Chicago crust pizza was outstanding. My first time back in awhile. To be honest in the past we had a couple of pizzas that were kind of soggy in the middle. Not today !! Everything was great !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers with Chicago Style Extra Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Matthew Garland
Best pizza I've had! I've been all over the USA.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rod Cockman
I recently put my body through a glorious test of endurance: I ordered a Chicago thin crust pizza from Molly O’Brien’s in Hot Springs Village, Arkansas… and I ate the entire thing. By myself. In one sitting. After way too many adult beverages. The kind of night where most people would reach for water and Advil—me? I reached for pizza, and I regret nothing.
This wasn’t just any pizza. It came out cut into squares—the classic Chicago tavern style. And let me tell you, that cut is dangerous. With triangles, you at least see the slices disappearing. With squares? It’s an illusion. You just keep popping them like potato chips, and before you know it, the box is empty, you’re full, and you’re questioning your life choices in the most satisfied way possible.
I went with black olives, mushrooms, and Italian sausage. Perfect combo. The crust was crisp and crunchy all the way through, no floppy sadness here. The Italian sausage was clearly homemade—none of that generic frozen stuff—with just the right fennel punch that made me feel like I was sitting at a family table in Chicago instead of alone in my car like a pizza-gobbling raccoon.
I also had a special request: I like my pizza with a little char, almost burned. And Molly O’Brien’s absolutely nailed it. The edges had that perfect smoky crisp, like the pizza had fought through a forest fire and come out victorious. Honestly, I wish this was their default style—because pizza with a little bite of char is a pizza that slaps.
Service? Top-notch. Ordering over the phone was quick and friendly—the kind of genuine customer service that makes you want to tip before you even get the food. Pickup was curbside and smooth, like a mob handoff. Except instead of an envelope of cash, I received a box of molten, cheesy joy that didn’t stand a chance against me and my slightly questionable blood-alcohol level.
Final verdict: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ out of 5. Molly O’Brien’s is the kind of place that makes pizza so good you’ll forget to take a proper picture, eat the entire thing in one sitting, and then spend the rest of the night telling your friends about your new life philosophy: square-cut pizza is a trap, and I’m fine with it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becky Babineaux
We love Mollie’s - we order pizza, they sent text updates and text when it’s ready. Just pull up out front and they bring it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
vince lancaster
Great pizza. Ordered on the way. Sat outside on deck. It was quite and pizza was good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Chrissy Kirby
Everything was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimberly
Service is Great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sean Dimond
Hot food served by friendly staff in a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Laurence Murphy
The disappointment we had after going for dinner here was probably more than any other place we’ve ever been. We kept getting told the pizza here was so great, but, unfortunately, it’s not. I hate to say it but it really was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. The others I was with didn’t enjoy their lasagne or spaghetti either but my friend with the hoagie liked his. The complimentary garlic bread was good, though. We also had almost an hour wait between placing our order and receiving.
Karen Clark
Delicious, tasty pizza with lovely and enjoyable outdoor porch seating.
I've only eaten at this place twice and both times the food was super amazing! Please understand that I was deviated when papa murphy's pizza had closed down! I just needed a pizza place that was close to the taste! Well, I surely found it here at Molly O'brien's! They have the nicest staff, pepsi products on the menu instead of coke products, the sweet tea is super awesome, the cashier is always so helpful and both servers were nice and hard working! I am a coach and after we finish playing basketball at Fountain Lake high school, we will probably stop and eat at Molly O'Brien's going forward! Trust that we told everyone in affiliation with our organization and we will bring them to celebrate our wins! Thank you for the best pizza and pasta we've ever tasted!
chenelle chenette
This has been my favorite pizza spot for over 10 years! The pizza is amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DannyP
The best place to get pizza anywhere near the village. Ponce has great pizza as well and usually gives a little more cheese, but Molly's hands down uses the best ingredients and is typically the most consistent. Even if you're on the west side of the village, Molly's is definitely worth the drive. ? Thank you guys for the amazing dining and take-out experiences you provide!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza, Meat Lovers with Chicago Style Extra Thin Crust Cheese Pizza, Super, Chicago Special Pizza
Chicago crust pizza was outstanding. My first time back in awhile. To be honest in the past we had a couple of pizzas that were kind of soggy in the middle. Not today !! Everything was great !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers with Chicago Style Extra Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Best pizza I've had! I've been all over the USA.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently put my body through a glorious test of endurance: I ordered a Chicago thin crust pizza from Molly O’Brien’s in Hot Springs Village, Arkansas… and I ate the entire thing. By myself. In one sitting. After way too many adult beverages. The kind of night where most people would reach for water and Advil—me? I reached for pizza, and I regret nothing.
This wasn’t just any pizza. It came out cut into squares—the classic Chicago tavern style. And let me tell you, that cut is dangerous. With triangles, you at least see the slices disappearing. With squares? It’s an illusion. You just keep popping them like potato chips, and before you know it, the box is empty, you’re full, and you’re questioning your life choices in the most satisfied way possible.
I went with black olives, mushrooms, and Italian sausage. Perfect combo. The crust was crisp and crunchy all the way through, no floppy sadness here. The Italian sausage was clearly homemade—none of that generic frozen stuff—with just the right fennel punch that made me feel like I was sitting at a family table in Chicago instead of alone in my car like a pizza-gobbling raccoon.
I also had a special request: I like my pizza with a little char, almost burned. And Molly O’Brien’s absolutely nailed it. The edges had that perfect smoky crisp, like the pizza had fought through a forest fire and come out victorious. Honestly, I wish this was their default style—because pizza with a little bite of char is a pizza that slaps.
Service? Top-notch. Ordering over the phone was quick and friendly—the kind of genuine customer service that makes you want to tip before you even get the food. Pickup was curbside and smooth, like a mob handoff. Except instead of an envelope of cash, I received a box of molten, cheesy joy that didn’t stand a chance against me and my slightly questionable blood-alcohol level.
Final verdict: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ out of 5.
Molly O’Brien’s is the kind of place that makes pizza so good you’ll forget to take a proper picture, eat the entire thing in one sitting, and then spend the rest of the night telling your friends about your new life philosophy: square-cut pizza is a trap, and I’m fine with it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love Mollie’s - we order pizza, they sent text updates and text when it’s ready. Just pull up out front and they bring it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza. Ordered on the way. Sat outside on deck. It was quite and pizza was good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Everything was perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service is Great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hot food served by friendly staff in a warm, inviting atmosphere.
The disappointment we had after going for dinner here was probably more than any other place we’ve ever been. We kept getting told the pizza here was so great, but, unfortunately, it’s not. I hate to say it but it really was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. The others I was with didn’t enjoy their lasagne or spaghetti either but my friend with the hoagie liked his. The complimentary garlic bread was good, though. We also had almost an hour wait between placing our order and receiving.
Delicious, tasty pizza with lovely and enjoyable outdoor porch seating.
Restaurantji Recommends
I've only eaten at this place twice and both times the food was super amazing! Please understand that I was deviated when papa murphy's pizza had closed down! I just needed a pizza place that was close to the taste! Well, I surely found it here at Molly O'brien's! They have the nicest staff, pepsi products on the menu instead of coke products, the sweet tea is super awesome, the cashier is always so helpful and both servers were nice and hard working! I am a coach and after we finish playing basketball at Fountain Lake high school, we will probably stop and eat at Molly O'Brien's going forward! Trust that we told everyone in affiliation with our organization and we will bring them to celebrate our wins! Thank you for the best pizza and pasta we've ever tasted!
This has been my favorite pizza spot for over 10 years! The pizza is amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best place to get pizza anywhere near the village. Ponce has great pizza as well and usually gives a little more cheese, but Molly's hands down uses the best ingredients and is typically the most consistent. Even if you're on the west side of the village, Molly's is definitely worth the drive. ? Thank you guys for the amazing dining and take-out experiences you provide!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza, Meat Lovers with Chicago Style Extra Thin Crust Cheese Pizza, Super, Chicago Special Pizza
Absolutely excellent pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
10 stars all the way! Great everything!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...