Did their special, xl pizza and wings, the wings were great. The service and dining felt natural. The pizza was sub par. Im not big on doing reviews but the pizza was greasy and soggy and only 4 hours later its kind of a goopy mess. The artichoke hearts were mush the onions tasted a litte rough. I might try this place again down the road since its close but so is little Caesars
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dry Hot Wings
Philip Kaiser
We really enjoy good pizza and i wish we had more quality pizza here in AZ but many in Az think Pizza hut is legit, like the folks in Iowa that think Taco Bell is authentic mexican food. Having eaten NY pizza in NY, this is banging! You know you have great pizza when every person eats every bit of crust with fresh slices still in the box. Their bread is awesome, which makes a great pie. Cheese seemed legit and the sauce was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lee Lee
I've been going to this place for years and truly liked it but after last night's experience I will never go back. Two times I have ordered honey hot wings and when delivered it's medium wings. So when my order was wrong for the 3nd time I called the store. The manager got on the phone and told me they were honey hot wings he made them himself and I told him there is no way they are honey hot wings. Honey hot wings are spicy and sweet and stinky. These literally were just buffalo sauce. He said I put honey in the sauce. I said no these are not sweet at all. Even my roommate said the same thing these were not right. I told him I wanted a refund. I spent 50 bucks for 20 wings and a large pizza and this was not okay Plus the other half of my wings which were mild had barley any sauce on them the pizza was a sausagepizza with barley any sausage which they charged me for.. The manager told me to get over it he made it right and he won't be refunding me. Such bad service and refused to make it right. Very disappointed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Douglas DeVries
Excellent crust and quality toppings.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jimmy Anthony
My crew and I have been working in Peoria lately and have had the pleasure of eating here twice now. The pizza is 🔥 and the staff/owner have been nothing but perfect. Highly recommend for the lunch special and pizza overall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jose Adam
Really happy I chose them. So thankful for their help!
lb Continue
A pizza place that doesn't do slices??? Go elsewhere!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jose Melendez
Pizza is amazing honestly. If Dave portnoy came here he would give this place a solid 7.5 to 7.9 it’s not in the 8s. But it’s definitely worthy of a try. I’ve eaten NY pizza since I was a kid all the time. This pizza really reminds me of ny pizza in a way. The taste is nostalgic. Atmosphere is eh. People are friendly here and serve you without attitude. I’ve come here so many times and I have never been let down on a regular cheese slice. Come here is you want to experience a subtle taste of what ny pizza can taste like!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
chris Eddy
Great tasting and fresh Everyone working the is professional and friendly
Fabian Anchondo
Super nice people super duper fire wings and pizza over all 5 ⭐️ if you ask me
Pizza was pretty good. Not too far off from New York style. Kind of hard to find in phoenix. Service was friendly. Restaurant was dirty. I sat there for an hour and no one came out to clean/wipe the dirty tables or chairs. There seemed to be multiple people working and they were not very busy.
Joe Oso
Pizza is super greasy and delicious. Wings need more sauce. You really need Coke products and alcohol. Restaurant is way too hot!!!! This is AZ!!! Turn the thermostat down!!!!! Otherwise it would be the best Peoria Pizza place!!!! And please please stop watering down your ranch and charging for it!!!
Adam Neuner
We showed up late they close at 9:00 we were there 15 minutes before and no complaints from staff or anybody in the restaurant. Great attitudes clean cut and very personable. I would recommend Don's to anyone anytime anywhere. Good job team
Richael Glenn
Great customer service! Defiantly recommend!
sean lujan
After new owner took over the food completely changed used to be the best pizza in town with great lunch specials, tried it twice since new owner and just not the same.
Did their special, xl pizza and wings, the wings were great. The service and dining felt natural. The pizza was sub par. Im not big on doing reviews but the pizza was greasy and soggy and only 4 hours later its kind of a goopy mess. The artichoke hearts were mush the onions tasted a litte rough. I might try this place again down the road since its close but so is little Caesars
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dry Hot Wings
We really enjoy good pizza and i wish we had more quality pizza here in AZ but many in Az think Pizza hut is legit, like the folks in Iowa that think Taco Bell is authentic mexican food. Having eaten NY pizza in NY, this is banging! You know you have great pizza when every person eats every bit of crust with fresh slices still in the box. Their bread is awesome, which makes a great pie. Cheese seemed legit and the sauce was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been going to this place for years and truly liked it but after last night's experience I will never go back. Two times I have ordered honey hot wings and when delivered it's medium wings. So when my order was wrong for the 3nd time I called the store. The manager got on the phone and told me they were honey hot wings he made them himself and I told him there is no way they are honey hot wings. Honey hot wings are spicy and sweet and stinky. These literally were just buffalo sauce. He said I put honey in the sauce. I said no these are not sweet at all. Even my roommate said the same thing these were not right. I told him I wanted a refund. I spent 50 bucks for 20 wings and a large pizza and this was not okay
Plus the other half of my wings which were mild had barley any sauce on them the pizza was a sausagepizza with barley any sausage which they charged me for.. The manager told me to get over it he made it right and he won't be refunding me. Such bad service and refused to make it right. Very disappointed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent crust and quality toppings.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
My crew and I have been working in Peoria lately and have had the pleasure of eating here twice now. The pizza is 🔥 and the staff/owner have been nothing but perfect. Highly recommend for the lunch special and pizza overall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really happy I chose them. So thankful for their help!
A pizza place that doesn't do slices??? Go elsewhere!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza is amazing honestly. If Dave portnoy came here he would give this place a solid 7.5 to 7.9 it’s not in the 8s. But it’s definitely worthy of a try. I’ve eaten NY pizza since I was a kid all the time. This pizza really reminds me of ny pizza in a way. The taste is nostalgic. Atmosphere is eh. People are friendly here and serve you without attitude. I’ve come here so many times and I have never been let down on a regular cheese slice. Come here is you want to experience a subtle taste of what ny pizza can taste like!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great tasting and fresh
Everyone working the is professional and friendly
Super nice people super duper fire wings and pizza over all 5 ⭐️ if you ask me
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was pretty good. Not too far off from New York style. Kind of hard to find in phoenix. Service was friendly. Restaurant was dirty. I sat there for an hour and no one came out to clean/wipe the dirty tables or chairs. There seemed to be multiple people working and they were not very busy.
Pizza is super greasy and delicious. Wings need more sauce. You really need Coke products and alcohol. Restaurant is way too hot!!!! This is AZ!!! Turn the thermostat down!!!!! Otherwise it would be the best Peoria Pizza place!!!! And please please stop watering down your ranch and charging for it!!!
We showed up late they close at 9:00 we were there 15 minutes before and no complaints from staff or anybody in the restaurant. Great attitudes clean cut and very personable. I would recommend Don's to anyone anytime anywhere. Good job team
Great customer service! Defiantly recommend!
After new owner took over the food completely changed used to be the best pizza in town with great lunch specials, tried it twice since new owner and just not the same.
Loading...