15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Hilton Head Island

“Waitress had an attitude and not a good one.I've updated my review from 3 to 5. After having a somewhat negative experience I received a prompt follow-up email from the GM who was sincerely concerned with my visit. She made up for it with a gift card and an apology. Our next visit was much better. Our server was Twila - very welcoming and attentive.“

“We ordered the Carolina Gold wings which were some of the best wings we’ve ever had and highly recommend. We enjoyed two different pizzas and they too were outstanding. I would highly recommend this restaurant and it was an outstanding change to all the seafood we’ve eaten this week.“

“We were treated with such kindness! I emailed ahead of time about getting a pizza that was safe for my kid with a severe tree nut allergy. We showed up the next day, not realizing it was 20 min before closing time. We were tired from a full day of traveling and just needed something that wasn’t fast food. When Bill recognized that I had emailed him about the allergy, he went out of his way to make us a pizza, even though he was backed up with orders. We were truly grateful for the compassion! The pizza ended up being *fantastic*. Can’t wait to get another pizza from TJ’s!Dietary restrictions: Info available for food allergies upon request“

“2nd visit to this spot. Convenient location and fair prices, especially on the island. Husband ordered a pizza and I had the hot Italian sub.My sub was exactly what I had hoped for. The bread was crusty and fresh. Homemade fries were also a bonus!Hubby's pizza was okay, a nice NY style crust. Buy overall just average.The dining was especially busy, even though it was past 2 pm. The servers were friendly, but it did take too long to get our check. They did a good job with drink refills.“

“Quaint little pizza joint, you would think it was special from looking at it. But WOW does the food speak volumes. Ordered the Chicken Pesto and the Supreme pizzas. Easily two of the best, if not the best, pizzas I've ever bought. The Chicken Pesto was unique and the flavor matched perfectly. I don't usually like Supreme Pizza, but had to go back for seconds! The crust was perfectly cooked and the sauce robust but not overwhelming.The prices may seem a bit steep from the outside, but the pizza is well worth the price!!“

“I love this pizza place so much. I visited Hilton Head for the PGA tournament and discovered this hidden gem. It’s been like 2 weeks since then and I can’t stop thinking about their pizza. Wish they had a location in Wilmington, Nc. This is the best pizza EVER. Perfectly fluffy but crunchy dough and all their toppings are fresh. So good.“

“Ruby and Calvin provided terrific service and attention even though it was peak Sat night dinner hours. Their friendliness, attention coupled with a good Italian meal that is reasonably priced is a gem here on the island. I highly recommend for good food at a reasonable price with warm and friendlyService. PS I dined outside with my cockapoo . A dog friendly restaurant is another plus.“

“Drinks are the key to this restaurant! You need to try the different frozen drinks, they are delicious and full of fun (I mean rum!). Pizza and BBQ pork are delicious as well, we had the BBQ chicken with jalapeño pizza and it was worth every bite! Hop on in and drink and eat your day away!“

“This restaurant is part if the Arthur Hills golf course in Palmetto Dunes. Quaint after golf spot with plenty of TVs and a monitor that overlooks and broadcasts the 18th hole. We had a blue cheese burger and Memphis chicken sandwich. Both came with fries and were tasty. Servers was friendly and food came fast.“

“Fair warning up front, I work with the DJ at Club Seats, so this review may be biased. Proceed at your peril and consider yourself warned.Club Seats is what i consider to be a typical gastro-pub; upscale food with a focus on handmade pizzas. Beyond the food, the area that makes Club Seats shine is the entertainment.They have several pool tables that are kept in good nick, a few video games and tv's. On various nights they have karaoke, trivia, and other pub games. They also have the NFL Sunday Ticket package and play the games when they are broadcast.For example, last night, they had musical trivia. The DJ played short excerpts from 5 songs, and each team had to come up with the artist and song name and, if he is being particularly cruel, the release year.Long story short, if you happen to find yourself in the area, stop by and give Club Seats a try, as you are guaranteed to find something you will enjoy.“

“I came to meet a friend and have a drink. The bartender Christine made me a margaritas that was absolutely amazing!! Mmmmtwahh! I definitely recommend stopping by. It's close to the beach and it smells amazing! I'll be back to try the food and have a margaritas while I wait. ?“

“A great local hang out spot with good prices, and a menu that reaches out to anyone who wanders in with an appetite! Tony makes you feel at home as soon as you enter this eclectic sports bar. As an owner, he also makes sure you're happy and satisfied with your visit. So next time you find yourself either traveling to the island, or heading off through Bluffton, make sure you stop by and see Tony. He'll make you feel like a local......even if you're not! I'm a 34yr local myself, and this is a place you need to try.......you'll thank me for it! ?“

“My wife and I had a great experience here. The service was wonderful! The people here took our minds off of a bad experience we'd had just a half an hour earlier with great energy and service. Will definitely be back whenever we return to Hilton Head.“

“I am a regular at this restaurant. It’s Old time Italian, nothing fancy. Great food at very reasonable prices! Today I had the real scallopini with eggplant covered in mozzarella cheese with tomatoes, olive oil and wine sauce. Where can you get a veal dish for $14 at lunch. And they have 10 items priced under $12 which includes salad and bread. I took the photo after I had been eating for a little while. All their portions are generous. And I’ve heard that’ the pizza is delicious here.“

“A shout out (and maybe a raise) to Amber for her hard work and dedication on the evening of February 18. She was the only person working out front - answering phones, taking orders, ringing up take out AND waiting on diners. She managed with grace and patience.“