50 Best American Restaurants in Columbus

“Kristinna was wonderful.Food is excellent. There was a lot of people at the restaurant and it was loud, which was great.Parking: Lots of people hanging out in the parking lot. Not leaving just hanging out. Leaving it difficult to get in and out.“

“Outstanding isn’t a strong enough word for the food and service. Incredible experience and likely the best dining experience that I’ve ever had in Columbus. Only complaint was the temperature in the restaurant. We were freezing for the entire two hours that we were in there.“

“This food is good!! Prices are amazing!4 of us ordered two appetizers, 4 meals, 2 alcoholic drinks and 2 sodas for just over $120. Review of food below:Wings: sauce is a little different. To me, it tastes like a cross between BBQ and teriyaki. Wings tasted ok, but I like my wings to be fried to crispy perfection, these were not. 3 out of 5.Crispy Thai shrimp: very good, had a ton of flavor. I would maybe fry them just a tad longer, but other than that, they were amazing. 4.5 out of 5.Crispy chicken tacos: girl, these r amazing. Easily a 5 out of 5. Super spicy too, so if you don't like spice, tell them to hold the pepper garnish.Crispy chicken plate: 5 out of 5. My daughter loved this.Chicken meatballs: now listen, my son ordered this and I thought it looked mad nasty, BUT he loved it and said he would def order again.My husband really liked the cactus juice drinks. He ain't even let me taste em. Stingy.We will be back, and I can't wait to try more things.Oh, I almost forgot, our server was amazing. I can't remember her name, but I've not had a better server that I can remember.“

“Delicious chef special of pan seared Chilean sea bass served over ramps and small roasted potatoes with a lemon-pea puree. For dessert a Basque cheesecake with cherries. All beautifully plated. Busy on a Saturday night, have reservations. This is a well known local favorite for fine dining.“

“Extremely welcoming and friendly environment with great food! Just as good of quality as a bigger name Italian Restaurant in Columbus for a more reasonable price. Fantastic service and you can really tell that it's family owned and the staff cares about the guests experience. Would highly recommend and will definitely be back!“

“Chloe was awesome! It was definitely an excellent experience. Be prepared to spend some $$$$$.Forcing me to coat check my suit jacket and charging me for it is really stupid, though, especially after I wore it for the paid burlesque show before the open nightclub time.The chicken strips were awful.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes there's an elevator.“

“My husband and I frequent highbank very often. We usually go in large groups with co-workers and we always make reservations in advanced. We are always well accommodated, we never wait long for drinks, and the food is always on point. We've been going for about 1.5 years now and we have only ever been disappointed once, and when we brought it up to the waitress she was very quick to fix the problem. My husband has done a few tours, made his own bottle of whiskey, and he has nothing but amazing things to say about that as well. I'm not a straight whiskey girl, more of a cocktail girl, and their cocktails never ever disappoint. This is the perfect location to have high quality food with refreshing, perfect cocktails. We recommend highbank to everyone we talk to when it comes to food and drinks.“

“The gyro omelette is highly recommended and will not disappoint. The hash browns were as crispy as you imagine hash browns should b. Will definitely come back to this diner one day.Service is great as well and sitting at the bar is fun experience.“

“Amazing experience here! We sat at the bar and the food was flavorful, and lively. Sean served us creative, complex cocktails. I mean truly memorable. Think you've had a good mojito? Try one here. Seriously, any of Sean's creations will engage flavors in a rare and elevated way. I don't think I've had a better cocktail experience.“

“Just go and eat here, full stop! Amazing Brisket and that was just the start! I ended up sampling most of the sides as well. Everything was great, super friendly staff, casual atmosphere. If I was a local this would definitely be a regular stop. Did I mention the wings?! They were amazing too. The wings are smoked before frying and I ordered them extra crispy! 10 out of 10 for everything. Great locally owned place and I wish them the best!“

“This place is Top Tier! From David, our Waiter to Dessert ? was PERFECT! The Bread Service with warm and soft Pretzel Bread, with whipped butter! Nobody has a better Bread Service! I had the Black Orchid Mocktail, Appetizer Surf and Turf (Scallops, Braised Short Ribs with Gnocchi and Black Garlic Jus) and my BFFFL had the Berries and Bubbles, THE LOBSTER MAC WAS EVERYTHING! The ridged pasta, with a silky-smooth Gruyére and Asiago Parmesan Béchamel Sauce and Succulent Lobster will be seared in my mind until the next time I am back in Columbus and I only had a spoonful from my Friend's plate! For Dessert, the Warm Butter Cake with Berries and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream was even better the next day!All I can say is GO! You won't be disappointed!“

“The only complaint I have is that if there is anything going wrong in the kitchen (like something burning ) you will smell it for your entire stay because of how open it isOther than that everything is phenomenal. Can get a bit pricey for the portions but very much worth it“

“Nice little spot for dinner. The bartender recommended the meatloaf. (I was dining at the bar). It is BIG... and delicious.Entrees are 20-30, and the Manhattan is pretty darn good!Mike and Wyatt do a terrific job of taking care of the bar.I'll be back.I will definitely be back.“

“Fist visit. Business entertainment for a party of 7. Round of cocktails followed by shared appetizers - roasted sausage, basil and mozzarella, and one other. Entrees were ricotta and sweet pea ravioli, lamb loin, seafood stew, and spinach gnocchi. All diners were happy campers. Seafood stew was probably the highlight. Shared desserts were tiramisu and vanilla bean cheesecake. Service was very good. Recommended! Damages with tip was $575.“

“Went to Natalie's for the first time last night. I truly enjoyed it. Just a wonderful evening of jazz, people, drinks, food. I will definitely be returning again. The only thing charging $18 for three wings. That's a little pricey. Next time I'll just get the big pizza, but Natalie is definitely a hidden gem in Columbus. ??“

“5 stars all the way around haven’t tried anything on the menu that isn’t great. When at work a few of us eat or grab coffee here everyday. I live in grove city and make a trip here for lunch with the wife on the weekends sometimes. Great people great food. Hidden gem for sure.Kid-friendliness: Kids menu“

“This hidden gem is absolutely amazing. From the food to the service - this place is 5 stars across the board. We’ve ordered different menu items every visit, and they’re always top notch. The short rib burger is in my top 3 best burgers of all time. Definitely one of my favorite spots in Columbus!“

“The house salad dressing is one of the most delicious things I’ve ever had. I reeaallyy need the recipe for it. I live in TX and likely won’t wind up in Columbus again so… just think about it lol. The coconut shrimp were so good and our service was really great.“

“My son and I have never been here until today. We drove around for 30 minutes just looking for something that had good reviews and a decent menu. We are so so glad we chose this place. The Food was absolutely amazing. Our server, Tessa, recommended an appetizer and it did not disappoint. Everything we had tasted like perfection. My son ordered the morning glory burger and I’ve never heard more, “oh my gosh this is amazing” and “mmms” out of him. The loaded baked potato was cooked perfectly! We will be visiting here again!“

“Visited Columbus for a few weeks and tried dinner at many restaurants. This was the only restaurant that I made sure to circle back to. Everything that was ordered as a group was shared and it was all a hit!!! Almost all of the appetizers Spoon pudding, Deviled eggs, wings, tots, mussels, wrapped dates, pie, Beet salad, just to name a few!“

“Impeccable service, intimate booths, well stocked bar, and approachable feel. Our waiter made me feel like we were old friends, he was accommodating and helpful with selections. They have a well stocked bar and I had an excellent manhattan and even a vesper. The wedge had some of the best blue cheese dressing I've ever had, and I've had my fair share of wedges. The burger was delicious and the sesame bun was perfect. It felt super cozy and inviting!“

“The best pancakes! I love this place. Great food at a great price, very affordable. The customer service is fantastic. It's small inside so with food this good and great prices and service you can expect a wait on weekends but it's so worth it. Best little diner around.“

“The food was unique and deliciously memorable! The drinks and their menu were creative and whimsical. The service was absolutely fabulous. We very much appreciated the chance to taste different options before buying a bottle. We settled on the apple brandy but we will be back for the bottled in bond and chamomile gin! The decor was such a great blend of natural and industrial elements. It gave the feeling of a gourmet restaurant and a relaxed intimate gathering space all at once. The only thing I would have changed was the volume of the music. Everyone was shouting over the "background music" which made ordering and conversation in general somewhat difficult.Parking: A bit of a walk from the parking lot but worth it!“

“Happened upon Grand Day Cafe on a Thursday, late morning. The restaurant is clean, bright and nicely decorated. While a full dining area the acoustics were perfect for a quiet conversation. The host and server were cheerful and pleasant and very attentive, checking in often. I ordered the Chicken Salad Melt on sourdough, which was grilled to perfection. The chicken salad had great flavor and just the right mix of ingredients. I got chips instead of fries and the presentation was inviting and even included a spig of parsley. Coffee was good and my cup stayed full the entire time. Check out their specials of the day board across from the checkout counter. One thing not note is they are a breakfast/lunch venue with limited hours, closing at 2:30 on weekdays and 3:00 on weekends.“

“beautiful spot for a nice dinner! the ambiance is refined without being snobby; clean, comfy interior with low lighting is perfect for an intimate dinner. service is so nice and recommended great drinks and dishes based on our preferences. i can't remember all we got but the focaccia was a crowd pleaser and my chicken entree was perfect. i would love to visit again!“

“One of the best chicken sandwiches I have ever had. I came with my family and there was 10 of us. Everything was delicious! The service was slow but there was so many of us I don't think it was really their fault. I highly recommend the BLT Chicken sandwich and get it how it comes. It's a little spicy. The picture doesn't do it justice.“

“Food is always amazing. It was shocking to be a little hole in the wall bar, that all food was home cooked. They have fair prices, and a verity to choose from. I was told owner cooks all items herself. She definitely puts her heart and soul into it. They have everything from potato, lasagna soup, to wings, pizza, or a fully loaded chef salad. The half size salad was just. Very generous on size.“

“We had an incredible experience when we were in town for the Arnold. We made an unplanned decision to have lunch at The Guild House and couldn’t have been more impressed, by not only the food, but their incredible hospitality. They’re doing right.“

“This is the 3rd time I've been to RingSide and I love it! The food is always amazingly delicious. The service is great. The staff is super personable, polite, and fun. The am since is fantastic as well. I highly recommend this place to everyone.“

“The environment here is always buzzing and lively, and the staff is always going above and beyond. I go with my friends for casual dinners and drinks at least twice a month, and I've never had a bad experience. I absolutely love the grilled cheese bites with tomato soup, and I love how much the drink menu changes.“

“We stopped here on a whim. We are sooo glad we did. Down the street from Schmidt's sausage haus. We walked in greeted with smiles. Sat at the bar. Ordered the Mohawk sandwich (I forget the name ). It had chicken salad and roast beef on marble rye. My girlfriend had the bratwurst sandwich. Both were amazing. Our bartenders were friendly. They made great drinks. Busy but not crowded. Fun atmosphere. Love their back story of the restaurant.“

“Service was quick and servers were friendly. Open space outside to eat and comfy area inside to eat. Very vibrant. The burger was moist and the fries were crispy and tasty. I did take out and was handed container without a bag not certain if that is the normal there. I would definitely eat there again“

“Just stopped in after a LaCrosse game before heading to Winery. Great biscuits and gravy, blueberry pancake and grabbed some donuts to go. Another reminder to never judge a book by its' cover. Definitely recommend and we will make a point to go whenever we are in the area. Heck...worth the drive when we have time to kill.“

“While working in Beechwold I love grabbing lunch at George's Beechwold Diner. This time it was their club sandwich but instead of the usual pretzel bun, I had them put it on wheat. The onion rings were an added treat. Always friendly service there, it's a great place for good diner food.“

“What a great place; Modern open decor with a cozy feel. They offer several Vegan and GF options, Our food was fantastic! We had the Fish Sandwich, Beef Chow Fung, and the 40 Yolk Tagliatelle. I tried them all and they were great. I had the Tropicalia Cocktail, it was refreshing and delicious. Our server was knowledgeable and attentive. Highly recommend.“

“We had a great waiter! The food was good and the drinks were great! The only complaint was our table was small but we didn’t make a reservation so it was hard to get a table!! I loved the expresso martini and mimosas!! My calamari, shrimp, and pizza were so good!! I’d definitely come back!!“

“Gyro was fantastic and the fries were done the way you expect a Greek place to do. While waiting for my takeout order I got to have a nice conversation with Tressa (hope I'm spelling your name right) and when my food came out she made sure I had everything that I needed.Great place all around!“

“I go here often since it's so close to me. Their wings are delicious, and the rest of their food is really good! The best part is that their prices are super reasonable - which is rare to say these days. Overall, it's great! Service can certainly be hit or miss, but that's how it is anywhere. Love it!“

“We are regulars here. The staff are friendly and hard working. Not afraid to have a conversation with you and they will make your order right without issue. They have other locations but we prefer this location based upon the employees we encounter and the food being so on point.“

“This has become one of my favorite restaurants food is always delicious and service is always top tier. Our waiter was wonderful he engaged with us, also kept checking in on us to make sure everything was up to standard. I had a reservation for 7:45 p.m, but I made a call and they were able to get me in at 7:15 p.m which was great due to them being really busy due to prom season. I wish they would bring back the little crossiant that came with the salad they were really good but thanks again for a wonderful dinner for me and my family.“

“Me and a friend went here for dinner and drinks, and it did not disappoint!! We shared the Margherita pizza, the arugula salad with the amish grilled chicken added on, and truffle fries. Each and every dish was SO YUMMY!!! And it was more than enough food for us to split among the two of us. The Amish chicken was divine, so tender & flavorful. Not only that, but our server was so kind and helpful with recommendations. Their drinks were 10/10 as well and strong! I ordered the why is it spicy and my friend ordered a mule. We were both pleased with them! The ambiance is lively and the inside is a great balance of rustic and cute. Great option for a girls night & date night. I will be coming again!“

“First time eating at Another Broken Egg Cafe. I ordered the Mardi Gras Omelette, City Grits and Buttermilk Pancakes. The omelette was outstanding!! It was filled with Louisiana crawfish, gulf shrimp, andouille sausage and red peppers. Every bite was filled with seafood goodness!! The grits were cooked to perfection and were super creamy! The pancakes were fluffy and delicious! Our server, Sylvia, was very attentive, knowledgeable and charismatic. We arrived just before the deluge of customers!!! Even though the restaurant was super busy, our food arrived promptly. Overall, it was a memorable experience and we can’t wait to return!!“

“Now, let’s talk about the food. Zorbas’ revamped menu is a culinary symphony, with each dish showcasing the best of American, Greek, Italian, and Mexican cuisine. Whether you’re craving a juicy burger with a Greek twist, indulging in savory Italian pasta dishes, or savoring the bold flavors of Mexican street food! New management “

“Always a good time. Only bad part is parking which is out of their hands - the food makes up for it including daily specials, which are always awesome to try. The service is always incredible. And the lighting is always perfect to enjoy your friends or family and not worry about everybody else around you.“

“Great little spot for some lunch or a sweet treat. We stopped in and had a sandwich and a piece of cake for lunch and it was amazing. Service was so nice and engaging you have to give it a shot. Oh, and get the carrot cake but better bring help, the slice is the size of your head! “

“Fast, friendly, super clean and the food was flavorful. Didn’t even need salt and pepper which isn’t always the case with health conscious spots. I got the turkey and sweet potato dish. If you’re deciding on if you should get the green smoothie or not.. do it!!“

“Went here with my family for dinner. Great experience. Food was awesome. I had the 2-2-2 breakfast and enjoyed each item. Other people with me had the quesadilla birria and thoroughly enjoyed it. Many old reviews from before the new owners took over keeping this place lower than it deserves!“

“Typical steakhouse, excellent steaks, served with 2 side dishes from a wide choice. The welcome rolls served hot are made on site. The sweet potato is succulent and tender.However, it is recommended to book in advance to avoid a long waiting time (sometimes up to an hour), especially on weekends. But patience is rewarded“

“Great experience, not a lot of new offerings style wise but what they do they do really well. Everything we've had had been great, love the honey chicken and the spare rib dinner. Don't miss the happy hour specials! Great service as “

“Atmosphere is very laid back. I came here looking for Blackbird Kitchen, thinking it was a restaurant, and was surprised to find that it’s the name of the food sold in the bar. So Blackbird Kitchen is not its own separate restaurant. You order food at the bar and they bring it to your table. Service was quick and the food was good overall. Parking was a bit confusing. Do not park in the parking lot before 6:30pm! You will need to find street parking, which was not hard. Outdoor seating area. They have live bands.Parking: Don’t park in the parking lot before 6:30pm. Free street parking down the side streets.“