Upper Crust Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, Salad, Chicken WingsAbout Upper Crust Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
House Combination Pizza
Hawaiian Spicy Hawaiian
Margherita Pizzas
Veggie Pesto
Meat Lovers
Upper Crust Pizzeria Reviews
157 ratings
Share your opinion about Upper Crust Pizzeria
Good pizza and friendly staff
Pizza was amazing, great dough, well balanced topings. Calzone was good too. Skip the salad, nothing to fuss about and overpriced
Small little pizza shop right when you get into Gualala! Absolutely delicious pizza, the Californian and the Sea Ranch were our favorite. Staff was incredibly helpful, we were going to take the pizzas to go, up to Bower Park for a picnic but it was closed - so they let us dine in instead!
Hours
| Monday | 3 - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 3 - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 3 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 3 - 8PM |
| Friday | 3 - 8PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 8PM |
| Sunday | 2 - 8PM |
Upper Crust Pizzeria is a small, busy place loved by locals, evident as they picked up pizzas. The veggie pesto pizza was scrumptious with incredible vegetables and cheeses. Despite the paper plate tearing, the pizza was stunningly excellent, with every ingredient in the vegetable pizza being tasted. A visitor on a road trip declared it the best pizza ever, praising the perfect dough thickness and awesome flavor. The group wished for a bigger pizza due to their enjoyment, with great customer service, cold beers, and a good view enhancing the experience. The house combo is one of the best pizzas around, with great crust, sauce, and quality toppings. The cozy atmosphere can get cramped during dinner, but outdoor seating is available when the weather allows. Parking is limited out front, but the nearby Gualala Supermarket lot offers a quick walk. Orders are ready on time, and the menu includes olive oil base options for those avoiding garlic. Even months later, visitors still think about the fantastic pizza.
Recently, guests praised the friendly personnel and delicious pizza. One visitor mentioned that even when busy on a Friday night, the staff accepted their order and let them dine in after 8 pm, highlighting their great service. Another group, staying in Gualala, found the pizza sooo good that everyone raved and fought over leftovers. Seating can be limited indoors and outdoors, but the atmosphere remains cozy and welcoming. The place, located in downtown Gualala, smells exactly like a great pizza joint should. Service is quick, with staff focused on delivering fresh, tasty pizzas just minutes after ordering, even during busy times. The food consistently hits the mark, making it a perfect ending to a visit to this majestic location. Overall, Upper Crust Pizzeria offers a warm, friendly environment with excellent pizza and attentive service, earning high praise from many satisfied customers.