Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos

$ • Pizza, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian

Menu Order Online

About Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos

Pie In The Sky Pizza in Cayucos is a cozy spot for casual lunch or takeout, serving incredible and delicious pizza. The food is very good and overall impressive, with a high quality product made with care. The crust is repeatedly highlighted as incredible, out of this world, buttery, flaky, and perfectly crispy, light & airy, and chewy, notably as a classic sourdough. The dough is also incredible. Pies have ample cheese, rich and full of flavor fillings, and a white sauce. Specific praised pizzas include the margarita, hot honey, and the seasonal special elote pizza, described as bomb. The half cheese half pep is also recommended, with a suggestion to order a whole pie.

The service is great with super friendly, warm, attentive, and welcoming staff who provide clear communication. The atmosphere feels personal and special. It is a fantastic by-the-slice place and a hidden gem. A note is that toppings can be skimpy, and there can be about an hour wait time, for which a text service is suggested. It is also wished they were open later. Customers do not mind the wait and would definitely be back, recommending the experience.