Always Yours Bakery Cafe

20634 Rustic Dr, Castro Valley
(510) 363-8736

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Half Dozen Regular Macarons
Lunar New Year Macaroons
Japanese Soufflé Slice
Boba Tea and Pastries
Character Macarons
Biscoff Cheesecake
Ube Crinkle Cookie
Japanese Soufflé
Fruit Lemon Tart
Oreo Cream Puff

Menu

Beverages
Assam Boba Milk Tea (22 oz)
Assam black tea with your choice of milk and our signature brown sugar honey boba.
Black Sugar Matcha Latte (22 oz)
Premium jade leaf matcha ceremonial grade matcha with your choice of milk, sweetened with black sugar.
Dark Roast Oolong Tea with Salted Cheese (22 oz)
Roasted oolong tea topped with our housemade salted cheese cream.
Earl Grey Creme Brulee Milk Tea (22 oz)
Creamy earl grey tea with your choice of milk, topped with our housemade salted cheese cream, torched sugar, and crème brûlée pudding. More of a dessert than a drink, and our most popular drink!
Guava Cheese Black Tea (22 oz)
Assam black tea sweetened with guava nectar and topped with our housemade salted cheese cream.
Jasmine Milk Tea (22 oz)
Classic jasmine green tea with your choice of milk.
Mango Matcha Latte (22 oz)
Premium ceremonial grade matcha with your choice of milk, sweetened with fresh mango puree.
Passion Fruit Black or Green Tea (22 oz)
Fresh passion fruit purée with our classic jasmine green tea or Assam black tea.
Peach Oolong Tea or Milk Tea (22 oz)
Ripe peach-infused oolong tea with your choice of milk or without milk.
Rose Garden Fruit Tea (22 oz)
Non-caffeinated. A floral yet fruity tea with fresh strawberries.
Strawberry Mango Fruit Tea (22 oz)
A refreshing drink made with green tea, fresh strawberry, and mango puree. Perfect for a hot day!
Strawberry Matcha Latte (22 oz)
Premium ceremonial grade matcha with your choice of milk, sweetened with fresh strawberry purée.
Tiger Sugar Milk Tea (22 oz)
Assam black tea with your choice of milk, sweetened with black sugar.

Macarons
Half Dozen (6) Variety Box of Macarons
6 of our most popular macaron flavors! A surprise box of our choice, complete with a macaron menu guide so you know what you are getting.
Dozen (12) Variety Box of Macarons
12 of our most popular regular macaron flavors! Comes with a macaron menu to let you know what flavors you've gotten.
Half Dozen (6) Variety Box of Character Macarons
Get a random assortment of our favorite character macarons and flavors in the shop! You never know what you may get! (We will label the flavor).
Dozen (12) Variety Box of Character Macarons
Get a random assortment (12) of our popular character macaron designs and flavors! We will label them on the box.

Cakes
Japanese Souffle Cheesecake (Slice)
A moist, light, and fluffy souffle cheesecake infused with vanilla bean, mango, or ube.
Strawberry Shortcake Box
Housemade chiffon cake layered with diplomat cream (vanilla pastry cream/whipped cream), strawberry jam, and fresh strawberries.
Earl Grey Tres Leches Cake
Sponge cake soaked in an earl grey tea-infused milk bath topped with earl grey whipped cream.

Small Desserts
Crème Brûlée
Creamy, rich custard infused with vanilla bean, topped with torched sugar.
Fruit Custard Tart
A buttery tart crust filled with either pastry cream or lemon curd.
Mini Cheesecake
A mini New-York style vanilla cheesecake topped with mascarpone cream and fresh berries.
Tiramisu Cup
Coffee-soaked ladyfingers between layers of vanilla mascarpone whipped cream, topped with cocoa powder.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+39 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+38 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I had the pleasure of working with Natalie & Always Yours Bakery for our last wedding of the event season! Always Yours Bakery has the best tiny desserts, boba, and service! I was initially afraid that we had too many desserts for the guests; but everything was gone within minutes of Natalie setting up the dessert & boba bar!

From the beginning of the planning process, Natalie was responsive, kind, and flexible. As a wedding planner, it is so imperative...
November 2025
Came to this place seeing the reviews. I just ordered a few items just to make sure i love them and boy, oh yeah..they were delicious. I ordered their pumpkin cheesecake (seasonal), Oreo chocolate cake and their new Matcha green tea with Pistachios. I would definitely go back for more. Sad its not in my area (Pleasanton)
November 2025
Very nice place to come sit and enjoy a few cookies and a drink.
I personally got and enjoyed the Ube Crinkle Cookie. A very soft center crunchy edges and a sweet buttery flavor making it a very delicious purchase.
Also enjoyed a Tiramisu Cup.
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Nick The Greek | Castro Valley - 20628 Rustic Dr
Greek, Salad, Soup, Vegan
iSushi - 20649 Rustic Dr
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Vegan
Loard's Ice Cream - 3389 Village Dr
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream

Always Yours Bakery Cafe

20634 Rustic Dr, Castro Valley, CA 94546
(510) 363-8736