17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lancaster

“RigaTony's Pizza & Pasta is a local eatery that offers a unique alternative to big pizza chains. While some customers have noted that the pizza can be too salty and the crust may be floppy due to the conveyor oven, others have praised the flavorful pizzas with good portion toppings. The restaurant also serves tasty wings and fries, although some found the fries to be over-seasoned. The customer service is consistently highly rated, with friendly and attentive staff. The menu offers a variety of options, including pasta, subs, and calzones, although some dishes may be hit or miss. Despite some inconsistencies, RigaTony's has built a loyal following, with customers willing to drive 25 minutes for their fix. With its good value for the price and commitment to customer satisfaction, RigaTony's is definitely worth a try for those looking for a fresh take on traditional pizza and pasta.“

“Big Belly Pizza Company is known for its fantastic dill pizza and good burger. The quality and flavor never disappoint, making it the go-to place for takeout. The crispy crust and delicious toppings set their pizza apart from the competition. The wings are a must-try with any pizza. The Mac and cheese bites are a hit with young diners. Overall, a consistent and kid-friendly spot for delicious pizza and sides.“

“Round Table Pizza offers outstanding red sauce and gooey cheese on their delicious pepperoni pizza. Customers might find the sauce a bit spicy for children, but it's well worth the wait. While some had trouble with online ordering and coupons, the friendly and humorous staff, like Matt and the girl with red hair, provide amazing customer service. In a town where good service can be hard to find, this pizzeria stands out for making every visit a pleasant experience.“

“Poppy Pizzeria offers good food with very friendly service in a comfy, open setting. The pizza is praised for its perfect crust, robust tomato sauce, and deliciously stretchy cheese. The pasta is also highly recommended. The atmosphere is pleasant with music at a comfortable volume. Special events like quarter auctions add to the fun experience. The staff is very sweet and professional, even under pressure.“

“Bravery Brewing Company is a top-notch micro-brewery in the western US, known for its hand-crafted selection of beer, all brewed on-site. The owners take great pride in the quality, offering an impressive variety of brews with complex flavors. The pizza is also a highlight. The family-owned establishment features a welcoming atmosphere, with friendly and helpful staff. Notable decor includes a display of R. Lee Ermey's Full Metal Jacket uniform. They offer cans to go and growlers for take-home refills.“

“Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta is a highly recommended restaurant under new ownership, offering delicious pizzas and great customer service. The staff is super friendly, and the owners care about their community. The menu features a wide variety of options, including custom pizzas with 18 toppings, thin or pan crust, and types of sauce. They also serve great wings and offer pickup, delivery, or in-person dining. With big improvements to their food and service, Captain Tony's is a must-try for pizza lovers.“

“Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta, under new ownership, offers great food and customer service. Their pizza is highly recommended, with some considering it the best in the area. While some have experienced poor service in the past, the new owners are working to improve the experience. The restaurant is ideal for take-out and delivery, with plans to become more involved in the community.“

“Lancaster Marketplace is a welcoming destination for various activities. It features spacious sidewalks, ideal for walks, and a dollar store for refreshments. The shopping center has recently seen a resurgence, hosting a variety of businesses such as restaurants, a hobby shop, Harbor Freight, and a Bin Store. Of particular interest is a store selling RC cars and parts, including a race track for testing or competing with cars. Customers appreciate the excellent service and the opportunity to try out or race their own cars.“

“Get Fresh Cafe offers a welcoming atmosphere with a cozy, intimate setting and a charming decor. The menu boasts a variety of healthy, made-fresh options that cater to different dietary needs, including dairy-free, gluten-free, keto-friendly, vegetarian, and vegan choices. The food is consistently tasty, and the staff is friendly and accommodating. Enjoy scrumptious treats like their cookies, and feel good about what you eat. With a cheerful and helpful team, Get Fresh Cafe is a great spot to relax and refuel.“

“Franklin's Cafe is a local gem that serves up delicious food with consistent quality. The restaurant is known for its friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. The menu offers a variety of options, including the popular Veggie Breakfast Burrito, Philly cheese steak, and carne asada burrito. Vegetarians will appreciate the Veggie Burrito. The cafe also serves breakfast options like steak and eggs, which is a great value. With a focus on freshness and quality, Franklin's Cafe is a must-visit for lunchtime.“

“Papa John's Pizza offers great pizzas that are delivered promptly. They often have specials available through their app. Customers have consistently received their orders correctly, with no disappointments. While the pizza is always good, some reviewers have mixed opinions on the wings, with one finding them lacking in sauce. The staff, including helpful and friendly team members like Kari, provide excellent customer service. However, there have been occasional issues with overbaking and cheese content.“

“Chuck E. Cheese is a popular spot for celebrations and family fun. The restaurant has undergone recent upgrades, including new games and a clean atmosphere. Service is good, and the staff work hard to ensure a enjoyable experience. The food and salad bar are decent, although a bit pricey. A small trampoline area is available for an additional fee. While it can get busy and staff may be short-staffed, the kids have a blast playing games for all ages, with few broken games to spoil the fun.“

“Papa Johns Pizza offers good pizza with friendly delivery service and ample parking. The calzone bites provide decent portions and value, though some find them a bit salty. The restaurant also caters to customers with dietary restrictions, providing gluten-free pizza options that satisfy customers.“

“Lemon Leaf Cafe, located in Palmdale, is a hidden gem known for its excellent service, fair prices, and relaxing ambiance with a view of the adjacent golf course. The cafe offers a smaller but varied menu, including a Caesar Salad, Pizza, and Greek Salad with delicious dressing. Their homemade-tasting chocolate cake is a popular dessert choice. The cafe has received praise for its quick and graceful response to last-minute catering requests, making it a reliable choice for events. Despite the limited hours, customers appreciate the ability to hold conversations without shouting. Overall, Lemon Leaf Cafe provides a pleasant dining experience with high-quality food.“

“Gino's Italian Restaurant is a beloved establishment that has been serving traditional Italian cuisine for years. The restaurant's crispy crust pizzas are a highlight, with perfect cheese and a sauce that balances spicy and sweet flavors. The menu also features authentic Italian dishes, including ravioli with generous amounts of Ricotta and noodles cooked al dente, as well as spaghetti, manicotti, and lasagna that are true to the Italian tradition. A popular item is the Original Baron, a dish that has been a customer favorite for decades. With two locations still open, Gino's remains a great option for those seeking a taste of Italy.“

“Pizza Hut is a popular spot for those who love BBQ chicken wings. Some customers find the drink selection lacking, but the bone-in BBQ chicken wings are a hit. However, the online ordering system can sometimes be down, causing inconvenience for customers trying to use rewards or coupons. Despite this, the E Ave J location in Lancaster stands out for its delicious pizza and speedy delivery. The managers and staff at this location are commended for their great service.“