Cosentino's Pizza
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
About Cosentino's Pizza
Cosentino's Pizza Reviews
129 ratings
I tried the place out as its been a while and I was disappointed as the food quality is not anything near the Big O we have enjoyed for 40 plus years. We tried meatball sandwich it just didn't make us feel the same. The food is good but not the old Big O good.
Pizza was great, would highly recommend. High quality ingredients, everything is fresh and the service is absolutely amazing! The sandwich is really well priced and you get a lot of food. The food is just amazing.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Absolutely delicious!
We dined in and had an outstanding experience at Pizza Castello. The food was fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. The cheesy meatball sandwich was perfectly toasted and loaded with melted cheese and herbs—comfort food at its best. We also tried a few dessert pizzas, and they were truly unique. The Nutella and pistachio combinations were indulgent without being overly sweet, and the crust was light yet crisp.
The...read full review
Absolutely delicious!
We dined in and had an outstanding experience at Pizza Castello. The food was fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. The cheesy meatball sandwich was perfectly toasted and loaded with melted cheese and herbs—comfort food at its best. We also tried a few dessert pizzas, and they were truly unique. The Nutella and pistachio combinations were indulgent without being overly sweet, and the crust was light yet crisp.
The...read full review
Cosentino's Pizza is a friendly restaurant known for its welcoming owner and high school student staff. They serve quality pizza, including the Supreme XL, which has a good balance of toppings with little grease. The meatball sub is also popular. Customers praise the fresh, flavorful ingredients and generous portions, especially on dishes like the cheesy meatball sandwich and dessert pizzas with Nutella and pistachio. The service is friendly and efficient, creating a relaxed atmosphere for dining in. While there have been occasional issues with food quality, such as cold or doughy pizza, overall the restaurant offers a positive experience. Prices are reasonable for the quality, and it remains a beloved spot serving the community for many years.