12 Best Bars in Sheridan

“I’m a music producer/dj out of South Dakota, and got the opportunity to play a show at Local Nakamal. I didn’t know what to expect, I had never visited Wyoming before! I can happily say that I was treated with the utmost kindness and respect! The atmosphere is awesome, I haven’t experienced anything like it in my travels thus far! Staff is very kind, and very knowledgeable. I hope to be back again soon!“

“We stopped here on our way back to MN and Kyle was our bartender, talk about a bartender who's knowledgeable and personable absolutely one of the best bartenders we've had in a bar that far exceed our expectations. Highly recommend to all of our friends and family.“

“The bartenders, the atmosphere, the music!“

“The best food in town by far! May be late night but its delicious!“

“Omg what an amazing little hidden gem! I wish this was closer to my home. If i get back to Sheridan again I'm coming here! I mean obviously the wine tasting set up is genius and a great deal to try before you buy. The selection is on point for sure and constantly updated with new items. The staff was fabulous and friendly. The selection at the liquor store was off the charts! But seriously i have to tell you the absolute deal clincher for me was the food here. The pizzas were freaking delicious and paired SO good with the wines. Grapes on a flatbread, who knew that could be so good. It was heavenly. ???????“

“Karin is the absolute best! She always makes everyone feel like family. Suttons is the only place we go because of her!!!! <3“

“One of the coolest bars we have been to.“

“Very good service for only one bar tender / waitress. Options were good for my family of 4. Kids like pizza 🍕. Grandpa likes beer 🍺 🤣 and my French dip sandwich and fries were delicious 😋. Grandma liked her hamburger 🍔 and fries too 😋. It was very convenient to have the bar/ restaurant right inside of the hotel 🏨 ! We didn't have to go out in the cold and rainey ⛈🌫 night.“

“I was in town for a couple of days and ate at the Pony Grill and Bar two days in a row. Let me just say they have an awesome menu and there's so much more I want to try. Such a good selection of food. I tried two different items on the menu and it was very delicious. I will definitely be back!“

“Great beer, awesome crew!“

“We have ate here a few of times now, food and service always good!! The gluten free pizza is so good. Some of the best we have had!“

“We ate here Friday to celebrate the last day of school . The hibachi chef (Yogi) was absolutely amazing , wonderful, entertaining, and so awesome with the kids ! All the staff took their time to make the children and adults feel special ! They went above and beyond any restaurant in Sheridan . And the food was amazing and the portions were huge!“