Bendy's Cookies & Cream

3029 Pumphouse Rd Ste. 109, Vestavia Hills

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sarah Abreu

10/10 recommend!! We are in town visiting and noticed the high star review for this place, it definitely lived up to the hype! Everything we had was delicious! The warm cookies paired with the ice cream was amazing! I will be craving the Maple Pound Cake Ice Cream from now on.

Mary Katherine Linatoc

Great ice cream and cookies, great customer service, great atmosphere! Everyone I’ve encountered is so nice. The place is always really clean. The cookies and ice cream are always fresh and delicious. I highly recommend!

Willie Mounce

This is the perfect stop for desert. We had a coffee ice cream sandwich with the white chocolate Carmel pecan cookies. Soooo good. We also had the ooey gooey cake ice cream in a waffle cone. This was a great stop if you are in Birmingham. The coffee ice cream was really good. It’s made from a local coffee, OHenrys. The staff were very friendly and the place was nice and clean.

Ashley Browder

Really great ice cream. It can be pricey but what isn’t.

Jimm Brower

What can you say about delicious handmade ice cream other than it's, well, delicious. You can literally taste the effort they put into making their ice cream. It's so awesomely fresh. Cookie Butter is the best ice cream ever. Start with a cookie butter ice cream sandwich, Cookie Butter between two freshly made oatmeal cookies!!! Then try a milkshake made with swett cream. Just delicious. It is a bit pricey, maybe even overly so. But, it's a treat not an every day thing anyway.

Starla Wilkins

Stopped in to get a requested ice cream sandwich for my son’s birthday. I placed my order for one sandwich and asked for it “to go” and was told they only do that for online orders and it’s about an hour prep time. Literally would not place my one ice cream sandwich in a closed container so that I could transport it.

Jordan Antonio

We always enjoy visiting Bendy’s—their ice cream is some of the best in Birmingham! However, we were disappointed on our last visit. We arrived at 8:15 on a Saturday night and were told milkshakes weren’t available because the machine had already been cleaned, even though the store doesn’t close until 9:30. Hopefully, they'll reconsider the policy of cleaning the machine an hour before closing.

Wendy Skinner

Best cookies !!

Yris Mendez

Very good ice cream specially the flavor passion fruit and strawberry buttermilk

Khaiah Burroughs

My first time trying Bendy’s Cookies & Cream was at an event my apartment hosted. I got cookies and cream ice cream & a chocolate chip cookie—it was DELICIOUS!!!! Thank you for coming out to treat us! It definitely cooled me off from the hot weather😎

Ethan Stein

I got the mint chocolate chip. The ice cream and flavors were 100% authentic. I've never had an authentic mint flavor like it. Love it!!

Marcus Harden

Sooo good!

Kaitlin Norris

Love their ice cream, but when I came in tonight the employees up front had a bunch of friends hanging around at the counter and i felt ignored. I understand teenagers having friends come and visit at work, but not to this extent.

Rachel Reidinger

Really good Cookies! We enjoyed it very much

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip

Greg Smith

Staff was very friendly and helpful, ice cream and cookies was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookie Butter Ice Cream Snickerdoodle Sandwich, Fresh Baked Custom Mix Dozen Cookies

Loading...