Picked up a pie at the gas station across from Little America. Strawberry rhubarb and it was delicious. Definitely will be back to try other flavors.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Pies
Leslie 1 Call Tech
We had an amazing lemon meringue pie. Absolutely delicious. We can’t wait to try another
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tillandsia Ducar
Just a text away. Very easy to order and pick up without hassle. Pie was delicious and perfect for my husband's birthday. We tried strawberry rhubarb, which was a first, and we loved it. Will order a pie every time we after in Flagstaff from now
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beth B.
I'm a pie snob. Pie is my favorite food. I usually avoid buying pie at stores or restaurants because it's just not as good as homemade. But then I tried a Pie Guy pie... The crust, which makes or breaks the pie in my opinion, is flaky and savory. It just melts in your mouth. The filling is sweet, rich and delicious! I've tried the apple, too many times to count, and the chocolate cream. I'll be looking for a cherry pie next time I roll through Flag.
Juliette W.
Absolutely delicious pies. Got the strawberry rhubarb and the chuckberry and these are probably the best pies I've ever had. You can definitely tell they are homemade and made with the special ingredients of love and care. Will be buying again.
Jessica E.
Great pies if you can hunt one down at the local convenience stores. We grabbed a banana cream pie and it was delicious. I'll definitely be on the lookout when I'm up in Flag.
C L.
BisbeeBerry‼‼. You can't go wrong with these pies. Never a disappointment. Always fresh and delicious. YUM!
Rowena P.
Best pie ever! The apple filling was fresh...still had a slightly firm bite, slightly tart. The crust was flakey. This was like a home made pie...not too sweet. It's a bargain at $13.50. Pick one up from one of the gas stations indicated. You won't regret it!
Mari Warnick
I was given an Apple pie for my birthday last year. It was delicious!
Sue R.
The peach gluten free pie was delicious! The pie guy prefers to have orders placed by text. He needs some advance notice for gluten free orders, a few days ahead of pick up. The pick up system is very easy and handy.
If you are in flagstaff you must get one of these pies! Best I've every had. These 5 stores in Flagstaff carry these pies: Kachina Village's Pic and Run on I 17 Mobil at Butler and I 40 Silver Saddle on 89 in Doney Park Marathon Station on 4th and 7th Chevron at Highway 180 and Forest
T B.
This guy is kinda of a jerk but his cream pies are good. When I asked about payment, because I couldn't understand his text, he became agitated. The easy pies like apple n cherry are ok but overpriced. You can find the same at Sprouts for a lot less. But the banana and chocolate creams are delightful.
Michalann A.
I absolutely do not recommend this location. Yelp took me to a house. There was a pie guys van in the driveway, but I'm not eating pie in a house in an "ok" residential area. They do not serve pie out of that location! Seriously upset that I drove across town for nothing. Fix Yelp business owner!!!!
whitney thatcher
Honestly, the best pie we have ever had. I discovered pie guy last year when I needed something for my husband’s birthday while we were visiting Flagstaff. My husband does not like desserts- but the one dessert he does like is rhubarb pie. It’s hard to find a good rhubarb pie that isn’t too sweet or too sour. My husband is very picky and absolutely loves Pie Guy’s rhubarb pie. If you need pie (or even if you don’t need pie) you must try Pie Guy!
Picked up a pie at the gas station across from Little America. Strawberry rhubarb and it was delicious. Definitely will be back to try other flavors.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Pies
We had an amazing lemon meringue pie. Absolutely delicious. We can’t wait to try another
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just a text away. Very easy to order and pick up without hassle. Pie was delicious and perfect for my husband's birthday. We tried strawberry rhubarb, which was a first, and we loved it. Will order a pie every time we after in Flagstaff from now
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm a pie snob. Pie is my favorite food. I usually avoid buying pie at stores or restaurants because it's just not as good as homemade. But then I tried a Pie Guy pie... The crust, which makes or breaks the pie in my opinion, is flaky and savory. It just melts in your mouth. The filling is sweet, rich and delicious! I've tried the apple, too many times to count, and the chocolate cream. I'll be looking for a cherry pie next time I roll through Flag.
Absolutely delicious pies. Got the strawberry rhubarb and the chuckberry and these are probably the best pies I've ever had. You can definitely tell they are homemade and made with the special ingredients of love and care. Will be buying again.
Great pies if you can hunt one down at the local convenience stores. We grabbed a banana cream pie and it was delicious. I'll definitely be on the lookout when I'm up in Flag.
BisbeeBerry‼‼. You can't go wrong with these pies. Never a disappointment. Always fresh and delicious. YUM!
Best pie ever! The apple filling was fresh...still had a slightly firm bite, slightly tart. The crust was flakey. This was like a home made pie...not too sweet. It's a bargain at $13.50. Pick one up from one of the gas stations indicated. You won't regret it!
I was given an Apple pie for my birthday last year. It was delicious!
The peach gluten free pie was delicious! The pie guy prefers to have orders placed by text. He needs some advance notice for gluten free orders, a few days ahead of pick up. The pick up system is very easy and handy.
Restaurantji Recommends
If you are in flagstaff you must get one of these pies! Best I've every had. These 5 stores in Flagstaff carry these pies: Kachina Village's Pic and Run on I 17 Mobil at Butler and I 40 Silver Saddle on 89 in Doney Park Marathon Station on 4th and 7th Chevron at Highway 180 and Forest
This guy is kinda of a jerk but his cream pies are good. When I asked about payment, because I couldn't understand his text, he became agitated. The easy pies like apple n cherry are ok but overpriced. You can find the same at Sprouts for a lot less. But the banana and chocolate creams are delightful.
I absolutely do not recommend this location. Yelp took me to a house. There was a pie guys van in the driveway, but I'm not eating pie in a house in an "ok" residential area. They do not serve pie out of that location! Seriously upset that I drove across town for nothing. Fix Yelp business owner!!!!
Honestly, the best pie we have ever had. I discovered pie guy last year when I needed something for my husband’s birthday while we were visiting Flagstaff. My husband does not like desserts- but the one dessert he does like is rhubarb pie. It’s hard to find a good rhubarb pie that isn’t too sweet or too sour. My husband is very picky and absolutely loves Pie Guy’s rhubarb pie. If you need pie (or even if you don’t need pie) you must try Pie Guy!
Good pies! Local! Can't beat that!