Pile High Deli

1331 Broadway St, Eureka
(707) 443-5362

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kevin Cronquist

Best Sandwiches in Humboldt County!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastrami, Muffaletta, Hot Pastrami, Avocado, Dutch Crunch Roll, Italian Combo, Crunch Roll, Potato Salad, Dungeness Crab, Garlic Herb Turkey

Loretta David

BEST ever

kinsey mcdonald

Stopped here while searching for a deli spot on a day trip from Oregon. We are visiting from Florida. My boyfriend and I both took a bite and said this is the best sandwich we have had in a long while! Exactly what I was craving out of a deli sandwich!

Liam Achterberg-Muñoz

Really delicious sandwiches!

katherine Soudan

Yummy filled.my tummy 😋

W Wildn

Best sandwich in Humboldt county, Jersey Mike's can take a lesson....

Andrew Parent

Great service they have a lot of choices for a small sandwich shop. Got the Cobb (turkey B cheese avocado) huge sandwich. Parking sucks but if that's the worst thing then I'm happy.

James Crutchfield

Great deli sandwich, bread was amazing!

Sienna Carter

Great sandwiches very filling. I got the pulled pork sandwich and it was amazing 10/10.

Haley Finegan

BEST sandwiches in town! Their potato salad is also soo good & very different from your traditional which I love.

Tasheena Moon

Went to grab a sandwich , walked in and the girl was extremely rude all I did was ask if she had a half sandwich and she gave me so much attitude honestly I really wanted to try this place with my boyfriend but I won’t ever come back again if this lady is the face of this business because honestly that is super unprofessional. This also isn’t the first time that something like this happened I also came to this location with my mom one time and we kindly asked if they would accept food stamps and she was also just super unnecessarily rude . I really can’t stand when people choose to be like this like if you aren’t happy with your job leave . Simple as that . If it was my choice she would be fired and never get close to my business again. It’s crazy when businesses portray themselves as super professional and nice and then have rude ignorant people like that working , being the face of their business crazy 💀 this was Sunday March 9th around 11:10 am so whoever was working then.

Kade Something

Food: Absolutely amazing. They have vegetarian options, tons of meat options, build your own, template sandwiches, and more. The food is plentiful, enough for two meals for some folks (like me). It's similar to how subway is set up but the quality of food is leagues better. The bread tastes fresh and there's an option to have your bread toasted, and they have so many cheese options (my favorite!).

Service: Top notch. Food is a little spendy however its worth it for a great sandwich. Everyone is extremely friendly and quick, they ask questions to make sure you're getting what you want, the relationships between the employees are very friendly, aiding in a welcoming atmosphere.

Atmosphere: Giving it 4.5/5 because of the location itself, its a bit out of the way hiding between some inconspicuous buildings. You can almost miss it, its got a pretty small parking lot and the inside is a little crowded when its lunchtime (which, to be fair happens in most places), but it felt quite cramped so be warned about that. Otherwise great lighting, outdoor seating, not too hot or cold inside (even when cramped).

Overall, 4.8/5 will be coming back again.

DANIELLE SANDERS

Most def recommend the hot pastrami on a roll, with munster and mayo, mustard, lettuce, n tomato. Yum and the sandwiches are huge

RE Cooper

I am originally from NY. Then I spent a lot of my life in Southern California. Historically, Reubens are made with Corned beef not Pastrami. 1st issue I had was the young woman on the phone. she was being quite argumentative when it came to my order. My older son and I wanted hot pastramis on rye with a side of sauerkraut. She said that's a Reuben. I'm like no it's not. It went back and forth. She told me there Reubens were made with Pastrami. I was like fine....
The Sandwiches were horrible. The Rye Bread was soggy, the Pastrami had absolutely no taste and the tiny side of sauerkraut we were given was warm, soggy, and tasteless.
If you're used to New York Pastrami , Rye and Sauerkraut or even So Cal, I would definitely not recommend

Nicholas T Stine

No dine in, but it's a clean establishment, with friendly staff. Full of good recommendations. I thoroughly enjoy it!

Loading...