4 Best American Restaurants in Monticello

“Me and my collegues have eaten here twice now. It’s always made to order and SUPER fast. A cute little diner with awesome milkshakes. The staff is always super bubbly and nice. I don’t have one negative thing to say about this establishment! Will be back!“

“One of my fav restaurants here in Monticello is The Crawfish Shack. There is not one thing I would change as far as the menu, service, & atmosphere. The main reason I love TCS is the owners. This past Sat Amanda was an answer to my prayer that I could cancel the order for the $70 10 lbs crawfish special i had placed earlier in the week b/c I didn’t get paid. She was so kind & understanding. I can’t wait to visit their new restaurant in Lake Village asap. In closing, grade earned is an A+, gold star, smiley face.“

“Great burgers and BLT'S. I love their ice!
Updated review for May 23, 2025. Ordered a chef salad, no egg and no ham. It is loaded with egg. Ordered ranch and I didn't get that either. I have a severe egg allergy. Asked for extra bacon on our BLT and that didn't happen either. Not happy at all and Breaker use to be amazing.“

“This place may have previously had some hiccups. But I visited today with my family and although they were packed and only a few workers, they kept a positive attitude and got everyone taken care of with a smile on their face! Please give this place another chance if you haven’t already!“