Cake by Sierra

1423 Cuyamaca St, El Cajon
(858) 381-4208

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sierra Petersen

Sierra made my gender reveal cake and absolutely killed it! I couldn’t have asked for a better cake ? The turn around time was relatively fast for how soon I asked for it, I’m so appreciative it. Not only does it look aesthetically pleasing, but it tasted so good!

Marlisys Hirako

I'm so happy I found Cake by Sierra!! She made the coolest cake inspired by One Piece for my daughters birthday! It looked incredible and was delicious too! Excellent customer service and pick up was simple! Will definitely get all my cakes from Sierra in the future!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Meghan Lacey

Sierra made my nieces birthday cake. We chose birthday sprinkle and it was delicious! The frosting was sweet but not too sweet and her decorating skills are amazing. Sierra was easy to communicate and coordinate with. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a custom cake!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Hong

Working with Sierra is a dream! She's timely in her communication, easy to work with, has great ideas, and is super friendly! I ordered a cake for my parent's 40th anniversary and was happy to contribute her decorating ideas and to give me a few different quotes for different size cakes. Her cake tasted amazing and looked incredible as well! I would highly recommend hiring Sierra for your cake needs! She won't disappoint!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Mousse

Perla Holahan

By far the best wedding cake I've ever tasted and not saying it because it was mine. My favorite was the Strawberry. I was sad when I didn't have any left ?. I went in blind. We didn't meet, it was all done over email and example screenshots of cakes I liked. It came out above and beyond what I expected and would highly recommend her cakes!!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Orlando Sandoval

Had A Cake made for my daughter’s birthday {Oogie Boogie} themed, Came out amazing and tasted amazing…

jenna kim

My boyfriend got me a cake from here for my birthday and it was the most stunning cake i’ve ever seen! It looked like it was straight out of pinterest and she really did an amazing job of listening to his requests of what I liked. It came out so beautiful and perfect.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: White Chocolate and Raspberry Mousse

Perlita Padilla

By far the best wedding cake I've ever tasted and not saying it because it was mine. My favorite was the Strawberry. I was sad when I didn't have any left ?. I went in blind. We didn't meet, it was all done over email and example screenshots of cakes I liked. It came out above and beyond what I expected and would highly recommend her cakes!!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dalia Nissim

Sierra made my daughter’s Minecraft Themed Birthday Cake. It was the first time I have used her services and she definitely didn’t disappoint. Her price seemed reasonable to me and still top notch quality. From the beginning when I contacted her about what I was looking for, to the end where she delivered it to the party venue. It was top class. Will definitely recommend her to others and will use her for my daughter’s birthday cakes again. The inside of the cake was tasty and fluffy and not overly sweet which is what I wanted. Even the icing/ frosting wasn’t super sweet and everything on the design was edible. Daughter chose Red Velvet for the cake. Definitely use Sierra for your cake needs.

Kathleen Pangan

The cookies and cream and strawberry cakes were delicious. Strawberry was my personal favorite and had actual strawberries in it. The cake was moist and fresh. The decor was beautifully made to our specification. She worked with us on designing something Dungeons and Dragons themed and integrated several designs into two layers and allowed the perfect amount of room for a topper I wanted, including dowels so the heavy 1.5 lb topper would be supported. She expertly printed the font I wanted for initials and ampersand, made a nice castle with greenery and dice-shaped windows, dragon scales, and a mini dragon tail wrapped between the layers. It was beautiful and delicious, and everyone loved it.

K G. M

Just found my To go to Cake Artist!Can’t recommend her enough.Had hard time finding someone in SD who’s talented enough, easy going, and gets the idea you have in mind smoothly without complications.Sierra is absolutely amazing starting with her customer service to being an amazing artist.Definitely the cake made the birthday a talk about! And the taste..! It’s not very strawdelicious.Can’t thank you enough and can’t wait for the next birthday

Liliana Valencia

My son told me he wanted a Sonic the Hedgehog cake and I didn't think we'd be able to get one in time. I reached out to Sierra and she was able to assist us. The cake came out perfect and tasted amazing too (cookies and cream)! My son was in love. 100% recommend.

Krista Morales

Sierra did my cake and cupcakes for my 18th debut and it was just absolutely gorgeous! Worked w me very well to get the exact decor I wanted, was very helpful w some last minute changes, and delivery was flawless! The cake was also delicious ? Will definitely come back to her for any future events and so should you!

Linda Crane

Sierra does beautiful work. Very talented. I highly recommend Sierra for all your baked goods. You won’t be disappointed.🎂👍

Loading...