This place appears to have a great concept upon opening but it’s now very run down and not clean. We arrived not long after opening and the bathroom was not clean and the yard was a mess. Toys and equipment strewn about. Insatiable sun bleached and it’s very much at your own risk. Pizza was just okay and slightly undercooked for a wood fire pizza.
Julia Vasquez
Great place to Eat . All ingredients r fresh . Friendly servi not overcrowded. Piz?a r cooked the way u like the crust too be Just ASK. Prices f fair. With Everythg going up. Just a great place to enjoy A nice tasting pizza. GOOD ENERGY THERE.
Karreno Alexanyan
Tic Tac Toe Pizza hits the spot every single time. The crust is that perfect golden balance between crispy and chewy, and the sauce has just the right tang. You can tell they care about quality — from the cheese to the toppings, everything tastes fresh and satisfying.
It’s the kind of place that reminds you why you fell in love with pizza in the first place. Whether you're grabbing a slice or a full pie, you can't go wrong. Friendly staff, quick service, and consistently great food. Definitely a go-to in the area!
Philip Sanchez
Poor customer service👎
Alejandra Lopez
Guy works in oven got 0 customer service,it was the worst pizza I ever had, it's was greasy and way too doughy the only thing I test was pepperoni otherwise the sauce was red and the dough was just a sponge
Happy J
Most random not only restaurant but overall place I’ve been to. Tic tac toe should give you a hint or warning to what will unfold in your dining experience here. No waiters or chefs just an iPad and a crochet pizza dude. Once you order you have 5 different areas to sit. Each one with its own unique style. We chose the outside next to a backyard play area. It felt like the McDonald’s playhouse/ party area. Felt a bit awkward but it wasn’t bad. The Buddha statues and restroom paper napkins made me feel safe strangely enough . To say this place has everything is an understatement. Coffee, parfaits, Kool-Aid jammers? they got it. They even have piano music coming from who knows where. The pizza was solid tho.
Mariam Bislamyan
Super delicious!! Super fresh! Super convenient!! A must try! Definitely ordering this again and again! Perrrrfect pair for margarita nights. Still was hot and sizzling after we picked it up and got home to eat.
Demetrious Z
Great people and great food. Bless these guys and it’s fun to play the piano they have also out in the outdoor seating area. Bless up to
Selim Yilmaz
This pizza has nothing to do with Italian pizza. The dough looks like bread dough. Margarita sauce is not good. I came here because I thought pizza cooked in a wood oven would be good, but I couldn't find that taste.
Savanna Mesch
I love having a wood fired pizza place in this area! Super affordable and nice vibes.
Just had my first visit to TicTacToe pizza, and wow this place hits all the marks for a perfect pizza night the crust has that perfect balance of chewy and generously loaded you can tell they really focus on quality here and it makes all the difference, I tried their tic tac toe and was blown away by the flavors,The staff was friendly,and the vibe of the place is welcoming, Definitely my new go to spot,if you're in the area, you've got to check it out
Kid-friendliness: The staff was so friendly with my kid
Tic Tac Toe Pizza in Eagle Rock is a gem for hand-crafted, wood-fired pizzas. I tried three types: the classic Margherita, made with fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and olive oil—a simple, delicious choice. The traditional pepperoni was another hit, with high-quality pepperoni that elevates the flavor. My favorite, though, was their signature Tic Tac Toe pizza with pepperoni, thinly sliced bell peppers, red onions, and house-made spicy honey—an unforgettable combination! The outdoor wood-fired oven adds charm, and there’s clean, comfortable patio and indoor seating. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, and parking is easy with plenty of street spaces. Highly recommend Tic Tac Toe Pizza for a must-try experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Margherita Pizza
Max Kelly
Truly excellent brick-oven pizza, made fresh and right in front of your eyes. Don’t be fooled by the casual exterior - this is a top notch pizza, with some of the best ingredients and friendliest staff you’ll find in the Eagle Rock area. And an incredible value for the price! I got a cheese pizza for just $10, and it’s much bigger than you’d expect for that price! Great for a quick bite, a casual date, or a large social gathering. Ample seating, quick turnaround, and even some nostalgic drinks and snacks in the refrigerator.
Max Fine
I’m confused how there are so many good reviews. Pizza looks good, toppings are good. The dough is terrible to the ninth degree. Think not in. Good way. Bad flavor. I had to throw it away. Service is great and its continent. Wish it was good because I’m right down the street. Dave would rate it a 2 or less. Maybe I got the dough on a bad day or something but just made the whole pizza really bad. Never had a problem with dough at any pizza place really.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Ondina Santa Maria
Awesome pizza been looking for a good pizza since Towne Pizza closed love the crust well done all the ingredients so fresh
This place appears to have a great concept upon opening but it’s now very run down and not clean. We arrived not long after opening and the bathroom was not clean and the yard was a mess. Toys and equipment strewn about. Insatiable sun bleached and it’s very much at your own risk. Pizza was just okay and slightly undercooked for a wood fire pizza.
Great place to Eat . All ingredients r fresh . Friendly servi not overcrowded. Piz?a r cooked the way u like the crust too be Just ASK. Prices f fair. With Everythg going up.
Just a great place to enjoy A nice tasting pizza. GOOD ENERGY THERE.
Tic Tac Toe Pizza hits the spot every single time. The crust is that perfect golden balance between crispy and chewy, and the sauce has just the right tang. You can tell they care about quality — from the cheese to the toppings, everything tastes fresh and satisfying.
It’s the kind of place that reminds you why you fell in love with pizza in the first place. Whether you're grabbing a slice or a full pie, you can't go wrong. Friendly staff, quick service, and consistently great food. Definitely a go-to in the area!
Poor customer service👎
Guy works in oven got 0 customer service,it was the worst pizza I ever had, it's was greasy and way too doughy the only thing I test was pepperoni otherwise the sauce was red and the dough was just a sponge
Most random not only restaurant but overall place I’ve been to. Tic tac toe should give you a hint or warning to what will unfold in your dining experience here. No waiters or chefs just an iPad and a crochet pizza dude. Once you order you have 5 different areas to sit. Each one with its own unique style. We chose the outside next to a backyard play area. It felt like the McDonald’s playhouse/ party area. Felt a bit awkward but it wasn’t bad. The Buddha statues and restroom paper napkins made me feel safe strangely enough . To say this place has everything is an understatement. Coffee, parfaits, Kool-Aid jammers? they got it. They even have piano music coming from who knows where. The pizza was solid tho.
Super delicious!! Super fresh! Super convenient!! A must try! Definitely ordering this again and again! Perrrrfect pair for margarita nights. Still was hot and sizzling after we picked it up and got home to eat.
Great people and great food. Bless these guys and it’s fun to play the piano they have also out in the outdoor seating area. Bless up to
This pizza has nothing to do with Italian pizza. The dough looks like bread dough. Margarita sauce is not good. I came here because I thought pizza cooked in a wood oven would be good, but I couldn't find that taste.
I love having a wood fired pizza place in this area! Super affordable and nice vibes.
Restaurantji Recommends
Just had my first visit to TicTacToe pizza, and wow this place hits all the marks for a perfect pizza night the crust has that perfect balance of chewy and generously loaded you can tell they really focus on quality here and it makes all the difference, I tried their tic tac toe and was blown away by the flavors,The staff was friendly,and the vibe of the place is welcoming, Definitely my new go to spot,if you're in the area, you've got to check it out
Kid-friendliness: The staff was so friendly with my kid
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Lentil Soup, Tictactoe Pizza, Greek Salad, Margherita Pizza
Tic Tac Toe Pizza in Eagle Rock is a gem for hand-crafted, wood-fired pizzas. I tried three types: the classic Margherita, made with fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and olive oil—a simple, delicious choice. The traditional pepperoni was another hit, with high-quality pepperoni that elevates the flavor. My favorite, though, was their signature Tic Tac Toe pizza with pepperoni, thinly sliced bell peppers, red onions, and house-made spicy honey—an unforgettable combination! The outdoor wood-fired oven adds charm, and there’s clean, comfortable patio and indoor seating. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, and parking is easy with plenty of street spaces. Highly recommend Tic Tac Toe Pizza for a must-try experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Margherita Pizza
Truly excellent brick-oven pizza, made fresh and right in front of your eyes. Don’t be fooled by the casual exterior - this is a top notch pizza, with some of the best ingredients and friendliest staff you’ll find in the Eagle Rock area. And an incredible value for the price! I got a cheese pizza for just $10, and it’s much bigger than you’d expect for that price!
Great for a quick bite, a casual date, or a large social gathering. Ample seating, quick turnaround, and even some nostalgic drinks and snacks in the refrigerator.
I’m confused how there are so many good reviews. Pizza looks good, toppings are good. The dough is terrible to the ninth degree. Think not in. Good way. Bad flavor. I had to throw it away. Service is great and its continent. Wish it was good because I’m right down the street. Dave would rate it a 2 or less. Maybe I got the dough on a bad day or something but just made the whole pizza really bad. Never had a problem with dough at any pizza place really.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Awesome pizza been looking for a good pizza since Towne Pizza closed love the crust well done all the ingredients so fresh
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...