Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Castro Valley
20674 Rustic Dr, Castro Valley
(510) 398-8532
Customers' Favorites
Tritip Sandwich
The Mr Pickle
Cookies
Featured items
Tom Turkey
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, + "The Works"
Listen Linda
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, Avocado, + "The Works"
BLAT
Bacon, Lettuce, Avocado, Tomato, Mayo on Toasted Multi-Grain
The Mr. Pickle
Chicken Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado, + "The Works"
Cali Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, Avocado, Cucumbers, + "The Works"
The Hero
Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Ham, Cheddar, + "The Works"
Italian
Pastrami, Ham, Salami, Provolone, Italian Dressing, + "The Works"
Big Easy
Chicken Salad, Swiss, Avocado, + "The Works"
Mrs. Pickle
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado + "The Works"
Meatball
Italian Meatballs, Provolone, Marinara Sauce, Garlic Sauce.
Avocado Sando
One full fresh Avocado, cucumbers, Swiss + "The Works".
The "O.G." Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, + "The Works"
BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo on Toasted Multi-Grain
Della's Deli
Turkey Breast, Salami, Ham, Cheddar, + "The Works"
CJ's Pastrami
Pastrami, Swiss, Mustard, Pickle.
Hot "T"
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Cranberry Sauce, + "The Works"
Big Jake
Turkey Breast, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + "The Works"
Hang Loose
Pastrami, Bacon, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + "The Works"
Chef Salad
Turkey Breast, Smoked Ham, Bacon, Cheddar, Swiss, Tomato, Cucumber, Pepperoncini, Croutons & Choice of Dressing
Truly Vegan
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Avocado, Red Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini, Mustard & Garlic Sauce
Whole Hot Premium
CJ's Pastrami
Pastrami, Swiss, Mustard, Pickle.
Meatball
Italian Meatballs, Provolone, Marinara Sauce, Garlic Sauce.
Kickin' Chicken
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Hot Sauce, + "The Works"
Hang Loose
Pastrami, Bacon, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + "The Works"
The Mr. Pickle
Chicken Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado, + "The Works"
Hot "T"
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Cranberry Sauce, + "The Works"
Got Beef
Roast Beef, Pastrami, Monterey Jack, + "The Works"
Mrs. Pickle
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado + "The Works"
BBQ Melt
Chicken Breast, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + "The Works"
French Dip
Roast Beef, Horseradish Mayo, Garlic Sauce, Au Jus.
Baja Cheesesteak
Roast Beef, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Red Bell Peppers, Onion, Pepperoncini.
Reuben
Pastrami, Swiss, Sauerkraut, Thousand Island on Toasted Marble Rye.
Pickle Burger
Roast Beef, Cheddar, Thousand Island Dressing + "The Works"
Golden Gate
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Teriyaki Sauce, + "The Works"
Santa Maria Tri-Tip
Tri-Tip, BBQ Sauce, + "The Works"
Fast Eddy
Roast Beef, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + "The Works"
The Ranch
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Ranch Dressing, + "The Works"
Reggie-Reggie
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce + "The Works"
Spicy Bird
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Jalapenos, Baja Sauce + "The Works"
Half Hot Premium
Meatball
Italian Meatballs, Provolone, Marinara Sauce, Garlic Sauce.
Baja Cheesesteak
Roast Beef, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Red Bell Peppers, Onion, Pepperoncini.
French Dip
Roast Beef, Horseradish Mayo, Garlic Sauce, Au Jus.
Kickin' Chicken
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Hot Sauce, + "The Works"
Santa Maria Tri-Tip
Tri-Tip, BBQ Sauce, + "The Works"
Golden Gate
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Teriyaki Sauce, + "The Works"
CJ's Pastrami
Pastrami, Swiss, Mustard, Pickle
Mrs. Pickle
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado + "The Works"
The Ranch
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Ranch Dressing, + "The Works"
The Mr. Pickle
Chicken Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado, + "The Works"
Got Beef
Roast Beef, Pastrami, Monterey Jack, + "The Works"
Hot "T"
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Cranberry Sauce, + "The Works"
Spicy Bird
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Jalapenos, Baja Sauce + "The Works"
Pickle Burger
Roast Beef, Cheddar, Thousand Island Dressing + "The Works"
Hang Loose
Pastrami, Bacon, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + "The Works"
Fast Eddy
Roast Beef, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + "The Works"
BBQ Melt
Chicken Breast, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + "The Works"
Reggie-Reggie
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce + "The Works"
Whole Cold Premium
Tom Turkey
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, + "The Works"
Listen Linda
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, Avocado, + "The Works"
Italian
Pastrami, Ham, Salami, Provolone, Italian Dressing, + "The Works"
The "O.G." Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, + "The Works"
Della's Deli
Turkey Breast, Salami, Ham, Cheddar, + "The Works"
Big Easy
Chicken Salad, Swiss, Avocado, + "The Works"
Big Jake
Turkey Breast, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + "The Works"
The Hero
Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Ham, Cheddar, + "The Works"
Cali Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, Avocado, Cucumbers, + "The Works"
Say Cheese
Cheddar, Monterrey Jack, Swiss, Provolone + "The Works"
Half Cold Premium
Tom Turkey
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, + "The Works"
Italian
Pastrami, Ham, Salami, Provolone, Italian Dressing, + "The Works"
Cali Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, Avocado, Cucumbers, + "The Works"
The Hero
Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Ham, Cheddar, + "The Works"
Big Jake
Turkey Breast, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + "The Works"
Listen Linda
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, Avocado, + "The Works"
Big Easy
Chicken Salad, Swiss, Avocado, + "The Works"
Della's Deli
Turkey Breast, Salami, Ham, Cheddar, + "The Works"
The "O.G." Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, + "The Works"
Say Cheese
Cheddar, Monterrey Jack, Swiss, Provolone + "The Works"
Classics
BLAT
Bacon, Lettuce, Avocado, Tomato, Mayo on Toasted Multi-Grain
Club
Turkey Breast, Ham, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomato, Lettuce, Mayo, on Toasted Multi-Grain
BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo on Toasted Multi-Grain
Whole Wholesome Choice
Truly Vegan
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Avocado, Red Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini, Mustard & Garlic Sauce
Veggie Pestoli
Pesto Aioli, Avocado, Red Bell Pepper, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini & Cheddar
Avocado Sando
One full fresh Avocado, cucumbers, Swiss + "The Works".
Summer Love Wrap
Turkey Breast, Avocado, Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Baja Sauce, + "The Works" on your choice of Wrap
Half Wholesome Choice
Truly Vegan
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Avocado, Red Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini, Mustard & Garlic Sauce
Avocado Sando
One half fresh Avocado, Swiss, cucumbers, + "The Works".
Veggie Pestoli
Pesto Aioli, Avocado, Red Bell Pepper, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini & Cheddar
My Deli
My Deli
Select your bread, meat, cheese, + "The Works"
1/2 My Deli
Select your bread, meat, cheese, + "The Works"
Salads
BBQ Tri-Tip Salad
Tri-Tip, Romaine, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Pepperoncini, Croutons & BBQ Ranch Dressing
Chef Salad
Turkey Breast, Smoked Ham, Bacon, Cheddar, Swiss, Tomato, Cucumber, Pepperoncini, Croutons & Choice of Dressing
Santa Fe Salad
Chicken Breast, Romaine, Avocado, Red Bell Pepper, Tomato, Jalapeño, Pepper Jack, Tortilla Strips & Baja Sauce
House Salad
Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Pepperoncini, Croutons & Choice of Dressing
Tuna Salad Salad
Albacore Tuna Salad, Romaine, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Pepperoncini, Croutons & Choice of Dressing
Combos
Bottled Beverage & Chips
Large Fountain & Chips
Regular Fountain & Chips
Sides & Chips
Regular Chips
3 Chocolate Chip Cookies
Jumbo Dill Pickle #
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie (1-dozen)
Chocolate Chip Cookie (2-dozen)
Dirty Chips
Macaroni Salad
Potato Salad
Sauces On The Side
Dressing On The Side
Beverages
Bottled Soda
Regular Fountain Beverage
Large Fountain Beverage
Lipton Pure Leaf
Aquafina Water
Kids Menu
Kids Turkey Meal
Turkey and your choice of cheese, includes applesauce, and cookie.
Kids Ham Meal
Ham and your choice of cheese, includes applesauce, and cookie.
Kids Salami Meal
Salami and your choice of cheese, includes applesauce, and cookie.
Kids PB&J Meal
Peanut butter and strawberry jelly, includes applesauce, and cookie.
Applesauce
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I choose this shop 9 out of 10 times because, honestly, one sandwich counts as both lunch and dinner for me. Mr. Pickle’s has a unique menu and ingredients list that I think sets it apart from other larger chains—think Dutch crunch rolls, peperoncinis, avocado at no extra charge in some recipes, and potato salads. My favorite part, though, is the surprise chocolate chip cookie (or sometimes multiple cookies) that I find at the bottom of my bag every time. It’s a small detail,...
May 2025
This was my first time trying Mr. Pickles, and I ordered pastrami, on Dutch crunch bread, with mayo, mustard, avocado, pickles, and cucumbers, lettuce, pepper jack cheese, American cheese, with a bowl of macaroni salad. It was a great portion and was very tasty. I received a chocolate cookie that was given with no extra cost. I would recommend it, and I will be ordering here again.
September 2024
You May Also Like
Vitality Bowls Castro Valley - 20668 Rustic Dr
![]()
Health Food, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Acai Bowls, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly
Rigatoni's Restaurant - Castro Valley - 20680 Rustic Dr
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian
iSushi - 20649 Rustic Dr
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Vegan
Low cost and healthy. I'll definitely be back!