11 Best Pizza Restaurants near Show Low

“This is the best dinner I know of at this price point. The ingredients are always fresh, the lobby and kitchen look clean, and the staff is very friendly. My pizzas are always ready on time, and I am happy to drive a little out of my way to get a Papa Murphy's pizza!“

“We have not been to Pizza Hut since early 1990’s in Indio California. Today we happen to be up In show low and we saw Pizza Hut so we stopped and got a vegetable pizza to go OMG it was fabulous. For sure we will be back except we will not wait for 28 years. Thank you for great service really appreciate it .“

“This place is great! They went out of their way to help our nonprofit show our support to the Show Low VA Clinic. Thank you guys!!“

“A huge shout out to Jose for being super awesome and helping me with my order. I’m a Mom of a Senior and part of a national group to “Adopt Seniors “. I live in Orlando and was sending a pizza to a Senior in Show Low. He came up with a clever phrase to write inside the pizza lid. The Senior’s Mom send me a pic. Thank you for making two Mommas and a Senior sooo happy!💕“

“thank you to James for the extra steps you take to manage the store“

“The food is very good, a little pricey. Nice atmosphere and the have the Cowboy Channel which I enjoy watching. It just added to thd theme and let me enjoy my favorite channel while I ate. The food will not disappoint. I highly recommend the fried Ribs they are delicious!“

“Amazing pizza! I loved how perfect the crust was. My wife had a calzone and it was as big as her head! Everything was so delicious!“

“The Pizza and Hot wings with the side of twisted bread sticks is a must it's DELICIOUS.. Friendly customer service.“

“We love this Red Devil!
It’s become a bit of a tradition to have dinner or lunch at this Red Devil whenever we find ourselves in Pinetop, because the experience has been consistently great.
Versus other places in the near vicinity have been… let’s say mixed.

I like how the interior is nice, yet still modest and quaint. It’s not trying too hard to be modern, nor old-timey. It’s just comfortably modest and well-kept.

Waiters have always been courteous and responsive. Whoever is in charge of hiring decisions knows what they’re doing!
When we were there last weekend our greeter went above and beyond.
Food is consistently great, never had a complaint.
The prices are also quite reasonable for what this is.

The only thing I could possibly complain about is that it can be a pain to drive in and out of, due to it requiring a left turn (if you’re coming south/eastbound) right after a traffic light, so you can’t legally sit in the center lane to wait for a clearing, and there’s only one way in and out. But there’s not much the restaurant can do about this, as this is by virtue of Pinetop being a small town that’s built on one big highway stroad, with all properties being siloed from each other.
Just a warning to those wanting to come here I guess. Probably best you go down a bit further and make a U-turn.“

“The store was very clean, and smelled really good. The man working there was very friendly and attentive. He told us he would bring our food out to the truck to us when it was done. It only took ten minutes to get our order. And, of course, the pizza and bread sticks were really good, and fresh and hot. We were very impressed, and happy we stopped there.“

“You know what to expect it's good pizza for an affordable price. Call ahead up here. That night that you don't wanna cook or go out. Everyone else is thinking the same. Order ahead and get the goods!! Love and respect to all. Mr. Roger J Woolley ❤️“