Lookout Mountain Creamery and Desserts

Delicious! And I appreciate the real ingredients sooo much. That’s hard to find these days. I’m enjoying my peanut pie right now, so yummy!

I only really leave reviews when the food is really good or service is or if it’s the opposite. The desserts were alright, nothing too special. The inside is cool. However today we went and the person working was a younger teenage girl, she was wearing a light pink hoodie had dirty blonde hair. When we went in, there was no one inside and for some reason when she came out of the back, she seemed annoyed. She was aggressively putting our items down. I work in customer service, so I understand having a bad day but there is no need to be having an attitude with the customers. I’ve been there before, and they are usually nice but her attitude just ruined our experience. I would have given the place 4 stars because the deserts are good but nothing too exciting but since the girl was rude it knocked down a star.

We're from out of town and even the locals all point us here. Hands down their favorite and they were right!!!

Great ice cream and friendly staff

Ice cream was not that great, store bought would have been much better. And the waffle cone, I couldn't tell if it was old and soggy or if it's supposed to be as tough as an old shoe but it was. I couldn't even eat it, really really terrible.

Real shame because it's a very charming little place but the actual product they served us was terrible.

Low quality ice cream. Very icy and not creamy at all. Waste of money. Mine went straight in the trash!

Honestly, not my favorite ice cream place. Nice environment and they had a variety of flavors but I thought my waffle cone was stale and my ice cream was bland. I had 2 different flavors and both textures were gritty. I prefer a creamy ice cream. This was more like a frozen milk. Waffle cone had areas that were kinda crunchy and areas that were chewy. Overall I would not return.

Eclectic little spot in a cute little town!

Usually go for ice cream but also have tried the key lime bars and love them. And the strawberry cupcakes are the best!!

Best ice cream I’ve ever had! The atmosphere is eclectic, nostalgic and fun. Would 100% recommend. Especially since the prices are the lowest I’ve seen for this type of market in years.

What a GREAT place to savor delicious homemade ice cream while simultaneously enjoying the fascinating, eclectic decor! We had a truly enjoyable experience and the ice cream was SO good! Met the owner, Brian, and enjoyed hearing the story of how he and his wife brought their vision to life. This is a MUST STOP place to visit. Will definitely be back when we travel this way again!

This is the coolest ice cream shop I’ve been in lately!!! From the decor to the friendly staff to the MADE-FROM-SCRATCH ice cream, this is a must visit see if you’re in the Ft. Payne/Mentone area!!!

Unique little joint. The key lime bar is excellent.

Tasted great but the ice cream was soft that it was just soup once they put it in the cone.

Great ice cream as always I would recommend this place to everyone