Clutch for some delivery pizza after a night out! The pizza was delicious and pretty true to the New York style. Big and floppy but a nice crust and bit of crunch! The food came pretty fresh and was clutch for being open late and still amazing. The breadsticks weren't the best. Kinda bland and the marinara didn't want to stick to the bread but otherwise I can't recommend this higher if you need pizza late at night!
Robert T.
I really like their slices. I go to the liquor store in the same parking lot to grab a beer, my wife and I get a few slices, and we eat in the car.
Patrick R.
I walked in today and grabbed two slices: a cheese slice and a mushroom & pepperoni. I found it to be respectable slice-Great? No. But solid. Crust has that crunchy/chewy combo you know and expect from a NY slice. Cheese isn't too oily. The place has a neighborhood feel to it. The dude behind the counter didn't care who I was and I appreciate that. Good, not great. And who needs great anyways. I'm sick of people telling me "this is the greatest, you need to stand in line for an hour to get one though". And, I've stopped complaining about prices as long as the cost of a meal is under $20. Which it was. Good on you, Garage.
Danny “Danny Star” SeoService
Best Pizza in Town by far. (period) Must try out pizza in Silverlake. Open Late, have slices, soft drinks and cookies.
I visit March 26, 1:00 am. Had a supreme slice. I told them i want to try the sauce and the guy gave me for free! It was amazing! The slice was verrrryyyyy big. Sometimes this slice somewhere elses whole pizza lol!The place is very good! You must visit and eat.The staff was very friendly and nice.My server looks like Pavarotti in 40s. I like that atmosphere. Kindly, thank you good sir.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
Jared Mayo
Do not respect autism people
Juan Bobo
it isnt lamonicas nor giordianos nor pizzeria uno nor amerigo vespucci's choice of pie were he to be reincarnated as an angelino in the modern era or reborn altogether nor is it a marco roma or a viccinos in chicago's north shore or a homemade pizza company that used to exist in winnetka until roughly 2016 when the owner mysterious vanished but they do offer an acceptable slice perhaps a little doughy not crispy enough maybe one day they will achieve the renown amerigo did and get two continents as namesake
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
Gerry B.
Always slices to go. Wide variety and fast service. Parking out front and a chill vibe. Support local!
Derek W.
Great late night spot that serves NY style pizza at a great price! I got a whole pepperoni and it was delicious.
Pia J.
Amazing service. Kind and patient with me trying to make a decision. But I didn't really have to because they offer any slice on demand. It's sooo nice and clean in there as well. Definitely would come back again and again! Only deliemma is who to share all this goodness with. I literally chose this place on a whim after getting terrible service at a very near by vegan place. That's what happens when you smile, people order big and leave a tip!! The deserve to be packed and I'm sure they are in the evening.
$35 for a pizza is madness. Have we all gone insane???
JAmes JEon
A really good NY style pizza. We got the white pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
alicia tully
I am from New Jersey where we know how to make a pizza. This is the closest thing to a New York or Jersey pizza! It is so good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
tadeusz charewicz
My first time here, wanted a pizza, so decided to try it out. I ordered a pizza, off the menu, expecting to pay around $20. It came to $38 plus change. I was, ok, I'm hungry, go for it. I was told it would be about. 15 minutes. 35 minutes later, I was given my pizza., by the person who took my order. I expressed my frustration, being told it would be 15 minutes. He did not apologize, but retorted , rather rudely that that is an approximate time., and there were other orders ahead me. 15 minutes and 35 minutes is outside approximate. Had he said it would be 30 minutes, I could have decided to wait or cancel my order. And again, rather than being apologetic, he was very rude. I doubt I will go back again. So, if you want an expensive pizza and rude service, this is the place to go,otherwise choose another option.Parking: Parking us adequate
Clutch for some delivery pizza after a night out! The pizza was delicious and pretty true to the New York style. Big and floppy but a nice crust and bit of crunch! The food came pretty fresh and was clutch for being open late and still amazing. The breadsticks weren't the best. Kinda bland and the marinara didn't want to stick to the bread but otherwise I can't recommend this higher if you need pizza late at night!
I really like their slices. I go to the liquor store in the same parking lot to grab a beer, my wife and I get a few slices, and we eat in the car.
I walked in today and grabbed two slices: a cheese slice and a mushroom & pepperoni. I found it to be respectable slice-Great? No. But solid. Crust has that crunchy/chewy combo you know and expect from a NY slice. Cheese isn't too oily. The place has a neighborhood feel to it. The dude behind the counter didn't care who I was and I appreciate that. Good, not great. And who needs great anyways. I'm sick of people telling me "this is the greatest, you need to stand in line for an hour to get one though". And, I've stopped complaining about prices as long as the cost of a meal is under $20. Which it was. Good on you, Garage.
Best Pizza in Town by far. (period) Must try out pizza in Silverlake. Open Late, have slices, soft drinks and cookies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza Slices
I visit March 26, 1:00 am. Had a supreme slice. I told them i want to try the sauce and the guy gave me for free! It was amazing! The slice was verrrryyyyy big. Sometimes this slice somewhere elses whole pizza lol!The place is very good! You must visit and eat.The staff was very friendly and nice.My server looks like Pavarotti in 40s. I like that atmosphere. Kindly, thank you good sir.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
Do not respect autism people
it isnt lamonicas nor giordianos nor pizzeria uno nor amerigo vespucci's choice of pie were he to be reincarnated as an angelino in the modern era or reborn altogether nor is it a marco roma or a viccinos in chicago's north shore or a homemade pizza company that used to exist in winnetka until roughly 2016 when the owner mysterious vanished but they do offer an acceptable slice perhaps a little doughy not crispy enough maybe one day they will achieve the renown amerigo did and get two continents as namesake
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
Always slices to go. Wide variety and fast service. Parking out front and a chill vibe. Support local!
Great late night spot that serves NY style pizza at a great price! I got a whole pepperoni and it was delicious.
Amazing service. Kind and patient with me trying to make a decision. But I didn't really have to because they offer any slice on demand. It's sooo nice and clean in there as well. Definitely would come back again and again! Only deliemma is who to share all this goodness with. I literally chose this place on a whim after getting terrible service at a very near by vegan place. That's what happens when you smile, people order big and leave a tip!! The deserve to be packed and I'm sure they are in the evening.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good pizza, service, opening time, vegan options, thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice 9, Cheese Slice, Vegan Garage Pizza Slice, Veggie Sandwich, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
$35 for a pizza is madness. Have we all gone insane???
A really good NY style pizza. We got the white pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am from New Jersey where we know how to make a pizza. This is the closest thing to a New York or Jersey pizza! It is so good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
My first time here, wanted a pizza, so decided to try it out. I ordered a pizza, off the menu, expecting to pay around $20. It came to $38 plus change. I was, ok, I'm hungry, go for it. I was told it would be about. 15 minutes. 35 minutes later, I was given my pizza., by the person who took my order. I expressed my frustration, being told it would be 15 minutes. He did not apologize, but retorted , rather rudely that that is an approximate time., and there were other orders ahead me. 15 minutes and 35 minutes is outside approximate. Had he said it would be 30 minutes, I could have decided to wait or cancel my order. And again, rather than being apologetic, he was very rude. I doubt I will go back again. So, if you want an expensive pizza and rude service, this is the place to go,otherwise choose another option.Parking: Parking us adequate
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1