The Cookie Plug
6193 Jarvis Ave, Newark
(510) 894-1320
Customers' Favorites
Cookies
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
It took me four visits to the Cookie Plug in order to develop this review– each visit was as harrowing as the last, but the fourth drove me away. While the cookies were amazing, the ambience was what frightened me. Each time that I attended this humble cookie joint, there was different staff present, but one manager always present. The manager was an older man, with clear signs of aging on his face and hands. Each rotating staff member always had a monotone voice and seemed...
Ordered on Door dash, but saw the site had a delivery option too. It took me time to figure out if these cookies were ok for kids and to find the ingredients. Website says these cookies are 100% kid friendly. The nutrition section on the website has the ingredients for each cookie. I wish finding this information was easier.We had the OG and nutty OG. Taste wise, they were just ok, nothing special. The OG was undercooked in my opinion. I had to put it in the oven again. I don't...
$5 per undercooked cookie. They're big, but not that big.Very sweet. Usually undercooked. After half dozen trips here just to try different flavors, I still haven't had a cookie that's been cooked all the way through. I guess some people prefer that? I do appreciate that the edges are chewy.Fancy boxes. Fancy decor - hellooo Yay Area Hip Hop?! (You'll understand when you walk in!) Big store for a bakery offering. Big selection of flavor options, some pretty...
You May Also Like
Tao's Fresh - 6185 Jarvis Ave
![]()
Asian, Asian Fusion, Bubble Tea, Barbeque
Subway - 6179 Jarvis Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Kong Sarang Tofu & BBQ - 6180 Jarvis Ave suite a
![]()
Korean, Barbeque, Noodles