Buttermilk & Honey Bakeshop

The best bakery we visited on our trip from California to Upstate New York!!!

when my husband and I travel we always try to find a good little bakery. we aren't always successful but we sure hit the jackpot with this little bakery!! Everything is delicious! Best Quiches and flakes pastries.

I believe I was looking for a traditional bakery and this is more of a boutique which is just not what we expected so probably error on me for stopping in😉 the kids saw bakery and got excited then when inside they couldn't find any donuts 🙃

No Veteran discount either 1st establishment in Wickenburg to not offer Veteran discount 😕

Very disappointing there are 6 items on display available 🐂

Parking: Bad energy

Kid-friendliness: Not kid friendly

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

this bakery is SO GOOD!! the staff is sweet & fun! the treats are yummy! love the little cute shop! cinnamon rolls are the best!

ABSOLUTELY the BEST Key Lime PIE EVER. NEVER EVER have I had better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I drove from Surprise to Wickenburg just to try this 4.9 star bakery and wasn’t disappointed at all! The cinnamon roll and cheddar biscuit were amazing. Happy mama realtor right here and will be recommending to my friends

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

love this place! wish I lived closer to it.

THE BEST BAKERY IN TOWN. Had the chance to get a cookie today and lemme tell ya… this place is top notch. Great staff and cute store. A must try.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It’s a cute place when you’re craving a treat. The strawberry cheesecake lacks much strawberry flavor, the citrus cake lacks citrus flavor. It felt like they got the texture and richness down perfectly but flavors weren’t quite developed
EDIT: see the owners response below. Otherwise the cheesecake is good, and I realize that the recipe would be a lighter touch of citrus. I won’t be back in town anytime soon during business hours but please give this local business a try it is awfully cute and everything tastes good.
I believe as a group we tried
Peanut butter cookie: 5/5 soft and chewy
Chocolate chip cookies: 5/5 soft chewy and sweet
from a picky person so an average 5
Keylime pie/cheesecake?: 5/5 very rich
Citrus cake: a great consistency it had good small crumbs and was bouncy. I believe this would pair really well with citrus tea or a lemonade. Not a strong citrus flavor but as the owner replied that’s just the cake style so 5/5

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Wife has severe corn sensitivies so bakery's are challenging to say the least. Corn is in everything from powdered sugar to baking powder and then more! We have a substantial lifetime milestone coming up and wanted to celebrate with some delightful baked items. Wife ordered macarons and explained the allergy. We got the macarons today and they are the BOMB! We watch way too many baking shows and immediately started looking at things like the foot of macarons, looking for nipples and on and on. Bottom line the macarons were perfect. I'm so glad Wickenburg has a bakery like Buttermilk &Honey Bakeshop where you can order goods and not have to run to Surprise.
Here's the bad thing: our celebration is tomorrow and because the macarons are so damn tasty we might have to display our treats differently because I keep sneaking treats.

Dietary restrictions: Cannot have corn and the bakery accomodated us with delicious treats.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Macaroon

Small bakery with a few choices. Menu is fresh daily. Has Flan which isn't at many. Cookies, Scones, Macaroons, Cake. Coffee - brewed. Couple flavors of ice cream scoops not soft serve. Some bottles refreshments. Outside seating area. Inside for ordering, only. One can call to request items or reserve what is being baked.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Very cute little Bakeshop, super friendly owner and everything we had was delicious! You can definitely taste the quality—-highly recommend the Potato Chorizo Turnover.
? ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fanny made me a custom cake that was sooooo good! Yumm, chocolate with a raspberry filling and chocolate ganache glaze with the cutest decor!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Visited from out of town and WOW! These pastries are absolutely delicious, my first time and I had to grab a batch of goodies. The service is absolutely welcoming and wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have gone to this cute little shop 3x. There is something new to try everytime. Staff has always been very nice and helpful. Love the name, shop, products, and staff. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5