Great pizza by the slice… My favorite are the Big Sur and the pesto This is a grab and go place… Very, very limited seating
Yayaan Management
This place was incredible, we were visiting the city, knew nothing about the place but while walking, we kept seeing dozens of people with pizza boxes, after a while we discerned the pizza must be amazing. As we walked towards it, we could see they had their own pizza box garbage rack. It was stacked with boxes. We got our slice and were beyond impressed . We kept thinking about that spot the rest of the trip. We love it!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cowell's Combo Pizza, Little Sur
Candi Dorr
Pizza is always good... but Pizza my heart is great! Try their ranch dressing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robbie
Perfect beachside pizza spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan LaCourt
Crispy crust
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
anna
Great pizzas 🍕 tried 4 different toppings and all were great.
Food: 5
M W
Online ordering said 55-65 minutes, but the workers told me and others more like 20-30 minutes. Pizza was soggy and cold when we picked up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Terri Osborne
Hands down the best pizza ever! Pepperoni is my favorite. I drove from Olympia Washington to Lake Arrowhead and made sure to stop in Capitola just to get a pizza! My kids grew up on this pizza when I lived in Pleasanton. We spent our summers in Capitola and enjoyed Pizza of my Heart!💕💕💕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kindray2025
We love getting pizza by the slice here but this time we ordered a whole pie while we were walking in the village and they had it ready in 20 minutes, it was great as usual
Awesome pizza. My family came to visit Capitola and take pictures of the beautiful beach and colorful houses nearby. Pizza My Heart caught our eyes as we were walking around.
We ordered the following: 🏆 Big Sur - it has been the two time world champion best pizza! So we had to try. Indeed there’s a reason why it is a winner 🍍 Maui Wowie - if you love Pineapple pizza / Hawaiian pizza, you Must order this. It’s the best we’ve ever had. It was a Hit 🥓 D’Lex Chicken and Bacon - for meat lovers
What stood out to us has been the fact that the crust is thin and they cook the pizza right in the oven for you. If you ordered individual slices they should come out of the oven in 2-3 min. The staff know what they are doing.
The pizza is great to eat while walking along the beach. There are no indoor seating, but plenty of benches and the whole beach to sit and eat. Our family stood outside, huddled around in a circle, and took turns taking a bite of each pizza. We loved it.
Thank you all for your service and the food you make to feed people. God bless you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marcy Sanchez
Amazing!!!!!!!!!
Naima Rashid
This pizza spot seriously blew me away. I got a slice of their pesto pizza and one called Little Sur—and man, both were absolutely delicious. The pesto slice was so good, we had to go back for another. It was ooey, gooey, cheesy, and perfectly melty—hands down one of the best slices I’ve ever had. Every bite was packed with flavor.
I stuck to the vegetarian options since the non-veg ones weren’t halal, but if they’re anything like the ones I tried, I bet they’re just as amazing. Between the two, I liked the pesto more—it really hit the spot.
Price-wise, it’s about $7 per slice—not the cheapest, but honestly, for the taste, totally worth it. The service was decent. The person who served us wasn’t super interactive, but hey, maybe it just wasn’t their day. No complaints though!
The location is great too—it’s right by the beach, so you can grab a slice, find a bench, and enjoy the view while savoring an incredible bite of pizza.
Todd Rogers
Walk up, buy your pizza 🍕 and wait a few minutes while they heat it up in the oven. Simple and easy.
Leo
The service is absolutely amazing, everyone is super nice. As a New Yorker myself, I can say that NYC pizza has nothing on this.
That 65th was was 5546
Atmosphere: 3
Great pizza by the slice… My favorite are the Big Sur and the pesto
This is a grab and go place… Very, very limited seating
This place was incredible, we were visiting the city, knew nothing about the place but while walking, we kept seeing dozens of people with pizza boxes, after a while we discerned the pizza must be amazing. As we walked towards it, we could see they had their own pizza box garbage rack. It was stacked with boxes. We got our slice and were beyond impressed . We kept thinking about that spot the rest of the trip. We love it!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cowell's Combo Pizza, Little Sur
Pizza is always good... but Pizza my heart is great! Try their ranch dressing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Perfect beachside pizza spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crispy crust
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizzas 🍕 tried 4 different toppings and all were great.
Food: 5
Online ordering said 55-65 minutes, but the workers told me and others more like 20-30 minutes. Pizza was soggy and cold when we picked up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Hands down the best pizza ever! Pepperoni is my favorite. I drove from Olympia Washington to Lake Arrowhead and made sure to stop in Capitola just to get a pizza! My kids grew up on this pizza when I lived in Pleasanton. We spent our summers in Capitola and enjoyed Pizza of my Heart!💕💕💕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love getting pizza by the slice here but this time we ordered a whole pie while we were walking in the village and they had it ready in 20 minutes, it was great as usual
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome pizza. My family came to visit Capitola and take pictures of the beautiful beach and colorful houses nearby. Pizza My Heart caught our eyes as we were walking around.
We ordered the following:
🏆 Big Sur - it has been the two time world champion best pizza! So we had to try. Indeed there’s a reason why it is a winner
🍍 Maui Wowie - if you love Pineapple pizza / Hawaiian pizza, you Must order this. It’s the best we’ve ever had. It was a Hit
🥓 D’Lex Chicken and Bacon - for meat lovers
What stood out to us has been the fact that the crust is thin and they cook the pizza right in the oven for you. If you ordered individual slices they should come out of the oven in 2-3 min. The staff know what they are doing.
The pizza is great to eat while walking along the beach. There are no indoor seating, but plenty of benches and the whole beach to sit and eat. Our family stood outside, huddled around in a circle, and took turns taking a bite of each pizza. We loved it.
Thank you all for your service and the food you make to feed people. God bless you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing!!!!!!!!!
This pizza spot seriously blew me away. I got a slice of their pesto pizza and one called Little Sur—and man, both were absolutely delicious. The pesto slice was so good, we had to go back for another. It was ooey, gooey, cheesy, and perfectly melty—hands down one of the best slices I’ve ever had. Every bite was packed with flavor.
I stuck to the vegetarian options since the non-veg ones weren’t halal, but if they’re anything like the ones I tried, I bet they’re just as amazing. Between the two, I liked the pesto more—it really hit the spot.
Price-wise, it’s about $7 per slice—not the cheapest, but honestly, for the taste, totally worth it. The service was decent. The person who served us wasn’t super interactive, but hey, maybe it just wasn’t their day. No complaints though!
The location is great too—it’s right by the beach, so you can grab a slice, find a bench, and enjoy the view while savoring an incredible bite of pizza.
Walk up, buy your pizza 🍕 and wait a few minutes while they heat it up in the oven. Simple and easy.
The service is absolutely amazing, everyone is super nice. As a New Yorker myself, I can say that NYC pizza has nothing on this.
Loading...