Paul’s live from ny pizza eureka ca
604 F St, Eureka
(707) 442-5800
Recent Reviews
Sort by
604 F St, Eureka
(707) 442-5800
Pizza was pretty good. The service could've been better. We ordered garlic knots that never came. This is the main reason, myself as a consumer, hate to tip restaurants before service is given. After letting the waitress know, she forgot. We asked for a refund on the knots & were obliged. No hard feelings on my end except to say the place wasn't real busy so I'm not sure how that slipped by.
2nd best pizza in humboldt, still fantastic
12” gluten free crust is available and delicious.
Not a dedicated kitchen but never had an issue.
Great pizza, what else needs to be said
Friendly service, family style atmosphere. Food was made quickly and very tasty. I recommend a visit. Priced good. Able to have a drink comfortably while you wait for your order.
Really good pizza.
I am CA-bred NY-raised and there was only one Paul’s pizza I’ve had that wasn’t foldable enough! It was the “Joe Namath” and honestly something about it was still… je me me sais quois 🤔🧐 delicious!
Might be big but skinny. Might be tasty but hardly enough ingredients for how expensive the pizza's are. Love the dine in and customer service.
Service was great, even gave treat to take with me for dog...
Pizza is just good . Not taking orders for whole pizzas past 7pm with 5 slices in the window. Pure lazy. They close early enough and to not take orders great way to not make money and piss off the locals .
Restaurantji Recommends
First stop for dinner on our Honeymoon. The food came quickly, staff were super friendly, and the drinks were great too.
This is New York style and I love The Godfather pizza! Huge slices, great quality ingredients. I found my go-to pizza in Eureka.
It's the best. Paul stands behind everything they make.
I'm a big fan of pizza by the slice and Paul's never disappoints! NY style pizza that hits all the right notes. Perfectly crisp, golden crust with a slight char, and a rich, tangy tomato sauce that doesn’t overwhelm. A balanced finish that leaves you wanting more. A classic slice.
If you want an authentic tasting NY slice, this is a great place to come. Tried a standard pepperoni and what I think was their version of a Hawaiian pizza. Both were very good. Staff was very nice too.
Loading...