New American Restaurants near Bexley, OH

“The pizza was good. We split a mushroom one. If you are really hungry you could probably eat a whole pie yourself. We split a small salad and one pie and we were good. Service was great and food came out pretty quick. It was a bit loud and holding a conversation was cumbersome. Beer selection is good. Several local brews on tap or in can. No mints on the way out… booParking: We got lucky and grabbed the only available spot in the parking lot next to the restaurant. I imagine there is more parking near by and we were there at the busiest time for dinner.“

“Outstanding isn’t a strong enough word for the food and service. Incredible experience and likely the best dining experience that I’ve ever had in Columbus. Only complaint was the temperature in the restaurant. We were freezing for the entire two hours that we were in there.“

“This was my 2nd time visit. Special occasion. 75th birthday. Called ahead to have a bottle of champagne chilling at the table upon our arrival and to please have a table in a corner for the five of us elderly hard hearing folks. The manager and staff were Great! My new favorite restaurant.“

“Amazing experience here! We sat at the bar and the food was flavorful, and lively. Sean served us creative, complex cocktails. I mean truly memorable. Think you've had a good mojito? Try one here. Seriously, any of Sean's creations will engage flavors in a rare and elevated way. I don't think I've had a better cocktail experience.“

“Went to Natalie's for the first time last night. I truly enjoyed it. Just a wonderful evening of jazz, people, drinks, food. I will definitely be returning again. The only thing charging $18 for three wings. That's a little pricey. Next time I'll just get the big pizza, but Natalie is definitely a hidden gem in Columbus. ??“

“Absolutely exquisite cuisine. Carefully prepared and intentional. The staff is consistently kind and attentive, and the management clearly cares about their customers.Their happy hour is extraordinarily affordable and a really obvious choice.“

“Nice little spot for dinner. The bartender recommended the meatloaf. (I was dining at the bar). It is BIG... and delicious.Entrees are 20-30, and the Manhattan is pretty darn good!Mike and Wyatt do a terrific job of taking care of the bar.I'll be back.I will definitely be back.“

“This hidden gem is absolutely amazing. From the food to the service - this place is 5 stars across the board. We’ve ordered different menu items every visit, and they’re always top notch. The short rib burger is in my top 3 best burgers of all time. Definitely one of my favorite spots in Columbus!“

“Visited Columbus for a few weeks and tried dinner at many restaurants. This was the only restaurant that I made sure to circle back to. Everything that was ordered as a group was shared and it was all a hit!!! Almost all of the appetizers Spoon pudding, Deviled eggs, wings, tots, mussels, wrapped dates, pie, Beet salad, just to name a few!“

“Impeccable service, intimate booths, well stocked bar, and approachable feel. Our waiter made me feel like we were old friends, he was accommodating and helpful with selections. They have a well stocked bar and I had an excellent manhattan and even a vesper. The wedge had some of the best blue cheese dressing I've ever had, and I've had my fair share of wedges. The burger was delicious and the sesame bun was perfect. It felt super cozy and inviting!“

“Only regrets....not taking pics of the apps! Brussel sprouts, deviled eggs and pot stickers oh my! So good! Two thumbs up for the burgers and Philly too! The pep pizza and margarita pizza were yummy! Only upgrade recommended is a balsamic glaze drizzled on top of the Margherita pizza. Thanks for having cloud chaser on draft and supporting the Crooked can in old Hilliard!“

“Very nice establishment!! We have always walked by, wondering what those great smells were a part of, now we know, met some friends there who were regulars and the food was delicious. Service was great, never had to ask for a refill of water or wine.“

“The food was unique and deliciously memorable! The drinks and their menu were creative and whimsical. The service was absolutely fabulous. We very much appreciated the chance to taste different options before buying a bottle. We settled on the apple brandy but we will be back for the bottled in bond and chamomile gin! The decor was such a great blend of natural and industrial elements. It gave the feeling of a gourmet restaurant and a relaxed intimate gathering space all at once. The only thing I would have changed was the volume of the music. Everyone was shouting over the "background music" which made ordering and conversation in general somewhat difficult.Parking: A bit of a walk from the parking lot but worth it!“

“The environment here is always buzzing and lively, and the staff is always going above and beyond. I go with my friends for casual dinners and drinks at least twice a month, and I've never had a bad experience. I absolutely love the grilled cheese bites with tomato soup, and I love how much the drink menu changes.“

“We had an incredible experience when we were in town for the Arnold. We made an unplanned decision to have lunch at The Guild House and couldn’t have been more impressed, by not only the food, but their incredible hospitality. They’re doing right.“

“Very impressed with this place. The atmosphere is open & inviting, service was solid. Food was the real thing though, it was excellent. We went for brunch and got the hash, which was so fabulously delicious. We shared the donuts as an appetizer and they were also excellent. I will absolutely return.“

“Went in to celebrate my wife's birthday. The staff who helped us knew it was her bday, it was mentioned 3-4 times which was cool! Happy hour before dinner was nice, drinks were very good. Bar staff was kind. Dinner service was great, food was delicious. Spent 2.5 hours there or so and enjoyed my evening with the wife!“

“Ate here twice in the past 2 days. Gyro hit the spot for dinner last night, had to go back again for lunch today. Carryout is super fast, friendly service & quite the tasty meal. I love the crunchy bits of gyro meat too. Will definitely be back!“

“What a great place; Modern open decor with a cozy feel. They offer several Vegan and GF options, Our food was fantastic! We had the Fish Sandwich, Beef Chow Fung, and the 40 Yolk Tagliatelle. I tried them all and they were great. I had the Tropicalia Cocktail, it was refreshing and delicious. Our server was knowledgeable and attentive. Highly recommend.“

“We had a great waiter! The food was good and the drinks were great! The only complaint was our table was small but we didn’t make a reservation so it was hard to get a table!! I loved the expresso martini and mimosas!! My calamari, shrimp, and pizza were so good!! I’d definitely come back!!“

“Fast, friendly, super clean and the food was flavorful. Didn’t even need salt and pepper which isn’t always the case with health conscious spots. I got the turkey and sweet potato dish. If you’re deciding on if you should get the green smoothie or not.. do it!!“

“Stopped by Arch City Tavern during happy hour. The Rueben eggrolls are phenomenal. The chicken wings are more like pigeon wings. They were so tiny we ordered another order as soon as they came out. The Buffalo blue cheese was good though. But I definitely wouldn't order the wings again though.“

“Dining at Alqueira was the experience that I’ve been searching for but not finding amongst the restaurants who seem to be trying too hard. The locally sourced and changing menu is prepared and presented in simple ways yet delivers deep and delicious flavors across all their dishes. We’ll be back the next time we visit Columbus.“

“Food was good, not the best but good. Service was excellent. My strawberry shortcake pancakes were good, they were a little raw. Sft very good. Eggs Benedict were ok, avocado was too ripe. The sauce on the eggs was bland. No flavor at all.“

“Nice bar with a relaxed modern atmosphere. You have to order everything at the bar and then bring it to your seating. I especially liked that there were 2 people playing chess and that the bartender came up with a non alcoholic cocktail I really enjoyed.“

“The smash burger is like the prototypical good burger. Perfect crust. Perfect amount of cheese and pickles. Add some ketchup and it is magical. And for 9$ (6$ on Wednesday, 9$ with fries) it is a steal.The atomic fireballs are deliciously cheesy and complemented the food well.The drinks are also great too.10/10 Would come back next Wednesday.Parking: parking lot is tiny, you'll need to find street parking near the residential streets on the side.“

“An awesome pub! A lot of people were here for lunch and there were only two servers during lunch time, but they were efficient and friendly. The food was served fast and tasted juicy and fresh. They also had daily specials. I was here for the taco deal on Wednesday. The taco tasted fresh and juicy with amazing coney sauce.Vegetarian options: Salads“

“I love this place! I ate lunch here every dayI was in the city! I ate in and did take out. Brussel sprouts, cauliflower bites, the BECKY!!!… everything was delicious. There was one day they were very short staffed so service was understandably slow, but everyone was still kind, efficient and really killed it honestly! The little red corvette frozen marg was amazing!My only complaint is that I tripped on the broken floor boards at the table behind the bar… the floor there is pretty damaged.Dietary restrictions: Vegan and vegetarian options“

“First time here and I must say I will be back the place makes you feel welcomed and have a home body experience the chicken and waffles was amazing the tequila sunrise is a must try I sat upfront and seen the place become crowded so it's a lot of people who come through I will be back that will be my go to places for breakfast every time I visit ColumbusParking: If you can find a spot on a Saturday morning in the front you got a good spot but it's a parking lot across from it and you can park there if it's not crowded“

“We looked at making a reservation on a Friday and they were booked up until 815pm. So we just decided to stop by anyways and they actually had comfortable seating at the bar. Our bartender/server was very attentive. She was very knowledgeable about the different signature cocktails they offered. The first mixed drink we tried was "Whats the buzz"! I believe that the correct name. You are to take these two flowers that make your mouth number for a couple of minutes and then drink some of the drink. I don't know how I feel about that drink. The second one she tried was the "Agave Cooler" and was good. For our meal, she has the fried chicken sliders, and I had the New York Strip well done. The sliders were good, but the steak was a bit dry. It seemed like they put it on the grill for the grill marks and then nuked it in the microwave. The steak had no juice at all underneath it on the plate. If I ate steak sauce with my steaks, today would have been the day to do so. I told the server, and she knocked some off of my bill. I didn't expect anything from telling her, but it was much appreciated. I'd still give them a 5 star for the overall experience!!“

“Lisa was very helpful in reviewing banquet and room options for our daughter's rehersal dinner coming up this July. She worked with us to make it an affordable endeavor without cutting corners that other venues suggested. We are looking forward to the dinner, while resting assured it will be a high quality event to be enjoyed by all of our guests.“

“This place is awesome! Great food and great service, Kenna was our server and it was so refreshing to be served by someone who actually takes their job seriously and tries to make it an experience for you!!! we will definitely be back whenever we visit Columbus again :)“

“Went here to eat brunch but they said they only do brunch on weekends. Service was good and I ordered tavern stack burger. It had tomato jam and it worked with other ingredients. We ordered corn bread for appetizer. It was really good too. Definitely will visit again to try brunch if i have chance.“

“Phenomenal food and drink, and great service. The server steered us in the right direction on cocktails which landed us on a classic old fashioned and the magic of the unicorn, both of which hit the spot. For food, we started with the tempura cauliflower which set the bar very, very high. Meaty and satisfying, with a delicious onion topping and delicate curry sauce. We went on to the grilled octopus, which was honestly some of the best I have had - tender as you can get. Finally, we shared the mushroom pasta with the added short rib. The split portion was more than enough to round out the meal for us. This dish was incredibly rich but it was topped off by a clever and bright salsa verde that brought it all into balance. As we finished up, the place started really filling up and I'm not surprised. We headed out after picking up a bottle of black walnut old fashioned mix to take home.“

“It's your typical industrial chic bar, with a decent selection of local drafts, and service that meets expectations.It's a short but noticable walk from the mall, especially in the rain. There are free parking garages all around.I didn't personally care for the draft choices, but it was perfect for my situation, which was to catch up with some friends after an all day event. The hidden gem of this place is their Ramen Spiced Mac n Cheese. It was so good and packed a little heat. I'm considering going back for that alone.Vegetarian options: While there aren't a ton of options, they are clearly marked on the menu and I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of my dish.Parking: There are free lots and garages all around this town center.Wheelchair accessibility: Typical wheelchair accessibility but parking is a little far.“

“My company had our holiday party here and it was absolutely amazing. I loved the ambiance of the establishment and the setup for dinner. All the staff we're super amazing and hands on the entire time. They engaged with us at every stage of preparing our meal and we all walked away with great tips. As you can see from my photos, our meal was absolutely amazing and delicious. I also loved the open bar and being offered the opportunity to take an old fashioned cocktail making course. I highly recommend anyone to not only book this venue, but to also check out their other events as well.“

“Had a fantastic experience at Parlay. The atmosphere was incredible. The perfect spot to watch March Madness. My bartenders were super attentive and friendly, and gave recommendations for other things to do while in town. Food was delicious. 5/5 stars and would absolutely come back if in the area again.“

“Stopped in at 4pm on 4/14/24 and placed a to go order. I didn't catch the hostesses name but she was incredibly friendly and helpful as I had never been there before today. I did happen to trade some words with Jesse Perkins who prepares the food and he explained some of the process of what goes into a seafood boil and what sets Kai's apart from the rest. I could tell Jesse loves his job, it was apparent the owner treats his staff very well. Jesse was incredibly passionate about what he does and it shows in the food he prepares. I can't rate the atmosphere yet as I havent stayed to eat but the 10 minutes I was there it seemed very enjoyable. 10/10 recommend and I will absolutely be returning.“

“We had a nice time at Canabar last night. Our friends live in the neighborhood so we stopped in for a drink. The band was going strong and everyone had a good time. This is a neighborhood hangout but the bartender was friendly and invited us to come back.“

“Me and my friend went here to catch up for drinks and dinner - Bodega is a great place for times like that. I've been coming to Bodega since college, I always enjoyed ambiance and service there which is always goooood. We ordered two appetizers to split - Brisket Queso & Crispy Chicken Wings (w/BBQ Sauce). Both were so good, the queso had brisket from their sister location at Bristol Republic, had great smoky flavor. The BBQ wings were really good, super solid! I would definitely return here whenever I get the chance. Their draft list is supreme, they have options for everyone! I've never had a bad experience here!“

“This is a nice quiet little place off the beaten path. The staff are always great and the atmosphere is always nice. The drink selection is good and I know they have food but I've never ordered any. It is definitely a nice place to just relax with friends or even by yourself.“

“We have been trying to get to the Rossi for sometime . Finally made it and we were not disappointed! We also very surprised to find that our reservation was so early we could take advantage of happy hour drinks and half price appetizers! Between the three of us, we started with Brussels, fried ravioli and bread service. We do not often rave about restaurant bread, however, this bread was amazing. Fluffy, crusty, and perfectly balance with the creamy butter it came with. Apps were great! As for mains, two of us had Pasta Rossi along with one lasagna. Every one of us enjoyed our dinner. Delicious. A small imperfection about this restaurant is that there is no bar to have a drink at or wait. The bar is usurped by seating reserved for eating patrons. Our table wasn't quite ready when we arrived for our reservation. Instead of being able to wait at the bar we walked to another bar within a close distance, but it would've been nice to just have stayed in one spot . Food is delicious, service was spot on and the vibe was great.“

“ATMOSPHERE 4 BELLY RUBS APP SIZE N/A BELLY RUBS APP TASTE N/A BELLY RUBS ENTRÉE SIZE 4 BELLY RUBS ENTRÉE TASTE 4 BELLY RUBS WAITING 3.5 BELLY RUBS SERVICE 4 BELLY RUBS CLEANLINESS 4 BELLY RUBS OVERALL 3.92 BELLY RUBS Was in town with a few hours to kill before I had to get to the airport. I located this on Yelp, and swung into Milestone 229. It is not a usual place that I would grab lunch, I felt out of place dressed casual and everyone else was in suits and ties, but it wasn't bad. Waitress was nice but was busy and took a while to get refills. Food was decent size; I had the prime rib sandwich with the dipping sauce. It had a different flavor to it but was good and filling. The Park around it was under construction, and it was dusty, but I bet it is beautiful this summer when it is completed. I will be back again. Keep on Cookin!“

“I love this place. The service and the food are wonderful. The atmosphere is a bit brighter than most pubs/ sport bars; I like that. Recently, I was there and a bit disappointed, only because they had a party in the back half that was entirely too loud. We, my table mates and I, could not hear each other talk, and hardly think. It was not a good a time. A suggestion to the management would be to not accept large parties, or at least screen off that section so the sound could be deflected.They have the best onion rings, and rueben sandwichKid-friendliness: Has a kids menuWheelchair accessibility: Can get in, to the bathroom would be a challenge.“

“Place is in a hotel and very wide open, so hard to give it a good atmosphere score.Overall 5, food 5, service 5.Got the salmon. It was flat-put excellent. Nothing more to say. Will absolutely be back.Server was a junior at OSU and talked through her experience in going to SDSU then coming back to OSU. I believe her name was Taylor. This was the conversation my daughter needed to hear to make up her mind. She has since accepted the OSU offer and is totally stoked to go in the fall. Pass on my regards to Taylor as she was super friendly & helpful.Will go back!“

“The food we did end up getting was great. Unfortunately, the restaurant was ‘out of bread' so we weren't able to order the French toast - disappointing since it was one of the few ‘sweet' options for brunch. The Pineapple cocktail was great. I enjoyed the short rib hash, although the portion size is a little small. The entire meal took a little longer than expected, namely because our waitress went MIA for 20 min after taking our drink orders. Overall, a good experience, but poor form to run out of bread 2.5 hours into Sunday brunch.“

“Kabyle-Algerian Restaurant in Columbus.Thank you so much for the owner and his team who were very courteous, professional, and very welcoming. The food was fresh, hot, and very tasty. I would definitely be back for the famous Algerian Sandwich!Thank you again for the free chorba frik &bourek during Ramadan! May god bless your business with more success!“

“It was a really nice place and our server was great! She was really friendly and attentive. It’s a little cramped inside, but I imagine during the spring/summer it is much better when the patio area is opened up. I got the wings, and they were pretty decent. My friend’s steak was excellent, but another friend’s pasta was just alright. So, can’t say it’s a top spot for me or anything, but good enough that I’d go back!“

“I recently ordered breakfast from Four Seasons Kitchen. I had the Sausage Egg & Cheese Burrito and home fries. The home fries were very good. The burrito was fine, but could have used more flavor. It was mostly egg and potato, with too little sausage to really be noticeable. I wish I had had some hot sauce with me to at least give it some kick. Still, I'd eat there again.“

“Somebody on Facebook said y’all were better than Canes and as an avid Caniac I had to find out….and I’m not disappointed! The chicken itself was seasoned, the service was great everything was fresh. And who doesn’t love rewards!!! I’ll definitely be back because you guys did not “