These guys are awesome.very friendly and cheerful.excellent costumer service.i ordered 3 different tips of pizza,and all were very delicious.the size of their slices are huge as well.definitely will go back and recommend them as well.good job guys ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phoenix Lam
Friendly, lovely staff. Definitely an "everyone knows your name" if you live in the area and frequently visit kind of vibe. Stopped in for a slice and the owner greeted customers by name, joked around with everyone. Some customers even came by just to say hi/chat it up.Pizza itself was great, thin crispy crust. Pizza loaded with toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 5th Ave Pizza
Pattybee Wolf
Best soup in town!Why make it at home it will never be as good as this!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
C K
Always great!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pfeifer Hill
Excellent thin-style NY pizza with a huge variety of toppings. Crust was crisp and just thick enough to have a good bite to it. Not greasy, really high quality overall. I’m from the East Coast of the US and would pick this as my go-to place. Amazing prices as well.Vegetarian options: Multiple vegetarian options that were equally delicious.Kid-friendliness: Perfect food option for kids.
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Max Arzumanov
10/10 no flop, not oily, and insanely good combinations. That slice in the top left is the heaviest pizza slice I’ve ever had, like an open faced sandwich with pulled pork, pineapple, bacon, onion, and more. I couldn’t even fold it, and it somehow stayed parallel to the ground without dropping or falling apart while I ate it. Actually unbelievable. Had the Canuck’s game on too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Mcphail
There is a reason they've been open for so
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andy
Nicest Staff And Owners! My all time FAV place to eat.Food is always Fresh and amazing.I'd recommend not coming during school lunch hours as the lineup gets EXTREMELY long, (Shows how good the pizza they make is haha)Vegetarian options: Good amount of VEG options.Kid-friendliness: The owners are the nicest to younger kids for sure.
Very tasty food and nice staff, friendly atmosphere in there and the baked penne was just the right portion to be filling (and it comes with garlic bread ?)
If you're a fan of big pizza slices and great company, give Nats new York Pizzeria a try! They have been around for years because they know how to do pizza right! Amazing thin crust with a crispy bottom that still manages to hold all its toppings. I enjoyed the BBQ chicken pizza the best! Service was quick and the interior is pure nostalgia
Amy P.
Large slices of thin crust pizza. Loaded toppings. Quick service. At lunch time and 3pm after school rush the place fill up easily. Some free street parking 1-2 blocks away. Meter parking right on Broadway. The ticket guy checks often
Tiffany C.
Great New York style pizza! They always have a decent veggie selection, though I usually grab a marg, since I like cheesy tomato slices. The staff are always friendly and welcoming! I usually get take away, but inside is a a cheer pie shop, as the name suggests.
Sun G.
Well that was a pleasant surprise. , I crashed this Yelp Elite event out of my error. I was more than okay paying for a slice.... The owner Nat gifted me a slice. Which was very kind of him. Had the beef special as I am trying to reduce my pork intake. The pizza was decent. Very typical NY taste. An amalgamation of American taste with Italian. Thin sourdough crust with American toppings. Good mouth feel. At the end of the day, there are so many pizza joints, what really separates one from another? Personal touch. Nat's kindness was authentic. I recommend this joint.
Valerie M.
Does not taste like Nat's pizza anymore. Too many hot peppers, the sauce is not the same, and the toppings are sloppy, increased to way too many chilli peppers on the spicy mushroom (no balance of flavours anymore)!! Very disappointing after so many years, I'll have to find another favourite pizza place.
These guys are awesome.very friendly and cheerful.excellent costumer service.i ordered 3 different tips of pizza,and all were very delicious.the size of their slices are huge as well.definitely will go back and recommend them as well.good job guys ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly, lovely staff. Definitely an "everyone knows your name" if you live in the area and frequently visit kind of vibe. Stopped in for a slice and the owner greeted customers by name, joked around with everyone. Some customers even came by just to say hi/chat it up.Pizza itself was great, thin crispy crust. Pizza loaded with toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 5th Ave Pizza
Best soup in town!Why make it at home it will never be as good as this!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always great!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent thin-style NY pizza with a huge variety of toppings. Crust was crisp and just thick enough to have a good bite to it. Not greasy, really high quality overall. I’m from the East Coast of the US and would pick this as my go-to place. Amazing prices as well.Vegetarian options: Multiple vegetarian options that were equally delicious.Kid-friendliness: Perfect food option for kids.
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
10/10 no flop, not oily, and insanely good combinations. That slice in the top left is the heaviest pizza slice I’ve ever had, like an open faced sandwich with pulled pork, pineapple, bacon, onion, and more. I couldn’t even fold it, and it somehow stayed parallel to the ground without dropping or falling apart while I ate it. Actually unbelievable. Had the Canuck’s game on too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There is a reason they've been open for so
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicest Staff And Owners! My all time FAV place to eat.Food is always Fresh and amazing.I'd recommend not coming during school lunch hours as the lineup gets EXTREMELY long, (Shows how good the pizza they make is haha)Vegetarian options: Good amount of VEG options.Kid-friendliness: The owners are the nicest to younger kids for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Cheese, Cheese Pizza, Pesto Artichoke, BBQ Chicken
Very tasty food and nice staff, friendly atmosphere in there and the baked penne was just the right portion to be filling (and it comes with garlic bread ?)
Too good.
Restaurantji Recommends
If you're a fan of big pizza slices and great company, give Nats new York Pizzeria a try! They have been around for years because they know how to do pizza right! Amazing thin crust with a crispy bottom that still manages to hold all its toppings. I enjoyed the BBQ chicken pizza the best! Service was quick and the interior is pure nostalgia
Large slices of thin crust pizza. Loaded toppings. Quick service. At lunch time and 3pm after school rush the place fill up easily. Some free street parking 1-2 blocks away. Meter parking right on Broadway. The ticket guy checks often
Great New York style pizza! They always have a decent veggie selection, though I usually grab a marg, since I like cheesy tomato slices. The staff are always friendly and welcoming! I usually get take away, but inside is a a cheer pie shop, as the name suggests.
Well that was a pleasant surprise. , I crashed this Yelp Elite event out of my error. I was more than okay paying for a slice.... The owner Nat gifted me a slice. Which was very kind of him. Had the beef special as I am trying to reduce my pork intake. The pizza was decent. Very typical NY taste. An amalgamation of American taste with Italian. Thin sourdough crust with American toppings. Good mouth feel. At the end of the day, there are so many pizza joints, what really separates one from another? Personal touch. Nat's kindness was authentic. I recommend this joint.
Does not taste like Nat's pizza anymore. Too many hot peppers, the sauce is not the same, and the toppings are sloppy, increased to way too many chilli peppers on the spicy mushroom (no balance of flavours anymore)!! Very disappointing after so many years, I'll have to find another favourite pizza place.