The Sicilian Baker

9780 W Northern Ave Suite 1100, Peoria
(623) 471-5721

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Nutella Lobster Tail
Sfogliatelle Single
Chocolate Cake
Tiramisu Cake
Mini Cannoli
Gelato

Menu

Cannoli Bar
Cannoli
Choose your shell, select your filling. Sicilian perfection tailored just for you.
Dolce Duo
Mini Cannoli
mini crispy pastry filled + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
1/2 Dozen Traditional Cannoli
crispy pastry filled + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
1 Dozen Traditional Cannoli
crispy pastry filled + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
Cannoli Cream .5lb
Half-pound of Sicilian Cannoli Cream, your choice of flavor

Cookies
1/2lb Amaretti Cookies
amaretto dough + almonds
1lb Amaretti Cookies
amaretto dough + almonds
1/2lb Green Almond Cookies
almond infused cookie + icing
1lb Green Almond Cookies
almond infused cookie + icing
1/2lb Italian Wedding Cookies
pecan shortbread + powdered sugar
1lb Italian Wedding Cookies
pecan shortbread + powdered sugar
1/2lb Taralucci Cookies
lemon dough + lemon glaze + confetti
1lb Taralucci Cookies
lemon dough + lemon glaze + confetti
1/2lb Assorted Cookies
Half-pound Assorted Cookies, Baker's Selection
1lb Assorted Cookies
One-pound Assorted Cookies, Baker's Selection
2lb Assorted Cookies
Two-pound Assorted Cookies, Baker's Selection

Pastries
Cassatina
almond marzipan + traditional cannoli cream + vanilla sponge
Flag Cookie
Individual Rum Cake
Napoleon
puff pastry + vanilla custard + icing
New York Cheesecake
Nutella Lobster Tail
puff pastry shell + nutella pastry cream
Sfogliatelle Single
buttery flaky dough + sweet ricotta+ powdered sugar
Tiramisu
espresso syrup-soaked lady fingers + sweet mascarpone cream
Vanilla Lobster Tail
puff pastry shell + vanilla pastry cream

Platters
1/2 Dozen lobster tail
puff pastry shell + vanilla pastry cream
1 Dozen lobster tail
puff pastry shell + vanilla pastry cream
Italian Dessert Platter
10 Amaretti cookie / 10 Almond Cookies / 10 Italian Wedding Cookies / 10 Mini Traditional Cannoli / 2 Sfogliatelle / 2 Nutella Lobster Tail / 2 Vanilla Lobster Tail

Caffè Siciliano
Americano
Bakerato
Cappuccino
Caramel Hazelnut Latte
Coffee
Coffee Decaf
Espresso
Espresso Double
Flat White
Honey Nut Macchiato
Latte
Nutella Latte
Raspberry White Mocha
White chocolate + Espresso + Raspberry
Salted Caramel Mocha

Bottled Beverages
Acqua Panna 16.9oz
Naturally crafted by the Tuscan landscape and bottled at the source, Acqua Panna Natural Spring Water is renowned for its unique taste.
Acqua Panna 1L
Naturally crafted by the Tuscan landscape and bottled at the source, Acqua Panna Natural Spring Water is renowned for its unique taste.
Sanpellegrino® 1L
San Pellegrino mineral water flows from a thermal spring at the foot of a dolomite mountain wall towering above the Brembo River in the Italian Alps.
Sanpellegrino® Aranciata Rossa
This authentic premium drink is made from a unique blend of sun-ripened oranges and blood oranges from Italy.
Sanpellegrino® Limonata
Sanpellegrino® Limonata is the authentic sparkling lemon beverage from Italy that is bursting with sunshine and all the magical moments of a Sicilian summer.
Sanpellegrino® Sparkling 500ml
San Pellegrino mineral water flows from a thermal spring at the foot of a dolomite mountain wall towering above the Brembo River in the Italian Alps.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+26 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+25 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The waiter was very attentive! Love the fact the owner came to our table and greeted us and asked us if everything was good. You don't see much of owners in restaurants greeting their customers.
October 2026
The Sicilian Butcher is always a fun place for a meal with a great vibe. Love the ambiance and always great service. Marco was great amd you will most likely see Jason, the Manager, working just as hard as all the staff to assure you have a great meal and a great experience. The menu brings a fun twist to the typical Italian menu.
October 2026
Our server was extremely thoughtful when part of my order was delayed and provided great recommendations. Our second time here since we live is CA. Might be our new go to when in town.
October 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

The Sicilian Butcher - 9780 West Northern Avenue Ste 1100
Sicilian, Italian, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Hash Kitchen - 9780 West Northern Avenue Ste 1110
Brunch, Burgers, Breakfast, Pet Friendly
BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse - 9748 West Northern Avenue
Pizza, Brewpubs, American, Vegan

The Sicilian Baker

9780 W Northern Ave Suite 1100, Peoria, AZ 85345
(623) 471-5721