Papa Johns Pizza

553 N 3rd St, Laramie
(307) 742-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eric Henderson

Fantastic supporters of #SMILEwithSANTA and KOCA935FM Laramie WY USA

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shivanand Sheshappanavar

This is pizza with mushroom topping and extra cheese. Pathetic.
I trashed the pizza after eating a slice of it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Eric Cummings

What is this? You guys didn't even try.

Marye Martin

I had to go to my bank and put in a dispute because they like to tip themselves. Had to call customer service to complain about this. Definitely won’t be ordering from them again and will suggest everyone else to look at their bank statements to see if you were charged extra for a tip

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Anastacia Rose

The pizza was perfect and done right on time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Petz

The best pizza ever. Try the stuff crust. It would be 5 stars but it's expensive.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Tim Grudzinski

Website tells everyone they are open until two Am on Saturday. Walke in at 7:20 and they told me they were closed. I know it’s hard to get people that care anymore but whoever is in charge should fire every employee that was “working” June 14 2025

Alanah

Pizza was great!

Erin Tolbert

Despite me unselecting the extra cheese they still added it anyway. They forgot the sausage and had to add it after the pizza was baked. And only 2 slices were cut through all the way. Plus the taste overall was less than mediocre.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Holly Z

Very disappointed. We ordered a garlic stuffed crust pizza Well Done. It was so doughy that we had to put it in our oven to cook it to be edible. All the extra toppings were all in a bunch on 3 pieces of pizza instead of being spread out on one half. I picked it up on time, but it wasn't even hot. Had trouble ordering with the app also. The price of the pizza was almost $30. That's outrageous!

Food: 2

N S

Yikes. The pizza tasted like it was an hour old, dry and sad. Barely any cheese or toppings. “Cardboard” gets thrown around too often, but in this case- it deserves it. The chicken was actually repulsive, made me feel gross and nauseous. They just like drizzle some sauce over the pathetic “chicken” too? At least spin them in the sauce…
There’s a ton of other options, go elsewhere!

Food: 1

Lorrie Alvarado

Pizza and wings are good but please send some Parmesan Cheese and Crushed Chili with your door dash orders - if we need to pay for it put it on your menu please - it should be an automatic condiment like ketchup for fries

Robin

So disappointed. Ordered New York style crust...it wasn't. For 22 bucks I expect more. The crust was so soggy it fell apart and it had next to no toppings. Last time I order from here, it has gone way downhill. Just sad.

raul carrillo

Always love it thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza

Salvador Martinez

Poor pizza bad wings and horrible customer service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Loading...