New York Bagel Cafe
$$ • Breakfast, BagelsAbout New York Bagel Cafe
Customers' Favorites
Salami with Cream Cheese and Kiwi Fruit
Lox and Cream Cheese Bagle
Toasted Buttered Bagel
Salmon Eggs Benedict
Mushroom Perogies
Fresh Lemonade
Bagel Platters
French Toast
Forest Ham
Frittata
New York Bagel Cafe Reviews
218 ratings
Share your opinion about New York Bagel Cafe
I’ve been coming here since I was a teenager and have never reviewed but have always loved this place. Came in for lunch today with my newborn son and a friend and not only was our food absolutely amazing as always, the iced coffee was 10/10 but our service was fabulous! We were treated so kindly and felt very welcomed. The food takes time because it is all cooked fresh and made with care. Truly a wonderful restaurant in the city.
This place is a classic for my family the food is varied from other places with things such as dragon fruit and caviar and smoked goose this is definitely a unique place
My sister and I took our mom here for her birthday breakfast and I cannot say enough good things!
I didn’t know what to expect going in but once you go inside it’s such a fun place, the food and drinks were fantastic and I cannot wait to go back.
Highly recommend!
I didn’t know what to expect going in but once you go inside it’s such a fun place, the food and drinks were fantastic and I cannot wait to go back.
Highly recommend!
Hours
| Monday | 9:30AM - 4PM |
| Tuesday | 9:30AM - 4PM |
| Wednesday | 9:30AM - 4PM |
| Thursday | 9:30AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 9:30AM - 4PM |
| Saturday | 9:30AM - 4PM |
| Sunday | 9:30AM - 4PM |
The New York Bagel Cafe offers a delightful brunch experience with excellent coffee and tasty dishes like egg benedict. The restaurant's beautiful venue and convenient location make it a popular choice, though the cozy atmosphere can feel crowded at times. Customers appreciate the cash-only policy and the overall quality of the food, which is often described as delicious, made to order, and packed with flavor.
The menu features a variety of options, including the best borscht that one reviewer has ever had, with a unique Polish style, complete with an egg, fresh dill, and sour cream on top. The homemade hollandaise sauce is praised for its velvety texture, and the portions are noted to be huge, often leaving customers unable to finish their meals. Many consider the cafe to be a "unique gem" in the heart of the city, with a cozy environment that encourages relaxation and enjoyment. The cafe's coffee, particularly the Cafe Borgia, is a favorite among regulars.
While the cafe can be busy, especially on weekends, customers are encouraged to arrive early or be prepared to wait, as the experience is worth it. The host is known to share stories, adding to the overall ambiance. Overall, the New York Bagel Cafe is a beloved destination for both breakfast and lunch, offering a cozy and delightful atmosphere, exceptional food, and friendly, attentive service.