Penny's Diner
$ •
Hours:
1170 W Flaming Gorge Way, Green River
(307) 875-3500
About Penny's Diner
Customers' Favorites
Penny's Diner Reviews
Share your opinion about Penny's Diner
We stopped by for lunch and their flattop was down. We’re so glad we stayed to enjoy delicious club and turkey sandwiches on toasted sourdough bread. Onion rings and fries were wonderful and fresh. Our server, Jenny S was friendly and efficient. Her welcome helped two weary travelers to feel at home.
The cook was great and the food all tasted good. But ther Server was terrible, they didn't write down our order as we were making in so as a result, I got the wrong cheese on my burger, it was a single instead of a double, I got onions when I said no onions, and no cheese on my fries when I asked for cheese fries. and that was just my order.
Awesome thanks for the hospitality
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Open 24 hours |
| Tuesday | Open 24 hours |
| Wednesday | Open 24 hours |
| Thursday | Open 24 hours |
| Friday | Open 24 hours |
| Saturday | Open 24 hours |
| Sunday | Open 24 hours |
Penny's Diner offers a mix of experiences. The food is generally regarded as good, and the atmosphere is described as adorable and cool. The diner is a classic-style place that feels both nostalgic and dependable, making every visit a pleasure. It serves some of the best green chili in town—especially when Don Pedro’s is closed—and the smothered crispy tots are highly recommended for their crispy texture and flavorful green chili, offering pure comfort on a plate. Customers enjoy big food portions and a 50s theme that creates a fun, welcoming environment. The staff is friendly and attentive, with servers like Kamar and Cori praised for their fantastic, respectful service. Food often arrives quickly and hot, with the burgers being top notch. The diner maintains a level of cleanliness that’s respectable given staffing and clientele. Customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the good food served with heart. While some have experienced confusion with the app-based menu and ordering system, many still find Penny's Diner to be a charming and dependable spot worth returning to. Overall, the decor and music add to the cute vibe, and the prices are fair for large portions and tasty meals.