again on future trips.

Kid-friendliness: They also made a custom pasta dish that the kids liked. Thank you!“

“Food was great, hot, tasted, and excellent service“

“Ordered 3 Baked Spaghetti’s & one order of ten wings! Crazy portions and the garlic bread was yummy! Great thing about their containers is that you may refrigerate & bake again! Very swift in ordering over the phone so tipped the pick up window 10%. $61 for everything but totally could feed 6 people if needed! Local favorite & close to the Interstate Ramps.“