11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fairhope

“Coming from Birmingham we are accustomed to having a LOT of really good food options. I am a "wanna be" foodie myself so I genuinely appreciate a quality environment, service that matches or exceeds expectations and food that has me wanting to try more. The menu isn't overwhelming yet there is a good variety of options. They have a 2 slice & salad offer that gives you multiple flavor choices! I tried 3 different pizzas, chopped salad and the pimento bacon burger! Even the fries were perfect texture and crunch! They have an outdoor patio space to compliment the indoor casual and relaxing vibe! This is a FAIRHOPE GEM! Rachel & Chris really seem to be genuinely invested in their business & customers! I value that as a business owner as well and was very thankful for the feeling I had upon departing today. This needs to be in your weekly rotation (like it is mine) or must visit while here on vacation! Next door the the library, easy find! Don't miss a chance to get you some Nini's Pizza, Wings or Burgers and more!“

“Freshest tasting ingredients I have ever had at a pizza place. The marinara sauce was incredible! The crust was delicious! The calzone was perfectly cooked! The service was great! Not a single negative thing to say about the restaurant.“

“Great food with great friends!!! Thank you Christopher for being so kind and putting up with us giggling uncontrollably!! We appreciate you!! Food was great too!!“

“This is a great place with great staff!“

“Service at this location is consistently fast and the employees are very kind. The one time I had an error (an issue with the app that didn’t include toppings) it was fixed without any problems and the lady who waited on me was as nice as could be.
Of the chain pizza restaurants in town this one is my favorite. Everything has tasted great and the value / discounts on offer are excellent.“

“We got in a bind on a field trip. We accidentally ordered our pizza from another Papa John’s on the wrong day. The other PJ would not even attempt to let us order pizzas for the right day. We called the PJ in Fairhope, and Beth Brooke accommodated us, made our pizzas in only 40 minutes, and made sure to give us the same deal! AMAZING customer service and the pizzas were delicious.“

“Rotolo’s is a great pizza joint! My favorite is the chalmette - a cheese bread with Buffalo sauce. Come try Rotolos! Great atmosphere, great servers, great manager!! Bingo nights and trivia nights are the best.“

“As a local I absolutely love to visit this restaurant! The protein bowl is my favorite. But perhaps even better than the food and the view (which is saying something) is Q, the server. She is a joyous caregiver who is truly amazing at her job. She turns a humble position into an opportunity to go above and beyond and brighten your day. She doesn’t just take your order, she cares about your experience and wants it to be the best it can be. I hope everyone gets a chance to meet her, I would return just to sit in her section. The bonus is the delicious food and great view. Someone get Q a raise.“

“Pretty good food, if the chef is there. The manager doesn't seem to care if the place is tidy, so the floor collects ballpoint pens, napkin bits, huge crumbs--- and the staff just walks over it. When I mentioned this to the site manager, he said they don't want to sweep while customers are there, so they just let it go. However, there were no customers there the last time we walked in at 2:00. Not a soul. And the floor was a mess. A simple "long mop," swished once along that floor, would've done the job in quiet moments. Please, Daniel, you're such a nice guy. Keep the floor clean.“

“Thank you for an awesome Glow Pool party Friday night! Everyone had a ball, perfect weather and the staff went above and beyond with the lighting, ice cream treats, gift boxes, chalk drawings and best of all movie. Thank you for all that you do!“

“This Domino’s runs like a well-oiled machine—and by “well-oiled,” I mean dripping in the kind of grease that soothes your soul while clogging your arteries. It’s fast food junk pizza, the kind you eat in shame, alone, with the curtains drawn, pretending you’re too good for it while secretly loving every bite. Perfect for those moments when you’re either broke, heartbroken, or both. Truly the gold standard of guilty pleasures.“